Huntington Town will have leaner budget, lower tax levy after residents' outrage over earlier proposed increases

While Huntington's proposed 2027 budget and its 18% tax hike sparked outrage this fall among some residents, late amendments to the plan have fueled uncertainty and frustration — and left town officials trying to crunch the new numbers.
Republican town board member Theresa Mari introduced more than three dozen amendments at Tuesday evening's board meeting to reduce the tax levy by $22.5 million and, she says, bring the levy under the town’s 2.68% state tax cap. In doing so, she threw a last-minute curveball into the budget discussion as the board prepared to vote on a spending plan.
Mari came up with 39 amendments, which ranged from removing $3,000 allotted for town board member travel expenses to including $3.5 million in highway funds secured by Rep. Nick LaLota that had not been put into the proposed budget.
The board voted 3-2 to approve the amendments — but the amended budget failed 3-2, leaving it to be adopted by default, said Town Clerk Andrew Raia. Under state law, a budget must be adopted by Friday.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- The Huntington Town Board had been poised to vote Tuesday on a 2027 budget that would have raised taxes by nearly 18.4%.
- Republican town board member Theresa Mari introduced more than three dozen amendments at Tuesday's board meeting to reduce the tax levy by $22.5 million and, she says, bring the levy under the town’s 2.68% state tax cap.
- While the amendments were approved, the budget was not, leaving it to be adopted by default and leaving town officials to try and crunch the new numbers.
What followed on Wednesday was a day of uncertainty.
Republican Town Supervisor Ed Smyth expressed his frustration with the late changes. On Wednesday, he said he viewed the amendments as "a work of fiction," based on the math and assumptions made to get under the tax cap.
"The revenue they relied on is implausible, but the expenses are real," he said.
Hashing out the numbers
Smyth said the town's comptroller is working to reconcile the amended budget to get updated numbers on how much the average homeowner will pay, the tax levy and the tax levy increase.
"When you change one number in the budget, then you have to change other numbers throughout the budget," he said. "We have to go through the whole budget book."
The budget is due to the county comptroller by Friday.
The board had been set to vote on a budget of $269.7 million for next year that would have raised taxes by nearly 18.4%. The proposed budget would have increased taxes by $25 a month for the average homeowner and would have included a $169.9 million tax levy.
Residents had expressed outrage over the proposed tax hike. In making his case for the budget in August, Smyth said it would equal “fiscal suicide” to not pass a budget that pierced the cap.
Mari told residents on Tuesday night that she spent a week combing through the budget to find the more than $22.5 million in savings that would bring the budget under the cap.
She said she had two guiding principles as she searched for ways to slash the tax levy. “First, if possible, I wanted to eliminate no jobs, and second, if possible, I wanted to eliminate no services,” she said.
One of Mari's amendments suggested deferring filling 24 vacant town positions to land $2 million in savings. Another sought to budget parking meter revenue closer to 2025 and projected 2026 numbers, adding $150,000 to the revenue line item.
Raising transparency questions
All of the amendments passed with Mari, Republican Dave Bennardo and Democrat Jennifer Hebert voting in favor. Conservative Brooke Lupinacci and Smyth abstained from all of the votes.
“I received these at 4 p.m. today, so I’ll be abstaining,” Smyth said at the 6 p.m. meeting.
Lupinacci expressed her frustration at the meeting.
“For months, we’ve been hearing from the supervisor who has been telling the board and residents that piercing the cap was the only path forward,” said Lupinacci, who along with Hebert had previously voted against piercing the tax cap. “Now I am being presented with a stack ... of unvetted resolutions ... so I don’t know exactly what’s going on here.”
Lupinacci called for more transparency, and while Hebert voted for all of the amendments, she ultimately voted against the proposed budget, citing the same lack of transparency.
“I don’t support the way that we went about this,” she said before casting her budget vote.
Smyth and Lupinacci also voted against the budget.
Residents speaking after Tuesday's vote echoed the calls for more clarity about the budget and how it comes together.
“I’m troubled by the process,” said longtime town resident Tammy Green. “It really needs to be more transparent.”
LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'
LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'