What to make of Suffolk Democrats' losses? Infighting, poor organizing and patronage, critics say.

Members of the Suffolk County Democratic Committee, led by Rich Schaffer (at podium), at their election night watch party at IBEW in Holtsville on Nov. 3. Credit: Randee Daddona
Democrats won big in Mississippi, Texas and Kansas.
Suffolk was another matter.
Now many Suffolk Democrats are seething over what they see as a squandered chance to capitalize on voter frustration with President Donald Trump and Republicans, blaming a county committee they say pulled their punches, trading electoral victories for protecting patronage jobs.
In the county clerk's race, Democrats didn't have a challenger on the ballot because the county committee this summer pushed out its candidate. In the other countywide race, for comptroller, the Democratic candidate came within one point of winning, despite being outspent by the Republican, $973,278 to $30,494, according to preliminary numbers.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- Some Suffolk Democrats are seething over what they see as a squandered chance to capitalize on voter frustration with President Donald Trump, blaming a county committee they say pulled their punches to protect patronage jobs.
- Democratic Chairman Rich Schaffer said members of the party should celebrate the victories, and promised to build the party toward future elections, while GOP Chairman Jesse Garcia boasted the "blue tsunami" ran into a "big red brick wall."
- Democratic critics say the results were emblematic of lackluster infrastructure in the county committee and cross-party dealmaking.
In the 2nd Assembly, 5th Assembly and 3rd Senate districts, Democratic so-called "paper candidates," who didn't campaign, still managed to get 40% of the vote. And two Democratic challengers came within razor-thin margins of unseating incumbent Republican Congress members who had won by double digits two years ago, with one campaign noting national Democrats and the county committee spent little money helping them.
The results were emblematic of what critics say has been both lackluster infrastructure in the county committee and cross-party dealmaking that's central to the intraparty power struggle that ensued over the past year, according to interviews with committee members, candidates and elected officials.
This will probably have been the most Democratic-friendly environment that certainly we've seen in a generation.
— Ken Colón, Islip Town Democratic Committee member
"Definite missed opportunity," said Ken Colón, an Islip Town Democratic Committee member who managed Democrat Josh Slaughter’s successful campaign in the 3rd Assembly District, one of a handful of State Senate, Assembly and town supervisor wins Democrats were able to notch. "This will probably have been the most Democratic-friendly environment that certainly we've seen in a generation."
Gov. Kathy Hochul, for instance, narrowly won Suffolk County over Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, according to unofficial results, after losing by more than 16 points in the 2022 race against former Rep. Lee Zeldin.
In a message to Democrats after the election, Democratic Chairman Rich Schaffer, who successfully fought off a leadership challenge in September, said members of the party should "celebrate these victories and recognize the tremendous work that went into achieving them."
He also said the party "is committed to building a stronger, more engaged, and more connected Democratic organization across our county" and will be launching new initiatives that will support town committees and build a foundation for 2027 and 2028.
He said that includes expanded outreach, investing in new leaders, strengthening relationships, bringing in new voices and "giving people meaningful opportunities to participate throughout the year."
"I am committed to building an organization that brings people together, listens to their concerns, develops leaders and remains active in the communities we serve," he said.
Schaffer and Bryan Sokolowski, political director for Suffolk Democrats, did not respond to additional questions or multiple interview requests about the election results and discontent among some party members.
County GOP Chairman Jesse Garcia, meanwhile, boasted to supporters after the election that when the "blue tsunami" came to Suffolk County, it ran into a "big red brick wall," echoing a phrase he first used in the 2018 election. Republicans, however, were unable to knock off any Suffolk incumbents in the State Assembly and Senate and suffered losses in Senate District 1 and Assembly Districts 3 and 12.
I am committed to building an organization that brings people together, listens to their concerns, develops leaders and remains active in the communities we serve.
— Rich Schaffer, Suffolk Democratic County Committee chair
In an interview, Garcia said Suffolk ended up "redder than Texas and Kansas" and "accomplished the mission" of reelecting both members of Congress and picking up a countywide seat through the work of its committee members over 11 months. He credited the committee people who helped volunteer on campaigns to get out the vote. He said those volunteers are embedded in their communities and local organizations and put in the work of knocking on doors to reach voters.
"Our committee people are the difference," he said.
Empty ballot in clerk race
No race has been the focus of critics' frustration with Suffolk County Democrats more than that of Suffolk clerk.
In April, Anthony Portesy, the former Brookhaven Democratic chairman who is general counsel at Suffolk OTB, announced he was running for clerk and that Schaffer "personally asked" him to run following another candidate's withdrawal, according to an email he sent to the committee members.
When he stepped down in August, Portesy said that protecting jobs were a factor.
"I fell on the sword because I believed it was necessary to stop people from losing their jobs across this county," he wrote in an email to committee members.
The email did not elaborate on how exactly people could lose their jobs, but Long Island party leaders have traditionally controlled patronage jobs at entities such as the boards of elections and off-track betting agencies, which employ party loyalists.

Suffolk County Clerk Vincent Puelo ran unopposed for reelection. Credit: Newsday/Patrick E. McCarthy
The Point, a newsletter from Newsday's editorial page, at the time linked threats about job losses to Garcia or Conservative Party Chairman Mike Torres, who works in the clerk's office. Garcia has denied any involvement in picking candidates for the Democratic Party. Torres did not respond to an interview request.
Kathryn Casey Quigley, chair of the Southold Democratic Committee who lost the bid for party leader in September, wrote an Aug. 15 memo to Schaffer requesting the committee "immediately fill the vacancy" for clerk to oppose incumbent Conservative Vincent Puleo. He did not.
Asked in an interview after Election Day what she believed the Democrats gained by not running a clerk candidate, Casey Quigley said: "Everybody would like to know."
She said cross-party deal making has been viewed as a way to elect people who otherwise wouldn't get elected, specifically in judicial races to allow for more diversity.
Portesy, who backed Schaffer as party leader in the September election, did not respond to a request for comment on the clerk's race.
Cutchogue's Abigail Field launched a write-in campaign for county clerk. Field, in two months of grassroots campaigning, managed to pull nearly 11% of the vote.
"When you have a Democratic leadership that concedes races in advance by running weak candidates or no candidate at all, how do you expect to win elections?" Field said.
Competitive comptroller race
The race for the fiscal watchdog position of county comptroller has been a rallying cry for the Democrats since the summer.
Jon Estreich, the Democrats' candidate for comptroller, fought an attempt from party leadership to get him off the ballot, saying at the time it was a "matter of honor." He lost by 6,548 votes, 265,160 to 258,612, to Republican Daniel Losquadro, the Brookhaven Highway Superintendent, according to unofficial results.
Estreich said he campaigned hard and didn't blame the county committee.
"From where we sat, we did everything we could," he said.
Legis. Greg Doroski (D-Jamesport) said the result of the comptroller race calls into question "the idea that he was going to be pulled off the ballot for some backroom deal because that race wasn't winnable anyway."
From where we sat, we did everything we could.
—Jon Estreich, Democratic candidate for Suffolk comptroller
He said if the county party had provided more financial assistance to Estreich's campaign, the outcome could have been different.
William Ferraro, field director for Christopher Murray’s successful campaign in Senate District 1, said that Estreich should have been the comptroller-elect and the fact he came up short is a "travesty for Democrats."
Campaign finance reports show the Suffolk GOP Committee outspent the Suffolk Democratic Committee, $1.4 million to $1.275 million. The GOP Committee raised about $2.1 million while the Democratic Committee raised $1.4 million.
Dale Pabst, campaign manager for Democrat Pat Halpin, who lost the 2nd District Congressional race to incumbent Andrew Garbarino (R-Bayport), said the campaign lacked financial support from the national Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.
He said the county committee provided "organizational help," which was "immensely helpful." But he added the focus on the internal fight for party control between Schaffer and Casey Quigley had an effect, particularly with regard to the money he believes the county party spent on Schaffer's reelection.
"We tried to focus on our campaign," he said. "But ultimately, there was an effect that came out of that. I think a lot of money was spent on that. Could it have been put in other better places? Sure. But that's just how things work sometimes."
'At any moment something could happen' In such a car-dependent place, agents' road tactics have brought new risk to the daily routines of many Latino drivers. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa and Newsday investigative reporter Josefa Velásquez have more on this story.
'At any moment something could happen' In such a car-dependent place, agents' road tactics have brought new risk to the daily routines of many Latino drivers. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa and Newsday investigative reporter Josefa Velásquez have more on this story.




