Read Newsday's original coverage of the 1956 kidnapping and murder...

Read Newsday's original coverage of the 1956 kidnapping and murder of baby Peter Weinberger. Credit: Newsday

Peter Weinberger, a month-old infant, was abducted from a stroller on the back patio of his parents' home in Westbury on July 4, 1956. 

The abduction shocked Long Island and brought national news attention as his parents, Beatrice (Betty) and Morris Weinberger, pleaded for his safe return.

After a handwriting analysis, investigators zeroed-in on a suspect: Angelo La Marca, a 31-year-old father and mechanic from Plainview, who was pressed for cash. La Marca confessed to the crime and brought investigators to where Weinberger was buried — a wooded area off Exit 37 of the Northern State Parkway in Plainview.

La Marca was tried, convicted and sentenced to death. He was executed on Aug. 7, 1958 at Sing Sing Prison in upstate Ossining.

Newsday documented the abduction and trial with wall-to-wall coverage, featuring stories on its front-page. 

Read our coverage here:

Rape, kidnapping charges dropped against man who died in custody ... Highest-paid LI nonprofit employees ... Out East: Seven Ponds Orchard Credit: Newsday

Updated 30 minutes ago South Asians concerned about online hate ... Rape, kidnapping charges dropped against man who died in custody ... Ex-teacher gets 3 years in prison ... Working Moms: Finding friends

Rape, kidnapping charges dropped against man who died in custody ... Highest-paid LI nonprofit employees ... Out East: Seven Ponds Orchard Credit: Newsday

Updated 30 minutes ago South Asians concerned about online hate ... Rape, kidnapping charges dropped against man who died in custody ... Ex-teacher gets 3 years in prison ... Working Moms: Finding friends

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME