Riley Fibbers, an East Islip restaurant, was damaged when Paul...

Riley Fibbers, an East Islip restaurant, was damaged when Paul Lucia set fire to it after he was asked to leave.  Credit: Joseph Sperber

A 61-year-old Islip Terrace man has been sentenced to 10 years in prison after pleading guilty to setting fire to the doorway of an East Islip restaurant-bar last fall after being asked by the staff to leave.

The Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office said Paul Lucia was sentenced Tuesday, having pleaded guilty to second-degree and third-degree arson and other related charges last month.

In his plea allocution, Lucia admitted having "deliberately" set the fire after being asked to leave Riley Fibbers.

The incident occurred last Nov. 20. Authorities said Lucia had been asked to leave after having taken a picture of one of the staff members and said he left the premises at about 5:30 p.m. in a white Jeep Patriot, only to return about two hours later with a can of gasoline and a lighter.

Video surveillance footage showed Lucia getting out of the Jeep, then dumping "liquid from the gas can near the rear entrance of the restaurant," the district attorney’s office said in a statement Tuesday.

The restaurant was open at the time and occupied by both staff and patrons, the district attorney’s office said. The fire caused damage to the outside awning and the kitchen. No one was injured.

Fleeing the scene, Lucia tossed the gas can over a fence. It was later recovered.

A witness recorded the license plate of the Jeep and provided it to responding police. The plates had been reported stolen about a week before, authorities later discovered.

Suffolk police located Lucia during a traffic stop the following day on Sunrise Highway and he was arrested.

In a statement issued Tuesday, Suffolk District Attorney Ray Tierney said: "What began as a simple request for the defendant to leave the premises escalated into an unwarranted and dangerous act of arson."

What's in store with the weather ... The hottest gifts for 2026 ... AI giving young basketball players a boost Credit: Newsday

October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather

What's in store with the weather ... The hottest gifts for 2026 ... AI giving young basketball players a boost Credit: Newsday

October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME