Industry groups say fixing roads in NYS won't be cheap
New York State’s major roads rank 45th in the nation for smoothness, a report found. Credit: Elizabeth Sagarin
New York’s major roads and bridges — which already rank poorly compared with others nationwide — are likely to get worse without a significant boost in funding, according to two studies released this week by industry groups.
To turn things around on state-administered roads and bridges, New York needs to nearly double spending over the next five years, according to a report by the American Road and Transportation Builders Association. It calls for a roughly $60 billion investment in the next five-year transportation capital plan, which covers roads, bridges, aid to local governments, rail, aviation infrastructure and non-Metropolitan Transportation Authority transit. The current plan, for $34.3 billion, expires in the spring.
Another study, looking only at state road repaving needs, estimated a $29.5 billion cost over five years. That includes about $2 billion on Long Island, according to the report from a business- and labor-funded group called Rebuild NY Now.
Sean Butler, a spokesman for Gov. Kathy Hochul, did not respond to the studies’ specific cost estimates or questions about how the state could come up with more funding. But, in a statement, he said the governor "has invested record amounts to repair our roads, making them safer and more resilient for all," and that more details would come in her budget proposal due in January.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- New York’s major roads and bridges — which already rank poorly compared with others nationwide — are likely to get worse without a significant boost in funding, according to two studies released this week by industry groups.
- Paying for roads has become trickier in recent decades. "User fees" like gas taxes, DMV fees, tolls and motor vehicle sales taxes have become a smaller share of New York’s road spending, with greater portions made up by federal aid and borrowing, according to one report.
- Highway construction prices nationwide have almost doubled over the past decade, according to federal inflation statistics.
The current capital plan, for 2022-2027, is nominally the largest in history, with a large chunk coming from the federal Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, passed in 2021. But inflation in the construction industry — which is far hotter than in the general economy — severely reduced its purchasing power.
It is unclear how much federal transportation funding the state can count on, since Congress has yet to pass a replacement for the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, which expired in September.
Currently, New York’s major roads rank 45th in the nation for smoothness, and there are 631 structurally deficient bridges, according to the ARTBA report.
Driving on rough roads costs drivers an additional $8.8 billion statewide each year, amounting to about $728 per driver in the New York metro area including Long Island, according to another study, released by TRIP in January.
"This needs to be addressed. The longer we delay, the more the cost of repairs will increase," said Marc Herbst, president of the Long Island Contractors’ Association, which sponsored the builder association’s study.
Stacey Sikes, acting president and CEO of the Long Island Association, said roads are essential to the regional economy: "Deteriorating roads drive up costs for businesses and commuters, disrupt the movement of goods and threaten our region’s economic competitiveness."
How to pay for it
Paying for roads has become trickier in recent decades. "User fees" like gas taxes, DMV fees, tolls and motor vehicle sales taxes have become a smaller share of New York’s road funding, with greater portions made up by federal aid and borrowing, according to the ARTBA report.
Electric vehicles, while beneficial to the environment in cutting emissions, cause more wear-and-tear to pavement because of their weight. Their popularity, as well as the spread of fuel-efficient vehicles, have reduced gas tax revenues — leading a few states to adopt taxes based on "vehicle miles traveled."
While gas taxes could be raised from their current rate (about 24 cents per gallon in New York, which is the 39th highest among states), doing so would be regressive and hurt lower-income people the most, said Jonathan Peters, a professor of transportation finance at the College of Staten Island.
"New York metro is one of the most tolled places in America," he added. The state could instead consider innovative new taxes like for parking spots in Manhattan or online shopping deliveries, he said.
Fred Hiffa, a consultant to Rebuild NY Now and a former NYSDOT first deputy commissioner, pointed out that the state also uses revenue from drivers — such as from congestion pricing, bridge tolls and a portion of gas taxes — to fund public transit, which it could instead put toward roads.
"There isn’t an even playing field between transit and highways in the state," he said.
But Rachel Weinberger, a transportation planner at the Regional Plan Association, said rather than reducing transit funding, the road system could be made more efficient. Some less-used roads, spurs and highway exits and entrances could be dismantled for cost savings, she said.
"We have been sort of slavishly devoted to repairing what we have without stopping to think if we actually need it," she said. "The only real way to get out of this is to rethink the system."
Two studies, different methods
Nationwide, highway construction prices have almost doubled over the past decade, according to federal inflation statistics.
To determine costs for the next five years, the ARTBA study extrapolated from past inflation, conditions on a subset of state roads and cost estimates in a 2022 state report. Its $60 billion estimate for the next five-year plan includes the costs for bringing state roads and bridges up to a state of good repair while keeping spending on other components of the plan — like aid to local governments — steady, according to economist Josh Hurwitz, one of the authors.
The other study, by Rebuild NY Now, was based on recent pavement conditions reports for all state roads. Its $29.5 billion estimate for bringing state roads up to standard — about 7% is needed on Long Island — does not include costs for bridges, state aid, airports or any of the rest of the components of the five-year plan.
Loading video…
Deal to shut down cesspools ... Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case ... Teen sentenced for fatal crash livestreamed on Instagram ... Picture This: Macy's Parade
Loading video…
Deal to shut down cesspools ... Latest in Jor'Dynn Duncan case ... Teen sentenced for fatal crash livestreamed on Instagram ... Picture This: Macy's Parade




