Islip Town fails to vote on '27 budget; default adoption of 18% tax hike set for Friday

Islip's 2027 fiscal budget, including an 18% property tax hike, is scheduled for adoption by default Friday. Credit: Neil Miller
Islip's 2027 fiscal budget, including an 18% property tax hike, is scheduled for adoption by default Friday after the board failed again at its Tuesday meeting to take a vote on the spending plan.
The afternoon meeting was the last one planned before New York State’s Friday deadline for towns to approve their budgets for next year. After that, the proposed budgets are adopted by default under state law.
The lack of a vote has spurred infighting between Supervisor Angie Carpenter and the four board members since early November. Carpenter, a Republican, was not available for comment Tuesday.
She crafted the proposed budget with town Comptroller Robert Kordic. Carpenter has criticized the town board for failing to suggest an alternative budget after rejecting her proposal on Nov. 7. Councilman Jorge Gaudron, a Democrat, and Michael McElwee, a Republican, both have said they were excluded from the process.
"It was one of those things [where] ‘it’s my way or the highway,’" Guadron said about Carpenter's alleged approach to the budget process.
Kordic first presented the proposed $306.5 million spending plan earlier this month, an $18.7 million increase over the current budget. The plan calls for a tax levy of $177.9 million. That’s an uptick of nearly 12%, far surpassing the town’s 2% tax cap limit.
Outside observers, like Paul Sabatino, the former Suffolk County chief deputy executive, called the failure to vote on a budget a civic "embarrassment."
"The power of the purse strings is really 90% of what government is all about," Sabatino told Newsday on Tuesday. "To say that you’re not going to present alternatives, that you’re not going to vote ... [that] really abdicates your role as an elected official."
If approved by default, the budget would mark the third time in a row Islip has pierced its tax cap.
The plan would increase taxes on a $400,000 home by $135 annually, from $772 this year to $907 in 2027, an 18% increase.
Kordic pinned this year’s increase on items such as a mandatory salary increases for union workers, as well as a rise in health insurance and pension costs.
Carpenter has previously said the tax hike was needed to keep services and town staff intact. She argued that Town Board members received a copy of the budget in September, but did not suggest any changes.
"We were faced with a choice — pierce the cap and raise taxes, or lay off a large portion of our employees," Carpenter wrote in Facebook post earlier this month. "This will allow our town to be sustainable."
Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends
Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends
