Ask the Expert: Can after-tax contributions to a tax-deferred retirement account be withdrawn first?
You’ve written that after-tax contributions to a tax-deferred retirement account can be withdrawn tax-free, even though their earnings are taxable when withdrawn. I’ve made about $25,000 of after-tax IRA contributions over the years. When I retire, can I take out that tax-free $25,000 as my first withdrawal?
No. You can’t remove your after-tax contributions in a lump sum. They must be withdrawn on a pro-rata, or proportional, basis.
You get no tax deduction for an after-tax contribution. If you earn $75,000 a year and make a $6,500 after-tax IRA contribution, for example, your taxable income is still $75,000. The trade-off: that $6,500 is tax-free when you withdraw it.
The after-tax contribution comes out pro rata: If your IRA balance is $100,000 and you made $6,500 in after-tax contributions, 6.5% of each withdrawal is tax free.
“Making non-deductible IRA contributions is like adding cream to a cup of coffee. There’s going to be a little cream in every sip you take — you can’t remove it separately,” said Ed Slott, a Rockville Centre tax accountant.
Non-deductible IRA contributions originally were made mostly by people who didn’t qualify to make deductible contributions. But today, they’re often used as a “back door” into a Roth IRA by people whose high earnings disqualify them from contributing directly to a Roth. There’s no earnings limit on converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, and it’s perfectly legal to build a traditional IRA with non-deductible contributions and then convert it to a Roth IRA.
But if you’re converting a traditional IRA that includes both deductible and non-deductible contributions, you must follow the pro-rata rule to calculate the tax on the conversion.
The bottom line:
Your non-deductible IRA contributions are tax-free when you withdraw them in retirement, but you can’t withdraw them in a single lump sum distribution.
More information:
Full coverage of the winter storm from NewsdayTV The NewsdayTV team was across Long Island monitoring the winter weather and what's next.
Full coverage of the winter storm from NewsdayTV The NewsdayTV team was across Long Island monitoring the winter weather and what's next.
