Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney discusses the case last...

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney discusses the case last year. Credit: Joseph Sperber

A former U.S. postal worker from Mastic Beach has pleaded guilty to stealing gift cards, greeting cards and lottery tickets from outgoing mail addressed to at least seven people, Suffolk County prosecutors said Monday.

Jonanni Jamison-Lewis, 36, was arrested in November 2025 by the Postal Service Inspector General’s Office and investigators with the Suffolk district attorney's office in connection with the thefts while she worked at the Oakdale post office. The items stolen from envelopes included a T.J. Maxx gift card worth $175 and another greeting card containing three New York Lottery scratch-off tickets, Suffolk prosecutors said.

Jamison-Lewis would open greeting cards to remove the gift cards or lotto tickets and then place the cards back into the outgoing mail sorting bin, according to prosecutors. Authorities used video surveillance that showed her using the stolen T.J. Maxx gift card at a store in Port Jefferson Station to buy jewelry, clothing and a handbag, prosecutors said.

She pleaded guilty Friday to nine counts each of felony grand larceny and felony criminal possession of stolen property, as well as two misdemeanors. 

Following Jamison-Lewis's arrest, investigators found four pieces of stolen mail inside her wallet and valuables she had bought with the gift cards. A search warrant at her home and vehicle found 20 other pieces of stolen mail, including more than $800 worth of gift cards, prosecutors said.

"People trust the Postal Service to deliver their mail safely and securely, not to have envelopes picked through and contents stolen," Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney said in a statement. "This defendant betrayed that trust for her own benefit, and her guilty plea makes clear that abusing a position of public trust comes with consequences."

Jamison-Lewis resigned from the Postal Service on Dec. 1, 2025, about a week after her arrest.

She is scheduled to be sentenced Jan. 11.

Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Biggest health insurance hike in decades ... Which NY colleges have highest earnings for grads Credit: Newsday

Updated 7 minutes ago 'Honor Wall' unveiled for fallen Suffolk officers ... Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Dems declare victory in Hempstead race ... Village eyes limits on chain stores

Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Biggest health insurance hike in decades ... Which NY colleges have highest earnings for grads Credit: Newsday

Updated 7 minutes ago 'Honor Wall' unveiled for fallen Suffolk officers ... Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Dems declare victory in Hempstead race ... Village eyes limits on chain stores

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME