Once enough states sign on to the compact, participating states...

Once enough states sign on to the compact, participating states pledge their electors to the winner of the national popular vote, even if that candidate loses their state. Credit: Ed Betz

This guest essay reflects the views of Mark J. Grossman, a communications and government relations consultant and an adjunct professor at Nassau and Suffolk community colleges.

In 1988, I served as Suffolk County coordinator for Michael Dukakis' presidential campaign and as a pledged delegate to the Democratic National Convention. I led the county's petitioning effort to get Dukakis on New York's primary ballot. The Massachusetts governor came to Long Island seeking our votes. We had organizing support, campaign materials and the energy of a genuine contest.

Then Dukakis won the primary, and everything changed.

During the general-election campaign, I joined strategy calls with coordinators statewide, discussing polling and how to accomplish more with less. But resources dried up almost overnight. Even signs and bumper stickers were hard to come by. But we didn't complain. We understood the calculation: National campaigns spend their money where electoral votes are up for grabs and New York was safely blue.

The recent midterms might have created a way to change that calculation.

Democrats won the governorships and both legislative chambers in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Arizona and Nevada. Together, those states have 61 electoral votes — which would be enough to put the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact over its 270-vote threshold.

The compact is already law in 18 states and Washington, D.C., representing 222 electoral votes. New York joined in 2014. Once enough states sign on, participating states pledge their electors to the winner of the national popular vote, even if that candidate loses their state.

It would not abolish the Electoral College. It would change how states participating in the compact award their electors, bypassing the difficult process of amending the Constitution.

Why should Long Islanders care?

Today, presidential campaigns concentrate their attention on a handful of competitive states. In reliably Democratic New York, Republicans have little incentive to pursue additional votes, while Democrats have little reason to worry about losing the state. Millions of votes in similarly predictable red and blue states get the same strategic indifference. The shrunken battleground map of recent presidential elections is dispiriting and disempowering.

In 2024, Donald Trump carried Nassau and Suffolk yet won none of New York's 28 electoral votes. They all went to Kamala Harris, who carried the state. Under the compact, every Long Island vote for either candidate would help determine the nationwide outcome, whether New York was close or not.

It wasn't always so easy to take New York for granted. In 1960, Richard Nixon and John F. Kennedy both campaigned at the old Long Island Arena in Commack. Nixon came in September; Kennedy appeared just two days before Election Day. Both were seeking votes in a competitive state.

Presidential candidates still visit Long Island. Trump rallied at Nassau Coliseum in 2024, and the Hamptons attract campaign fundraisers. But an occasional appearance isn't the same as a sustained effort to win additional votes here.

A national popular vote wouldn't guarantee frequent campaign stops on Long Island. Candidates would still make strategic choices. But there would be a reason to compete for votes in states that currently attract little general-election attention.

Obstacles remain. Newly elected legislatures must pass the compact, and litigation likely would follow.

I understood why the Dukakis campaign directed its resources elsewhere in 1988. It was playing by the rules. Nearly four decades later, perhaps it's time for rules that make winning the most votes, rather than the right combination of states, the way we elect a president.

This guest essay reflects the views of Mark J. Grossman, a communications and government relations consultant and an adjunct professor at Nassau and Suffolk community colleges.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME