Supporters, opponents of New York's Scaffold Law gear up for battle

Large scaffolding on East 77th Street on the Upper East Side for a residential building under construction. Credit: Newsday/Edward B. Colby.
Critics and proponents of a 140-year-old, only-in-New York law that holds property owners and contractors responsible for all falls on construction sites, even if the worker was negligent, are gearing up for a battle that could shape the direction — and price tag — of development across the state.
At stake: the future of the 1885 Scaffold Law, which supporters contend keeps workers safe on some of the most dangerous job sites in the nation, while opponents argue it has drastically raised the price to build statewide, largely due to elevated insurance costs.
'Outdated' law
In the wake of the November election, in which Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul won another four-year term, housing and construction groups have intensified a lobbying and public relations campaign to overhaul the law, releasing reports showing its effect on the development industry and meeting with the governor and her top aides on the issue, according to public records and advocates familiar with the issue.
Meanwhile, some labor unions, the state Trial Lawyers Association and law firms that file many Scaffold Law claims are publicly pushing back against changes, utilizing a pair of recent deadly construction accidents in Brooklyn and on the Loop Parkway bridge as proof the law must remain unchanged.
For her part, Hochul has yet to show her hand.
"The governor is always looking for ways to improve how New York builds, but there is no proposal to announce on scaffold law requirements," said spokesperson Kristin Devoe. "As always, she’ll lay out her policy agenda in January."
Unlike her predecessor, former Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo, who steered clear of the politically charged issue, Hochul has appeared willing to engage in discussions about the Scaffold Law, particularly after enacting sweeping auto insurance fraud reforms over the summer, according to industry officials who've taken part in the conversations.
"New Yorkers have made it clear that affordability must be a top priority," said Michael Florio, chief executive of the Long Island Builders Institute, a nonprofit trade association. "Reforming New York’s outdated and costly Scaffold Law would be a meaningful step toward reducing construction costs, making housing more affordable, and helping us build the homes New Yorkers desperately need."
For years, the Scaffold Law, which exists only in the Big Apple, has been a "white whale" of sorts for developers and the construction industry, which contend it's responsible for insurance costs skyrocketing 500% higher than in other states, while driving up the price of affordable housing and construction of publicly funded projects.
They also argue the law has been exploited by individuals — working with a network of lawyers and doctors, many of whom live or work on the Island — who, authorities contend, stage accidents, fabricate injuries and subject themselves to unnecessary surgeries to collect large payouts.
Disincentivizing 'bad behavior'
But supporters of the law argue that its "absolute liability" standard is critical in holding employers and property owners liable for unsafe conditions and that eliminating those protections would put lives at risk.
"If the industry groups push hard [for change], we'll push harder," said Charlene Obernauer, executive director of the New York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health, a nonprofit organization with offices in Hauppauge that advocates for workplace safety. "Workers are put in some of the most dangerous circumstances without any power to change their conditions to make it safer for themselves. So to disincentivize bad behavior, we continue to support scaffold safety laws."
To date, legislative efforts to overhaul or repeal the Scaffold Law have failed, with resistance largely coming from city Democrats in both chambers, who've consistently expressed support for the bill's protections.
For example, a bill introduced in January by Assemb. Andrew Molitor, an upstate Republican, to fully repeal the Scaffold Law never moved out of committee. Molitor told Newsday he plans to reintroduce the bill in the next legislative session.
But advocates see a window of opportunity after state lawmakers passed changes pushed by Hochul that cap damages and enable prosecutors to seek criminal penalties against individuals involved in auto insurance fraud. The changes could lower auto insurance rates by as much as 10% for New York drivers, according to some estimates.
"Voters handed Democrats a mandate to make life more affordable," said Tom Stebbins, executive director at the Lawsuit Reform Alliance of New York. "Fixing the liability laws that increase the cost of everything should be at the top of Albany's agenda in 2027."
A recent statewide survey of general-election voters, including those on Long Island, commissioned by the Albany-based Empire Center for Public Policy, a conservative-leaning think tank, showed widespread support for retooling the Scaffold Law.
Earlier this month, Enterprise Community Partners, a national housing nonprofit overseeing about 200 properties in New York, released a report that found insurance costs for affordable housing have jumped 169% since 2018, in large part due to the Scaffold Law.
The report cites data from the Building Trades Employers’ Association, which found the Scaffold Law was responsible for New York insurance costs representing 8-10% of development budgets, compared to 2-4% in neighboring states.
"These costs are driving distress in New York’s vital affordable housing stock, eating up expense budgets that should be going to repairs, staffing, and resident services, and putting upward pressure on rents," said Patrick Boyle, co-author of the report and senior director at Enterprise.
Attorney Charles Pierce Jr., head of the Construction Department at Rosenberg & Estis, a Manhattan law firm, said his clients, including construction firms on Long Island, have struggled to obtain affordable insurance on projects. One client, he said, was forced to close its doors after it couldn't obtain insurance following a roofing accident.
"The cost of the insurance each year is going up so much," said Pierce, who lives in Huntington. "And the more dangerous the work, obviously the more the insurance goes up. There aren't as many insurers as there used to be. No one really wants to write [policies] in New York. And then of the few left, to the extent they write, it's very expensive."
Changes to face resistance
Legislative changes are likely to face stiff resistance from entrenched and formidable interests in the city and in Albany, experts say.
"Changes to the legislation will only empower unscrupulous actors who already take advantage of their workers by failing to establish the safety measures necessary to prevent harm at their construction sites," said Gary LaBarbera, president of the NYS Building & Construction Trades Council. "Perpetuating this behavior and opening the door for more accidents will only hurt workers, hinder key projects, and discourage critical job development."
The Scaffold Law also has strong supporters among those with influence at City Hall.
Ali Najmi serves as special counsel to the Liakas Law firm, which has been accused in federal racketeering suits of recruiting individuals, including those from Freeport, to stage accidents at locations across the city. The firm has denied the claims. Najmi also serves as chair of Mayor Zohran Mamdani's Advisory Committee on the Judiciary.
Last week, Najmi posted on X that the scaffolding collapse on the Loop Parkway bridge, which killed one worker and left another missing, and a building collapse in Brooklyn, which claimed the lives of six adults and two children, are why the Scaffold Law should be protected.
"In one day a building collapses in Brooklyn and scaffolding collapses in Nassau," Najmi wrote. "Death and multiple injured in both accidents. We need to strengthen worker safety laws. Protect the Scaffold Law. The people who build New York are not expendable."
The mayor's office did not respond to requests for comment on potential Scaffold Law changes.
