Mineola: Apartments, LIRR, diversity, village perks draw buyers

By Stacey AltherrSpecial to NewsdayUpdated October 13, 2025

THE SCOOP Mayor Paul Pereira said one good reason people like to buy their homes in Mineola is the old adage — location, location, location.

Specifically, the proximity to the Long Island Rail Road "is a big one," he said. "Especially after the addition of the East Side Access [to Grand Central Station]."

The Mineola LIRR station is a major hub in the area and is surrounded by multiple transit oriented developments. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

While Mineola is still a mostly suburban community with single-family homes, the area along Second Avenue in recent years has seen more than 1,000 luxury rental units built, with more on the way. Some of the more elegant ones, such as One Third Avenue, which is one block from the train station and boasts amenities such as indoor pool, doorman and rooftop lounge, with prices start at $3,600 for a one-bedroom, according to its website.

Matt Catapano, left, of Sea Cliff, and Alexa Di Gregorio,... — Matt Catapano, left, of Sea Cliff, and Alexa Di Gregorio, of Merrick, both of whom work in Mineola, enjoy a courtyard at Morgan Parc. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

Morgan Parc, also on Second Street, includes a gym, pool and playroom, as well as lounge. Rents, according to their website, start at $4,195 for a one-bedroom.

The village has upped its fun game, with more park events, such as the summer concert series at Memorial Park. This summer, the village held a "Sounds on Second," during which Second Avenue was closed off, store owners stayed open later and restaurants set up tables for outdoor dining.

Dana Franklin, left, of Lynbrook, and Maureen Mekeel, of Wantagh,... — Dana Franklin, left, of Lynbrook, and Maureen Mekeel, of Wantagh, walk through Mineola's Memorial Park — one of two village parks. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

Those who live in the village have perks like a residents-only pool and two parks — Memorial Park and Wilson Park. National chain restaurants, such as The Cook's Table, are coming to Second Avenue as well.

The village has lower taxes than surrounding communities, Pereira said, because of its strong commercial tax base.

Longtime village staples include Mineola Diner, owned by Shane Fritsche, left,... — Longtime village staples include Mineola Diner, owned by Shane Fritsche, left, of Carle Place, and Mike Alpert, of Westbury, and Station Plaza Coffee Shop & Diner, where Jenny Luca, of Mineola, works. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

For lifelong resident, former art teacher and current real estate agent Michael Fink, the village's greatest benefit is the cultural mix of its residents, which he said makes for a more friendly and understanding population.

"The mix means everyone works together," he said. "It's one of the first things I noticed about the place. There is a huge connection."

Emily Drummer, of Mineola, walks her dog, Dolly, through their... — Emily Drummer, of Mineola, walks her dog, Dolly, through their hometown. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

It is also the place where children he taught in Mineola are now coming back to him to buy a home in their old neighborhood — "I am selling a home now to a former student."

Depending on where they live in the village, students attend one of three school districts: East Williston, Mineola, or Carle Place. Being close to Winthrop Hospital, a big employer in the area, is also a bonus.

Homes along Fairfield Avenue, top, and Roslyn Road in Mineola. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

SALE PRICES Between Oct. 1, 2024, and Sept. 30, 2025, there were 144 home sales with a median sale price of $705,000, according to OneKey MLS. During that period a year earlier, there were 167 home sales with a median sale price of $660,000.

CONDOS AND CO-OPS There are seven co-ops, priced between $225,000 and $480,000, on the market.

OTHER STATS

Population 21,082

Median age 41.6

Median home value $700,000

Monthly LIRR ticket from Mineola $253

School districts, graduation rates Mineola (95%), East Williston (98%), Carle Place (94%)

Library Mineola

Transit NICE Bus Routes 22, 22x, 23, 24, 27, 40x

Sources: 2023 American Community Survey; OneKey MLS via InfoSparks by ShowingTime; LIRR; data.nysed.gov; Nassau Inter-County Express

ON THE MARKET

$998,000

This four-bedroom Colonial has two full bathrooms and one half-bath, including a primary suite with walk-in closet and full bathroom. The renovated kitchen has both a wall oven and stove, and wood floors throughout. The basement is partially finished, and the backyard is surrounded by privacy shrubbery. Taxes are $16,868. Carol Giordano, Howard Hannah Coach, 516-248-9494.

$899,000

This $899,000 Mineola home has a new roof and new electrical work. Credit: Berkshire Hathaway

Built in 1929, the four-bed, 2½-bath home has a new roof and new electrical work. The home has a fireplace in the living room, a formal dining room and a renovated kitchen with a primary suite. Outside, the home has a professionally landscaped yard with a hot tub. Taxes are $16,283. Michael Fink, Berkshire Hathaway, 516-741-3070.

RECENTLY SOLD

$910,000

Brown Street

Style Cape

Bedrooms 3

Bathrooms 1

Built 1948

Lot size 0.1 acre

Taxes $12,231

+/- List price +$111,000

Days on market 12

$798,000