Oheka Castle in Huntington was auctioned last month.

Oheka Castle in Huntington was auctioned last month. Credit: Newsday/J. Conrad Williams Jr.

A federal bankruptcy court judge on Thursday heard from the attorneys in a dispute over $3 million a Woodbury investment firm says the outgoing corporate owner of Oheka Castle owes from the $72 million sale of the Huntington mansion and property. 

Tabone LLC and its managing partner, John M. Tabone, filed a proof of claim against the estate in U.S. Bankruptcy Court on Oct. 14, 2025. They say castle owner Kahn Property Owner LLC and Oheka operator Gary Melius refused to pay the company for consulting services aimed at helping Melius secure a lender to avoid the castle going into foreclosure for over $60 million in debt.

Kahn Property Owner objected to the claim on the grounds that Tabone, an unsecured creditor, did not deliver the funding. Melius has an ownership stake in Kahn Property Owner.

The judge on Thursday did not issue a ruling in the case.

According to court documents, Melius hired Tabone LLC in early 2024 to help raise between $50 million and $100 million to refinance the Oheka debt. Melius dropped the firm in May 2025 and began talks with another company, Taconic Capital, Tabone said in the court filing.

On Thursday, the attorney for Tabone, Robert L. Pryor, argued before Judge Louis Scarcella that Melius “sabotaged” the deal, citing an email from that month, the text of which was included in the filing.

"We have a deal and then we don't have one," Melius said, according to Tabone's five-page filing. "If I do my deal with Taconic, you get nothing."

Oheka Castle operator Gary Melius, left, with attorney Joseph S....

Oheka Castle operator Gary Melius, left, with attorney Joseph S. Maniscalco on Tuesday. Credit: Newsday/Steve Pfost

After the hearing, Pryor told Newsday the email is one of the items that would constitute a repudiation of the objection.

“They [Tabone] were moving forward with the term sheet when Melius said, 'I’m not going to pay you,' ” Pryor said, referring to a document between Kahn Property Owner, Melius and Tabone.

Taconic Capital, aka 135 W. Gate Drive LLC, subsequently refinanced Melius' $60 million debt, Newsday has previously reported.

Joseph S. Maniscalco, the attorney for Kahn Property Owner, disputed there was any sabotage and said Tabone is not owed $3 million.

“We never got the financing; he never got the money he was hired to get,” Maniscalco said after the hearing. “I don’t understand how you get paid when you didn’t deliver.”

Scarcella has given Maniscalco until Dec. 11 to respond in writing to Tabone’s latest arguments.

Earlier this week, Scarcella signed off on the $72 million sale of the castle to Gold Coast Property & Estate Management LLC, which submitted the winning bid at auction last month. A closing date is expected in the next 30 days.

Loading video…

Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case... New acting LIRR president ... Jets, Chargers preview Credit: Newsday

Deal to shut down cesspools ... Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case ... Teen sentenced for fatal crash livestreamed on Instagram ... Picture This: Macy's Parade

Loading video…

Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case... New acting LIRR president ... Jets, Chargers preview Credit: Newsday

Deal to shut down cesspools ... Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case ... Teen sentenced for fatal crash livestreamed on Instagram ... Picture This: Macy's Parade