Smithtown passes budget despite residents' ire at the nearly 6% tax levy increase
Smithtown Supervisor Edward Wehrheim speaks during a town board meeting at Smithtown Town Hall in Smithtown Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. Credit: Barry Sloan
The Town of Smithtown board voted Thursday to pass a $149.4 million budget for 2027, which will exceed the state’s 2% tax cap for the second consecutive year.
The budget for the coming fiscal year represents a 5.63% increase from last year’s $141.4 million spending plan, resulting in a tax levy hike of 5.87%.
For the average assessed home in Smithtown, that means town taxes will go up by $117.65, or 6.44%. The increase, officials said, is required to maintain the town's workforce, services and operations.
The increases were driven as a result of unfunded state policy mandates to health insurance, retirement and Tier 6 changes, which cost the town nearly $3 million, while collectively bargained salaries rose another $1.87 million and rising solid waste and waste-to-energy costs cost the town $410,000, Smithtown Supervisor Ed Wehrheim had previously said.
But residents at recent public hearings mostly opposed the spending hikes, some questioning whether other steps could have been taken to cut costs rather than raise taxes — a move that they have said will put added pressure on their pocketbooks.
Nicole Garguilo, Wehrheim's spokeswoman and the town's public information officer, read a statement on Thursday on behalf of Wehrheim and the town regarding the budget. In response to some of the claims residents made at those meetings, Garguilo said while the board respects their right to criticize, the town board has "made deliberate, responsible investments to address decades of deferred maintenance and aging infrastructure that preceded this administration." The board voted 4-0 to pass the budget, with Councilman Tom McCarthy absent.
Garguilo pointed to the improvements to town parks and facilities in recent years, as well as the downtown revitalization efforts to districts in St. James, Kings Park and Smithtown, "which have laid the groundwork for private investment, new business, housing opportunities and renewed economic activities."
She added that the town's highway department had uncovered sinkholes, deteriorating drainage and other infrastructure issues that it has worked to fix to ensure safety for pedestrians, motorists and surrounding properties.
During one heated exchange, Laurie Weitz, of Kings Park, who criticized the board on the budget in previous meetings, told the board during the public comment portion of the hearing she had requested budget information from the town via FOIL requests, and accused the board of not being transparent about the budget-making process.
Weitz also said after reviewing budget information she had seen, she felt the town board could have done more to trim the spending plan, such as by opting to take less expensive healthcare plans.
"What we really want is transparency," Weitz said. "I don't want a speech. I want to see the numbers."
Wehrheim in response said that Weitz's FOIL requests are expected to cost the town tens of thousands of dollars for town staff to address, and the board's healthcare plans were done according to collective bargaining agreements.
"No one here is in the SAG union. We're elected officials. The department heads and deputies are in the (Smithtown Administrators Guild) union, not us. And everything you just said, it's all done by CBA agreements. It's all done by contract agreements," Wehrheim said.
Previously, Wehrheim stated in the budget address note that the town also had to absorb the court-ordered LIPA tax shift, which adds approximately $23.12 to the average homeowner’s bill.
Wehrheim has defended the decision for the town had to pierce the tax cap as a necessary step to avoid cutting town staff, which would result in a reduction of town services, Newsday previously reported.
Individual salaries for the four town board members are slated to increase 3%, to $98,408. Wehrheim’s salary will climb 3.2%, to $166,869, with the salary hikes attributable to the cost of living and inflation, Wehrheim has stated.
Loading video…
Deal to shut down cesspools ... Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case ... Teen sentenced for fatal crash livestreamed on Instagram ... Picture This: Macy's Parade
Loading video…
Deal to shut down cesspools ... Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case ... Teen sentenced for fatal crash livestreamed on Instagram ... Picture This: Macy's Parade