A Flock camera operated by the Suffolk County Sheriff's office...

A Flock camera operated by the Suffolk County Sheriff's office on Route 48 near Carroll Avenue in Peconic on Tuesday. Credit: Randee Daddona

Southold lawmakers raised lingering concerns about Flock Safety’s AI-powered license plate readers on Tuesday, while officials from the Suffolk County Sheriff’s Office and town police defended them, saying there are internal safeguards to protect against misuse.

Law enforcement agencies are increasingly relying on Flock cameras to pinpoint stolen vehicles, missing people and for other crime-solving leads. But concerns over civil liberties, data security and access have drawn national scrutiny, prompting county and state lawmakers to consider regulations on the technology.

The sheriff’s department controls eight of the 11 Flock cameras within Southold Town.

Chief Deputy Sheriff Christopher Brockmeyer spoke at length about internal policies governing the use of Flock cameras during a town meeting on Tuesday, two weeks after Councilwoman Alexa Suess called for the town to end its contract with Flock over privacy concerns.

WHAT NEWDSAY FOUND

  • Southold police and the Suffolk County Sheriff's Office say Flock’s artificial intelligence license plate readers have helped law enforcement solve crimes more quickly.
  • Town officials say security and privacy questions remain unanswered, including encryption practices and third-party access.
  • Chief Deputy Sheriff Christopher Brockmeyer said the agency has safeguards to protect against misuse of Flock readers.

Brockmeyer on Tuesday said the cameras are a “critical investigative and intelligence tool.”

The cameras capture photos of cars passing by and log the license plate, make, model and color of the vehicle, Brockmeyer said. The cameras do not capture video feeds or use facial recognition, law enforcement and Flock company officials have said.

Brockmeyer said the technology can be used to provide leads in cases from hit-and-runs to homicides and trafficking, and that sharing information between agencies is crucial since investigations frequently cross jurisdictional lines.

Internal controls

Across the country, Flock cameras have faced backlash after reports that police officers have misused the technology to stalk exes or romantic interests, according to media reports.

“The effectiveness of any technology depends on its capabilities, but also on the integrity and safeguards surrounding the use,” Brockmeyer said, adding it’s important to maintain public trust.

Suffolk Chief Deputy Sheriff Christopher Brockmeyer speaks to lawmakers about...

Suffolk Chief Deputy Sheriff Christopher Brockmeyer speaks to lawmakers about Flock Safety cameras during a Southold town board work session Tuesday. Credit: Randee Daddona

The sheriff’s office stores data for 30 days, after which it is automatically deleted. Access is restricted and searches are logged and audited regularly, Brockmeyer said.

He also said the sheriff’s office has hired an independent civilian auditor as another layer of oversight.

Southold Police Chief Steven Grattan said in an interview that the department has similar internal policies and has not had reports of improper use.

Several cameras have been vandalized with paint, wires unplugged wires or bags placed over camera lenses. Though the incidents may signal residents' backlash, Grattan said he still supports the cameras.

“It’s not a reason for us to abandon the technology,” he said.

Practices questioned

At Tuesday’s meeting, Southold officials questioned how data is protected and shared.

Councilwoman Alexa Suess distinguished her trust in local law enforcement from her concerns about Flock.

“I believe your oversight is very strong,” she said at the meeting. “My concern is actually with how the data is handled and shared via the vendor. Unfortunately, that is not something that we can legislate.”

Brockmeyer said police “routinely” handle sensitive information, from criminal records and victims' addresses to DNA evidence and sensitive photographs and videos.

“These types of records contain significantly more personal information than a still image of a vehicle and its license plate captured on an ALPR system,” he said Tuesday. He acknowledged that Flock’s cloud-based system could be vulnerable to hacks and data breaches.

“It’s something that we have to take seriously,” Brockmeyer said. “I also think that it’s something that is just a reality in today’s day and age.”

Flock insists that it does not share or sell data.

A Flock spokesperson said in an email Tuesday: "Data is encrypted on the device, in transit to the cloud and in cloud storage. Bishop Fox, an independent security firm, recently conducted a penetration test of Flock."

The statement pointed to the firm's findings, a summary of which stated: "There were 36 issues of varying levels of severity found ... of those, 24 are already fixed and independently confirmed; the remainder are in progress to be fixed, or nominal risks Flock decided to watch and manage."

Law enforcement officials acknowledged they didn’t have all of the technical answers sought by the town board and said Flock should be part of ongoing discussions.

Flock representatives defended the technology during a Suffolk County Legislature hearing in October. Suffolk lawmakers are weighing legislation that would address data access and audits, Newsday previously reported.

Councilwoman Anne Smith said the town’s goal is to protect both civil liberties and public safety.

“It just feels like the technology got ahead of our use, which often happens because we trust it before we understand it,” Smith said.

U.S. loses its measles-free status ... October's LI home prices are out ... Holiday gift guide Credit: Newsday

Updated 7 minutes ago Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends

U.S. loses its measles-free status ... October's LI home prices are out ... Holiday gift guide Credit: Newsday

Updated 7 minutes ago Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME