Amazon's standard-bearer act on climate is wearing thin

An Amazon data center is under construction in New Florence, Mo., on Nov. 9. Credit: AP/Jeff Roberson
This column reflects the personal views of the author and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners. Mark Gongloff is a Bloomberg Opinion editor and columnist covering climate change. He previously worked for Fortune.com, the Huffington Post and The Wall Street Journal.
Meeting publicly announced goals is tricky, but it gets much easier when you set the key performance indicator as “Trust me, bro.”
Amazon.com Inc. announced this week that it plans to cut the carbon intensity of its electricity use by 65% from 2019 levels by 2030. In other words, Amazon has vowed to fairly soon emit 65% less heat-trapping gas for every electron it uses to power its vast server farms and other operations around the world than it did in 2019.
That sounds great, you might be thinking. But then you might also be wondering: 65% of what? What was Amazon’s carbon intensity in 2019? Or in 2025, or in any other year for that matter? (Carbon intensity is the amount of greenhouse gas emitted for a particular activity, economic output or energy generated.)
Those numbers, alas, are state secrets. When asked for past carbon-intensity figures, an Amazon spokesperson told my colleague Liam Denning that they haven’t released those numbers “yet.” They did promise to “share progress toward the goal annually in our Sustainability Report, starting with our next report.” Sometime in mid-2027, then, we might get the answers to our questions, depending on how Amazon chooses to frame its progress. For now, though, we have no benchmark with which to judge that 65% figure.
The company does release a measure of the carbon intensity of its revenue, which rose last year to 112.8 grams of carbon dioxide equivalent emitted per dollar from 109 in 2024. That’s moving in the wrong direction, and it’s also not exactly the same thing as the intensity of electricity.
It might be tempting to give Amazon a pass on this fuzzy goal. Amazon has at least pledged to reach net-zero emissions by 2040, which really is a verifiable indicator. It has encouraged other corporate net-zero strivers to sign its climate pledge, racking up 656 signatories by the end of 2025.
Amazon is also one of the world’s biggest clean-energy investors, claiming 712 projects in 30 countries at the start of 2026, totaling 42 gigawatts of potential capacity, enough to power 13 million U.S. homes for a year. Its clean-power purchasing agreements total 62.5 GW of capacity, according to Bloomberg NEF, making it far and away the global leader. Alphabet Inc.’s 42 GW is a distant second.
But Amazon’s climate standard-bearer act has worn thin lately, owing mainly to the AI boom. Its emissions jumped last year to 80.9 million tons of CO2 from 69.6 million the year before, according to its latest sustainability report. They were 51.2 million tons in 2019, when Amazon made its net-zero pledge. Getting that number to zero tons by 2040 became 16% more difficult in 2025, and the goal has almost certainly moved further out of reach in this year of gas-powered data centers everywhere, all the time.
In fact, Amazon is the world’s biggest purchaser of behind-the-meter fossil-gas power, according to BNEF, with orders for 11.7 GW of capacity by 2031. These gas plants that aren’t connected to the broader grid generally emit far more carbon than those connected to the grid.
Among Amazon’s gas projects is an off-grid plant in West Texas with the potential to spew 33 million metric tons of CO2 into the atmosphere each year, or more than a third of its entire corporate emissions in 2025. That would make it the dirtiest power plant in the country, topping an Arkansas coal plant that currently holds that title with a mere 20 million tons of CO2 per year.
Meanwhile, Amazon’s hunger for green energy has cooled this year. Through September, it has purchased just 1.6 GW of capacity, according to BNEF, compared with 7.6 GW for new leader Meta Platforms Inc. and 3.7 GW for Google. And about half of that capacity is nuclear, which won’t come online for many years.
Amazon contends its data centers use energy more efficiently than their peers, with a higher percentage going to computing power and less to peripherals like lighting and cooling. It also says its clean-energy investments let it “match 100% of the electricity consumed by our operations with renewable energy sources.”
But note that careful language about “matching” energy consumption with renewable sources. This isn’t the same as actually using renewable sources for 100% of operations. That percentage is another number Amazon doesn’t report, though it promises to do so in the future.
Cutting the carbon intensity of your energy is a necessary step toward erasing your carbon emissions, but it’s not sufficient. Consider China, for example. Its carbon intensity has tumbled from 1.28 kilograms of CO2 per dollar of GDP in 1990 to 0.39 kg last year. Like Amazon, China is also a world leader in clean-energy investments.
But China is also a world leader in mining and burning coal, which helps explain why, even as its economy has grown more efficient, its carbon emissions have exploded. Last year, China emitted 8.8 tons of CO2 per person, up from 2.2 tons in 1990. In other words, even as China’s carbon efficiency has quadrupled, so have its emissions.
China has been rightly criticized for aiming at a second-derivative metric that gives it just enough climate sincerity to maintain as much of the fossil-fuel status quo as the metric allows. Amazon shouldn’t escape the same scrutiny. Having your cake and eating it too is no way to diet.
This column reflects the personal views of the author and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners. Mark Gongloff is a Bloomberg Opinion editor and columnist covering climate change. He previously worked for Fortune.com, the Huffington Post and The Wall Street Journal.

