Syosset partnership looks to revive abandoned Woodbury School building
The abandoned Woodbury School building was built in 1925. Credit: Morgan Campbell
A century-old abandoned school building that sits on a hillside in Woodbury could find new life as a community hub under a local partnership.
Syosset officials have a $19.1 million plan to restore the brick building, built in 1925 at the corner of Woodbury Road and Jericho Turnpike, so it can serve the growing need for library programming and school district meeting space. The Syosset Public Library and the Syosset Central School District partnered to create the proposal, which still needs approval from both boards and the community.
“The renovations would stabilize and repair this deteriorating structure, and it would return a community asset back to public use,” school district Superintendent Thomas Rogers said in an email. The building has been vacant since 2007, according to the school district.
The library and school district formed a partnership to transform the structure into a modern satellite facility. A feasibility study of the project presented to the community in September showed renderings of modern meeting areas, outdoor space, study rooms and places for children to play.
The Syosset Central School District is expected to contribute $3.5 million to the project, according to officials. If the proposal is accepted by the community, it would raise the library tax for a home valued at $850,000 by around $120, the study said.
The district could use the facility "as an off-site location for professional development and for students as an in-district field trip site taking advantage of both the outdoor programming space and the local history collection that are under consideration," Rogers said.
A 'well used' library system
The library has a need for more space, since its programming attendance has risen significantly in recent years.
There were 27,945 total attendees of the library’s programs in 2025, up 35% from 2016. Meanwhile, 97% of adult programs and 95% of children’s registered programs had a waitlist last year, according to the study.
Christine Belling, director of the Syosset Public Library, said the plan “is an interesting and unique opportunity for the Syosset Library to partner with the Syosset Central School District to repurpose the 100-year-old Woodbury School to expand library programs and services for the entire community.”
Megan Ballato, with H2M Architects, said during the Sept. 29 public session that the plan includes a connecting road between the building's parking lot and the adjacent Walt Whitman Elementary School's parking lot that would be open only after school hours to accommodate larger library events.
Michael Borra, of Syosset, a retired teacher in the district, said he supported the library expansion because its services are “well used” by the community.
“This opportunity they have for the additional space, for meetings, study rooms and to have other children there would be great,” Borra said.
Community input
The library and school district have held two public meetings to hear community concerns over the proposal, which included questions over security, staffing and traffic.
In 2014, the district entered into a contract with a developer to build a shopping center on the land that includes the abandoned school building, which is adjacent to the elementary school. The community opposed the plan, and the district paid the buyer $125,000 to void the agreement, Newsday reported.
At the time, residents told Newsday they were concerned over the impacts a shopping center would have on the area and that they would prefer the building be repurposed for educational or professional uses.
No board votes related to the new project have been scheduled, Belling said.
If the community approves the project, construction is expected to begin in summer 2028, with the facility opening toward the end of 2029, officials said.
Woodbury School
- Built in 1925 on a hillside at the corner of Woodbury Road and Jericho Turnpike.
- Vacant since 2007, according to the school district.
- Earlier plans called for a shopping center on the land.
- Current proposal to restore it includes using it for library programming and school district meeting space.
Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends
Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends
