$10M Sag Harbor house for sale had hidden fireplaces, antiques buried in the yard

JoAnn McLean, who owns this historic Sag Harbor home, dug up artifacts and did some research on its past when she first moved in nearly 10 years ago. Credit: JoAnn McLean
An archaeologist dug up some of her home's hidden past when she first moved in nearly 10 years ago.
Now, that home is on the market: $9.6 million for a historic Sag Harbor estate. The taxes are $23,321.
The seller, JoAnn McLean, was drawn to the home by its construction date: circa 1850.
"It was in pretty bad shape when we bought it," said McLean, who earned her master's degree in anthropology, with a specialization in archaeology, from New York University in 1991. "We knew it would take some time to make it into the house that we wanted it to be."
McLean and her husband purchased the home in 2017. They renovated it over the course of two years. In the process, she discovered six fireplaces hidden behind the walls, and original hardwood beneath the flooring at the time.
"Once we started taking things apart, we found these wonderful surprises," McLean said.

McLean led an excavation of the property and found artifacts like medicinal bottles in the ground. Credit: JoAnn McLean

Hidden behind the walls of the home were a total of six fireplaces. Credit: JoAnn McLean
The house spans more than 2,500 square feet and features four bedrooms and 5½ bathrooms. The Greek revival home sits on Main Street and directly overlooks Otter Pond. The property includes a heated in-ground pool, pool house and a separate, legal studio space, with a bedroom, living room, kitchenette and bathroom.
While renovating, McLean led an excavation around the property before installing a new septic system. She and several volunteers dug up artifacts, including medicinal bottles, tableware and an arrowhead, McLean said.
The house has ties to Margaret Olivia Slocum Sage, a prominent figure in Sag Harbor's history. After being left a fortune by her late husband in the early 1900s, Sage acquired several properties around Otter Pond, including McLean's, moving some of the structures around but leaving McLean's home untouched, the homeowner discovered.

The 2,500-square-foot house has four bedrooms and 5½ bathrooms Credit: Rise Media /Cameron Burton
In Sag Harbor, Sage is known for building the John Jermain Memorial Library (named after her grandfather), Pierson Middle-High School (named after her mother) and Mashashimuet Park, which was once a racetrack, according to the Sag Harbor community archive.
"She was a great philanthropist, and provided so much to Sag Harbor," McLean said.
The land surrounding the property by the pond is preserved, said listing agent Jennifer Ponzini, of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.
"It's beautifully landscaped," she said. "When buyers are walking back there, they call it serene."
As the home moves on to its next chapter, McLean's discoveries will always be cherished, Ponzini said.
"It still has its character, and I think the buyer is really going to appreciate that," she said.

The property also has a separate, legal studio space with kitchenette and bathroom. Credit: Rise Media /Cameron Burton

A heated in-ground pool sits beside the home's pool house. Credit: Rise Media /Cameron Burton

The home was renovated over two years. Credit: Rise Media /Cameron Burton

