The expense is among the largest for Long Island towns and cities, and is a key driver of tax hikes, officials say. NewsdayTV's Joseph Ostapiuk reports. Credit: Newsday

Long Island towns and cities spent $344.4 million on employee and retiree healthcare premiums last year, a ballooning cost that officials say is expected to trigger tax hikes and further strain municipal budgets. 

The total across Long Island's 13 towns and two cities was up about 3% over 2024, and 37% over 2021, according to state data analyzed by Newsday. Municipal officials, facing a Nov. 20 deadline to finalize 2027 spending plans, expect the cost to rise steeply next year.

Officials have cited the sharply rising expense of covering employee and retiree healthcare plans as a key driver of annual tax hikes. The benefit can account for more than 15% of some town and city spending plans, making it among their largest single expenses. State-set premiums have risen an average of 6% annually since 2021 and increased nearly 10% in 2026, the highest change in years, state data shows. 

Healthcare costs between 2024 and 2025 rose the most in Long Beach, where the city experienced a 17%, or $2.6 million, jump to $17.6 million. In the Town of Oyster Bay, the expense rose nearly 19%, or $7.1 million, to $45.1 million.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • Healthcare costs for Long Island town and city governments rose to $344.4 million in 2025, nearly 3% higher than 2024's total.

  • Some officials are budgeting for 10% increases next year, putting a strain on town finances.

  • Government officials said they have limited options to curb the cost and must rely on tax increases to balance spending plans.

"It's unlike almost anything else on our budget," Rob Darienzo, Oyster Bay's budget director, said in an interview. "We do our best to keep our salaries the same, and we try to reduce our debt. And yet, the health insurance premiums, mandated by New York State, they skyrocket out of control."

Budget officials are bracing for double-digit-percent increases to healthcare expenses each year, on top of surging employee pension costs. The increases have compelled towns and cities to keep their workforces flat and lean on incentive programs to reduce the number of highly paid workers and the cost of their benefits, officials said. 

Nearly 7,000 town and city employees are covered by the New York State Health Insurance Plan. NYSHIP covers about 27,000 dependents on Long Island, according to the state Department of Civil Service, which administers the health plan. 

NYSHIP premium rates, which are set by the state, rose 2.2% in 2021, 7.4% in 2022, 8.6% in 2023 and 8.9% in 2024 but were flat in 2025, the agency said. Then, in 2026, premium rates jumped 9.6%. 

The rate changes are affected by several factors, officials say, from the number of employees enrolled in family plans to increases in the cost of medical procedures.

The rising burden of funding benefit programs is a "huge problem" in the long term, said Zilvinas Silenas, president of the Empire Center, a conservative think tank based in Albany.

"If this continues, meaning more and more people claim benefits or the benefits become increasingly generous or even the wages become more generous, there is a finite number of taxpayers in New York that can support that," Silenas said. 

Climbing costs

Healthcare costs, along with other annual increases like contractual raises and retirement benefits, make it difficult to stay below the state's 2% tax cap, Southampton Supervisor Maria Moore said. Last year, the town negotiated for new employees to pay 15% of their healthcare benefits, rather than 10%, to help blunt the rising cost as part of its contract with the Civil Service Employees Association union.

"How can you stay below 2% when just the salary increases contractually are 3%, the healthcare is going up 6% more than likely, the pension will likely go up another 10% ... not to mention the cost of gas, diesel [and] materials?" Moore said. "Everything costs more now."

Southampton's healthcare costs have risen from $17 million in 2022 to $22.1 million in 2025, state data shows.

Babylon Deputy Comptroller Cathy Wuertz said governments are in a defensive position while preparing budgets. 

"We budget conservatively," Wuertz said. "Some years it works in our favor, where we get a couple of bucks that we didn’t have to spend. You budget according to what you think is going to happen, according to trends, and you just go from there."

Future concerns 

North Hempstead Town Hall. The town's healthcare costs are forecast...

North Hempstead Town Hall. The town's healthcare costs are forecast to jump even more next year. Credit: Neil Miller

The tide of rising healthcare costs isn't expected to recede in the near future, officials said.

East Hampton's 2027 budget anticipated $14.8 million in health insurance costs, a nearly 5% increase over this year. 

The state usually releases its official rate increases in late November or December — after town and city budgets are finalized. That means officials base budgets, and project one of their largest expenses, off limited information. 

"A lot of that is really just trying to, for lack of a better phrase, sharpening your pencils — looking at prior year history and increases, and really just hoping that you're coming up with as best of an accurate number as possible," East Hampton Town Administrator Rebecca Hansen said.

On the national level, healthcare premiums have risen at a fast clip, as more patients sign up for mental health services and undergo expensive treatments, said Matthew Rae, associate director for the healthcare marketplace program at KFF, a Washington, D.C., health policy and research nonprofit. Newer drugs on the market, like GLP-1s and emerging cancer treatments, are also driving premium hikes, Rae said. 

That leaves employers to shoulder a growing expense.

"What used to be considered an expensive drug was $100,000. There are now a lot of drugs on the market that are $1 million," Rae said, referring to treatments for cancers and diseases like sickle cell. "How we finance that may be a challenge, and for whatever reason we made employers the basis of our healthcare finance system, but we need to figure out how to pay for stuff like that that is remarkably changing people's lives."

In North Hempstead, healthcare costs rose nearly 2% between 2025 and 2026 but are expected to rise almost 6% next year, said Umberto Mignardi, a town spokesman.

Costs have climbed due to "higher medical facility and physician fees, rising specialty drug and prescription costs, aging active and retiree plan demographics, state-mandated coverage expansions and caps on member out-of-pocket spending," Mignardi said. 

Creative decisions 

Smithtown Town Hall. The town eliminated more than 30 part-time seasonal...

Smithtown Town Hall. The town eliminated more than 30 part-time seasonal positions in 2025.  Credit: Neil Miller

Some towns have resorted to workforce reductions and buyouts to keep pace.

In October, Suffolk County supervisors signed a letter to Gov. Kathy Hochul asking the state to consider adjusting its tax cap formula. The supervisors asked for more flexibility to address "the growing financial pressures facing local governments."

The letter stressed that municipal budgets are forced to "absorb significant costs that we have no vote, voice or authority to determine."

Smithtown eliminated more than 30 part-time seasonal positions in 2025, Smithtown Comptroller Paul Rubano said. The only way to bring down health insurance and retirement costs is to cull the full-time headcount. 

"The Town has very few options for controlling this cost other than cutting services by shrinking the workforce," Rubano said.

In North Hempstead, the town has over the past two years offered voluntary buyout programs to help reduce health insurance costs. 

"As positions are refilled, new hires enter at lower base salary tiers and typically contribute a higher percentage toward their health insurance premiums," Mignardi said. 

Addressing rising healthcare costs "is one of the biggest, if not the biggest challenge facing municipalities," said Chris Koetzle, executive director of the New York Association of Towns.

Labor unions have extracted attractive benefits for their workers and amassed powerful followings that have led to surging costs, he said.

"I think local governments are doing everything they can," Koetzle said. "They're just stuck."

Newsday's Denise M. Bonilla, Alek Lewis, Carl MacGowan, Joshua Needelman and Jean-Paul Salamanca contributed to this story.

Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Biggest health insurance hike in decades ... Which NY colleges have highest earnings for grads Credit: Newsday

Honor Wall unveiled for fallen Suffolk officers ... Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Dems declare victory in Hempstead race ... Village eyes limits on chain stores

Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Biggest health insurance hike in decades ... Which NY colleges have highest earnings for grads Credit: Newsday

Honor Wall unveiled for fallen Suffolk officers ... Alleged gang members charged with drug trafficking ... Dems declare victory in Hempstead race ... Village eyes limits on chain stores

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME