Long Island

Newsday Endorsements Story Gallery 2011

Town of Hempstead Supervisor <a href="/topics/Kate_Murray">Kate Murray</a> runs a tight fiscal ship. In a time of falling sales- and mortgage-tax revenues, her 2012 budget is balanced without a property tax increase. By reducing the workforce through attrition, she doesn't have to make layoffs or cut services now that hard times are here. 
 What Murray, 49, of <a href="/topics/Levittown%2C_NY">Levittown</a>, hasn't been able to do in her four terms is cut the many layers of patronage that the Republican Party demands of elected officials in its historic base, a town Republicans have run for 110 years. That flaw has led to the greatest embarrassment of Murray's tenure: poor conditions at the town's animal shelter, which has a budget of $7 million a year. High salaries for those with political connections but not the proper work credentials have led to continued protests by animal-rights activists, a criminal investigation by the county district attorney and a financial audit by the state comptroller. Murray, whose weak excuse is that no one told her of any problems, seems to have put a skilled staff in place at last. 
 Democratic challenger Gary Port, 49, a lawyer from <a href="/topics/West_Hempstead%2C_NY">West Hempstead</a>, says he would work to modernize the zoning laws to jump-start the economy and fill vacant storefronts. Port, a local business leader, scoutmaster and youth baseball coach, has served 25 years in the military. A lieutenant colonel in the <a href="/topics/United_States_Military_Academy">Army</a> Reserve, Port is the legal adviser to the 78th Division commander. Port has made the animal shelter a key issue, but he doesn't offer any transformative ideas for the town or have the executive experience to manage such a large local government. Newsday endorses Murray. hN

Opinion

VPHEMSUP

Murray for Hempstead supervisor

0LU2377C.JPG

When Bill Wilkinson took over as <a href="/topics/East_Hampton%2C_NY">East Hampton</a> Town supervisor in 2010, the community's finances were a shambles. 
 A town of just 22,000 year-round residents -- give or take a few movie stars -- was facing a $27-million deficit in its $70-million annual budget, and a grand jury reported that the town had experienced a "complete collapse of fiscal management." 
 Since then, Wilkinson, a 62-year-old Republican from <a href="/topics/Montauk%2C_NY">Montauk</a> and former senior vice president of human resources at <a href="/topics/Disney_Channel">Walt Disney</a> Co., has made remarkable strides toward cleaning up the mess left by his precessor. In just a single term of office, he's reduced the number of full-time employees from a peak of 411 to around 320. He also cut in half the number of town departments, consolidating 26 into 13, and worked with union leaders so that employees could be deployed flexibly in different jobs at different times of year. He underspent the 2010 budget by a remarkable $8 million. 
 Wilkinson's challenger this year is Zachary Cohen, a 62-year-old community activist and real estate investor from <a href="/topics/Springs%2C_NY">Springs</a> with a strong business background of his own. Cohen, who is not a member of any political party, has made a specialty of environmental and budgetary issues. Clearly, he cares about the community. 
 But Wilkinson's track record speaks for itself. The incumbent has brought tremendous skill and energy to a difficult task, and it makes no sense to change leadership at this point, now that he's got the town back on the rails. 
 Newsday endorses Wilkinson. hN

VPEHSUP

Editorial: Re-elect Wilkinson in E. Hampton

0LU235BC.JPG

Supervisor <a href="/topics/John_Venditto">John Venditto</a> says Oyster Bay must continue to deliver the suburban dream of one-family homes, good schools and fine beaches that has made the town a magnet for more than six decades. The Republican's philosophy is not to change anything, and that message has gotten him elected seven times by overwhelming majorities. 
Absent a demand for a change, Venditto's opponents have had a difficult time setting an agenda. Democratic challenger John Capobianco, 47, is a voice for residents who might harbor dreams of new vitality in the town's stagnant downtowns, such as <a href="/topics/Hicksville%2C_NY">Hicksville</a>. Capobianco lives in the Village of <a href="/topics/Farmingdale%2C_NY">Farmingdale</a> and is a member of its downtown revitalization committee, which has developed a comprehensive plan that includes housing above stores on Main Street. A member of the Farmingdale school board, Capobianco is a martial arts and bonsai artisan who sought an Assembly seat last year. 
Capobianco blames Venditto for the recent lowering of the town's bond rating due to the drawing down of reserve funds and the lack of a financial plan to raise revenue. He says overspending on patronage jobs, especially for the largest town public safety force on <a href="/topics/Long_Island%2C_NY">Long Island</a>, is wasteful. Valid criticisms, but the Democrat doesn't have the necessary managerial experience to run the town. 
Venditto, 62, of <a href="/topics/North_Massapequa%2C_NY">North Massapequa</a>, says the town's debt is moderate and that he will tighten spending by reducing overtime costs. Instead of a tax increase, he's considering raising revenue by increasing user fees for parking and recreational activities. With the promise of a renewed focus on maintaining fiscal integrity, Newsday endorses Venditto. hN

VPOBSUP

Editorial: Re-elect Venditto in Oyster Bay

poCOL

Every town on <a href="/topics/Long_Island%2C_NY">Long Island</a> has problems, but the Town of Riverhead has one problem that should be easily remedied: the term of its town supervisor is just two years. Some other towns have sensibly adopted four-year terms, and Riverhead should do the same.
That would take voter approval, yet the question isn't on the ballot this year. So why does it matter now? The issue is continuity, which makes it crucially important to the question of who should be elected town supervisor in the upcoming election. A two-year term makes it too difficult to take an appropriately long-term view of such matters as what to do with the 2,900-acre <a href="/topics/Calverton%2C_NY">Calverton</a> property known as EPCAL. 
<a href="/topics/Phil_Cardinale">Phil Cardinale</a>, the 62-year-old Democratic challenger from <a href="/topics/Jamesport%2C_NY">Jamesport</a>, served three terms as town supervisor until his narrow defeat two years ago by Sean Walter, a 45-year-old Republican from <a href="/topics/Wading_River%2C_NY">Wading River</a>. Both men are intelligent, experienced attorneys who've done a decent job running their fractious town. And both have notable weaknesses. Neither is the best consensus-builder in the world. Both have hurled ugly charges at one another.
During his tenure, <a href="/topics/Phil_Cardinale">Cardinale</a> and others laid the groundwork for much of the downtown revival now under way. He was decisive in heading off a fiscal disaster mushrooming from the town's landfill. 
But Walter has successfully continued and expanded the downtown renaissance, working closely with business and cheerleading at every opportunity. Riverhead, a town with too much turmoil and turnover, needs continuity. Newsday endorses Walter. hN

VPRIVSUP

Editorial: Re-elect Walter in Riverhead

0LTYEOOC.JPG

Dominating the <a href="/topics/North_Fork%2C_NY">North Fork</a>, Southold Town is home to all the competing interests of recreation, wine-making, residents and vacationers. The best town supervisor is one who can balance those conflicts. 
 As supervisor, Republican Scott Russell, 47, of <a href="/topics/Cutchogue%2C_NY">Cutchogue</a>, seems to have many issues well in hand. His $38.8-million budget stays within the 2 percent property tax cap; he negotiated more modest contracts with town workers and police; he has an economic development commission examining ways to attract tenants to abandoned commercial spaces; and he is grappling with the perennial <a href="/topics/North_Fork%2C_NY">North Fork</a> problems of loud parties and post-wine-tasting drunken driving. 
 The Democratic challenger is Robert Meguin, 63, a Southold lawyer who has been a top legal aide to three judges and now runs his own general practice. Meguin is critical of the town budget, noting four consecutive tax increases, and a tax base that has eroded by more than 13 percent since 2008. 
 Both candidates are rightly concerned about the growing traffic congestion, and would support a separate transportation authority for the East End. Russell is correct to be pessimistic about wresting funding from the <a href="/topics/Metropolitan_Transportation_Authority">Metropolitan Transportation Authority</a>. He paints a vision of light rail cars running on existing tracks, and commissioning bus and shuttle services. 
 Meguin called the Southold Town Board "anti-business" and said he would take a lighter hand with the <a href="/topics/North_Fork%2C_NY">North Fork</a> vineyards and their expansion ideas. However, it's a fine line when there's a growing drunken-driving problem. For striking a reasonable balance as well as his other accomplishments, Newsday endorses Russell.

VPHOLDSUP

Scott Russell for Southold supervisor

scott russell

Too often in past years, serious questions of how to govern the huge and still-growing Town of Brookhaven have taken a backseat to partisan bickering. Happily, that has changed. And this year's election for supervisor offers hope that the new calm can continue. 
 Both the incumbent, Democrat Mark Lesko, and his Republican challenger, M. Cecile Forte, are serious, high-quality candidates who focus intelligently on the issues. 
 Lesko, 44, of <a href="/topics/East_Setauket%2C_NY">East Setauket</a>, won a special election in March 2009 against Tim Mazzei, the leader of the town board's Republican majority. That November, he defeated Martin Haley, the town's buildings and fire prevention commissioner, for a full two-year term. 
 Lesko's political deftness in naming Kathleen Walsh, a Republican councilwoman, as his deputy, plus a commendable spirit of cooperation by Mazzei, led to calmer times. 
 Forte, 65, of <a href="/topics/Port_Jefferson%2C_NY">Port Jefferson</a>, served 31 years as a professor and administrator at <a href="/topics/Suffolk_County%2C_NY">Suffolk</a> County Community College. She's deputy chair of the planning board, which she chaired in 2005. She narrowly lost a 2009 race for town clerk. 
 One of Lesko's key initiatives has been Blight to Light, a campaign to revitalize eyesores. The most visible has been his effort to convert the dreary streetscape near the <a href="/topics/Ronkonkoma%2C_NY">Ronkonkoma</a> <a href="/topics/Long_Island_Rail_Road">Long Island Rail Road</a> station into a real downtown, with residences, restaurants and shops. Forte supports the idea. 
 Lesko was a key player in launching Accelerate <a href="/topics/Long_Island%2C_NY">Long Island</a>, a still-evolving initiative that aims to keep high-tech firms here. He played a positive role in the development of a plan to protect the headwaters of the Carmans River. But he faces opposition from environmentalists over development in the area. He'll have to work hard to strike a balance between the environment and the economy there. 
 Forte considers preserving our water second only to job creation. She wants to make the town more business-friendly, with a customer-service attitude. 
 She has lived in Brookhaven since 1970, and she has an admirable personal passion for it. Forte has a solid grasp of the issues, but she disagrees with Lesko on few of them. As impressive as she is, she did not make a compelling case for replacing an effective incumbent. Newsday endorses Lesko.

VPBRSUP

Newsday endorses Lesko for Brookhaven supervisor

0LTR0HRC.JPG

Political, polished, confident and aggressive, <a href="/topics/North_Hempstead%2C_NY">North Hempstead</a> Supervisor <a href="/topics/Jon_Kaiman">Jon Kaiman</a>'s governing style is bold, and he manages his town well. The budget always balances and services are delivered competently. What's more, Kaiman, a 49-year-old Democrat who lives in <a href="/topics/Great_Neck%2C_NY">Great Neck</a> Village, never settles for a stay-the-course routine. Instead, he seeks improvement and innovation for his town with a devotion bordering on the fanatical. 
 His opponent, 36-year-old Republican Lee Tu, is a political comer with a grassroots approach who sought the job in 2009 as well. Tu, a senior audit manager from <a href="/topics/Albertson%2C_NY">Albertson</a>, cares about the community. At the same time, he seems to portray relatively minor issues as major battles to paint Kaiman as an out-of-touch executive who discounts the needs of certain neighborhoods and constituencies, a charge that does not resonate. 
 In fact, Kaiman has shown the detail-oriented tenacity to keep improving on his past innovations, like the town's 311 call-answering system. At the same time, he is continuing to introduce vital programs. Perhaps the most impressive is a new initiative that eliminated lightly used town buses meant to transport senior citizens. Now, taxis take the seniors when they wish; the town pays half, the senior pays half, saving the town hundreds of thousands of dollars and helping thousands of seniors. Kaiman steadily seems to be getting better: He has, over his four terms, become less abrasive, more inclusive and a better communicator, while continuing to brandish the intellectual power and ambition to better his town. Newsday endorses Kaiman.

VPNHEMSUP

Re-elect Jon Kaiman in North Hempstead

0LSVBO6C.JPG

This is the first editorial board endorsement for 2011. 
 &nbsp; 
 When he was first elected supervisor in 2006, Phil Nolan faced the challenge of setting the Town of Islip on a steadier course after the campaign-funds scandal that sent his predecessor, Peter McGowan, to prison. 
 Since then, Nolan, 61, a <a href="/topics/U.S._Democratic_Party">Democrat</a> from the hamlet of Islip, has maintained a firm hand on the wheel of government. He deserves re-election. 
 Nolan's accomplishments are many: He trimmed the town workforce from 1,029 year-round positions in 2007 to about 730; saved $6.5 million in three years (and won a national award) by tightening oversight of workers' compensation; won federal funds to renovate the vital Maple Avenue ferry dock and expand parking; cut overtime costs for snow removal by preparing streets with a brine coating before storms; reduced the number of town vehicles allowed for personal use of employees; and eliminated health plans for officials working on town boards. 
 In five budgets, Nolan raised town taxes by 2.9 percent in 2008, 1.87 percent in 2009, and has kept them flat ever since. 
 His opponent, <a href="/topics/U.S._Republican_Party">Republican</a> Tom Croci, 39, of <a href="/topics/Bohemia%2C_NY">Bohemia</a>, is on a leave of absence from his job as district director for Sen. <a href="/topics/Lee_Zeldin">Lee Zeldin</a> (R-<a href="/topics/Shirley%2C_NY">Shirley</a>) and has an impressive background as a businessman, lawyer, naval reserve lieutenant commander with two tours of <a href="/topics/Afghanistan">Afghanistan</a> and service in the White House situation room under President <a href="/topics/George_W._Bush">George W. Bush</a>. But he lacks the experience in local government required to be supervisor. 
 In an interview, Croci correctly identified the town's biggest challenges, including developing <a href="/topics/Long_Island%2C_NY">Long Island</a> MacArthur Airport, working with neighboring town officials to improve the <a href="/topics/Ronkonkoma%2C_NY">Ronkonkoma</a> railroad hub, and monitoring the proposed Heartland Town Square at the Pilgrim Psychiatric Center. On the latter project, in particular, Croci impatiently blamed Nolan and "politics" for delays, but could not provide specifics. Nolan, meanwhile, explained that the multi-use proposal, including 9,300 apartments on 451 acres, is overly ambitious, and he is pushing the developer to pledge to pay expenses, including widening of roads to handle greater traffic. That determined pressure and his fiscal leadership are the kind of stewardship needed to protect the interests of residents. 
 Newsday endorses Nolan for supervisor.

VPISSUP

Phil Nolan for Islip supervisor

0LTMWIKC.JPG

Newsday endorsements 2011

Newsday

Newsday endorsement logo cropped

Most Popular

NEWSDAY TV SHORTS

Vertical videos

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa stops by Smokin' Al's in Massapequa to try their oversized nachos, known as Macho Nachos.

Trendy Bites: 'Macho Nachos' at Smokin' Al's

From a surf lesson to eating along the boardwalk, Newsday travel writer Carissa Kellman explores Rockaway Beach.

Surf’s up: Best waves, best bites in Rockaway Beach 

NewsdayTV's Doug Geed takes us out to East Hampton, where an old farm turned arts center hosts community events.

Out East: Duck Creek Arts Center

The consequences depend less on the alleged crime than on the county where police make the arrest. Newsday political reporter Bahar Ostadan has the story.

Women arrested at illicit spas in Nassau risk deportation, but not in Suffolk

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa visits Macchiato Espresso Bar in Mattituck to learn the art of the latte.

LI Works: Whole latte love goes into this art

Stretches of forest are turning into lifeless tree trunks, known as ghost forests, as salt water intrusion destroys the soil. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie has more.

Climate change creating ‘ghost forests’ on Long Island 

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano tries a Hyrox fitness class at Black Bear Athletics in West Babylon.

Why Hyrox is trending on Long Island

Matthew Smith sentenced to up to 22 years in prison for drunken-driving crash that killed Nassau County Police Officer Patricia Espinosa. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie has more.

Man who drove drunk and killed Nassau police officer gets up to 22 years in prison

From pizza to clams, Newsday food writer Andi Berlin visits two restaurants that are on the way to Northwell at Jones Beach Theater.

Eats en route to Jones Beach

Former Holy Trinity lineman Lance Swift spoke with Newsday high school sports reporter Jared Valluzzi after the Titans suspended their football program.

Former Holy Trinity lineman reflects on football program suspension

Latest Videos

Latest videos

Seth Kurpiel, who suffered a broken neck in 2025, reconnected with the medical professionals who helped him get back on his feet. NewsdayTV's Andrew Ehinger has more.

'The impossible is possible'

The end of the program could send thousands back to Haiti, which has been severely afflicted with gang violence, political instability and displacement. NewsdayTV's Shari Einhorn has more.

'They can't survive'

Wednesday commemmorated the 100th anniversary of Babe Ruth catching a baseball dropped from a plane at Mitchel Field in Uniondale. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa has more.

'I wish I was around here to see it'

Bay Shore residents voice concern over plan to turn former Monfort Missionaries seminary into an Islamic boarding school. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

'You're in the middle of a residential area'

'Nothing is going to bring my wife back'

Sign up for the NewsdayTV newsletter

Long Island Newsletter Widget

The pool is aimed at teaching kids to swim and preventing drownings, officials said.

Swimming pool at Jones Beach reopens after 17 years, $100M renovation

Long Island Article Bottom Module

"This was dilapidated for 40 years. And now ... we think it's beautiful," the principal at B2K Development said.

Less than 2 years after construction wrapped, former Long Beach Superblock is almost fully occupied

The village will borrow $275,000 to pay for a court award to Sharon Abramski, who had been fired from her job as clerk-treasurer.

Manorhaven to borrow to cover judgment for former employee

County officials stripped Dana Spagnuolo of her job duties and then fired her in November 2024 because she participated in investigations into crime lab employees conducted by state and county inspectors general, court papers say.

Lawsuit: Ex-Nassau medical examiner worker subject of 'harassment' for talking to investigators

The retailer will lease a 414,000-square-foot warehouse under construction in Yaphank as part of a broader effort to expand its North American supply chain.

Home Depot plans massive LI warehouse

Hospital executives announced Monday a $110 million shortfall in its pool of money held in the captive to settle malpractice claims.

Why did NUMC run its own insurance plan in the Cayman Islands?

A lawyer for the former CEO rejected allegations of mismanagement as "wildly off base."

NUMC: Former leaders failed to set aside enough for malpractice claims

Long Island Video Playlist

There is a new push to look into the effect of screen time in classrooms. NewsdayTV's Shari Einhorn spoke to Newsday state reporter Keshia Clukey and other experts on the topic.

'I don't advocate for one blanket policy'

Two months into the state's "bell-to-bell" ban on electronic devices in schools, some districts are reporting positive changes in the classroom. NewsdayTV's Andrew Ehinger reports.

'Students are much more talkative to one another'

NewsdayTV's Jasmine Anderson and Newsday education reporter Dandan Zou talk to Long Island school administrators about how the school cellphone ban is going so far.

'Kids are outside. They're playing. They're laughing together.'

Homeowners say their taxes make it almost unaffordable to live on Long Island. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa sat down with Newsday towns reporter Sam Kmack to learn more about residents who are taking action.

'Homeowners are under real financial pressure'

Following two days of hazy skies from the Canadian wildfire smoke, NewsdayTV meteorologist Geoff Bansen has a look at what the weekend weather will look like.

Long Island weather: Expect bluer skies this afternoon

An arbitrator detailed ex-officer George Trimigliozzi's poor job performance before his high-profile criminal case. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie and Newsday investigative reporter Jim Baumbach has more.

'He really wasn't being a police officer'

NewsdayTV goes behind the scenes of the day Rex Heuermann was sentenced for the Gilgo killings.

'A million years isn't enough'

The hazy skies are hanging around Long Island Thursday as smoke from the Canadian wildfires continues to fill the air.

Long Island weather: When will smoke, heat go away?

'Honestly, I was hurt'

A heat advisory remains in effect on Long Island through late Thursday. NewsdayTV's meteorologist Geoff Bansen has the forecast.

Canadian wildfire smoke could impact Long Island

Vincent Puleo, who's worked in public office for nearly two decades, terminated the spa's lease following Newsday's reporting. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie talks with Newsday reporters Sandra Peddie and Bahar Ostadan about the story.

'They dabble in other stuff behind the covers'

Police are only addressing the supply, but demand is what fuels the illicit sex trade, experts say. Newsday political reporter Bahar Ostadan has the story.

'If you don't address demand, you don't address the problem'

Homepage Trending

Cyclospora: How to protect yourself

Wallet Watch

FeedMe Magazine

Summer Fun Book

<a href="https://www.newsday.com/video/newsdaytv-top-stories">Get more on these and other NewsdayTV stories</a>

Newsday TV

NewsdayTV Top Item

A Newsday review of court records sheds new light on ICE's Long Island operation and where it's happening. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa, Shari Einhorn, investigative reporter Josefa Velásquez and attorney Reuben Kerben break it down.

'The strategy that I'm seeing ... is very chaotic'

App Nativo Ad Unit Slot

Long Island - megaslot

Follow all the latest news on Long Island with Newsday. Read top local stories, watch video, and see pictures from all around Nassau and Suffolk counties.

Most Popular

Latest Videos

Stay logged in.