Garden City 22, Carey 18

Garden City Justin Guterding reacts after his team stopped Carey on a dramatic fourth down from the 1-yard line in the fourth quarter of the Nassau II semifinals at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City's Brett Stewart drops back for a pass in the first quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Carey at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City Justin Guterding makes a catch in the third quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Carey at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City quarterback Brett Stewart throws a pass in the second quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Carey at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City Justin Guterding reacts after his team stopped Carey on a dramatic fourth down from the 1-yard line in the fourth quarter of the Nassau II semifinals at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City's Tim McDonagh fights for yards in the fourth quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Carey at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City's Justin Guterding reacts as the final seconds tick down on his team's 22-18 win over Carey in the Nassau II semifinals at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Carey quarterback Ray Catapano throws a pass in the first quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Garden City at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Garden City's Scott D'Antonio, left, breaks loose for an 84-yard rushing touchdown in the fourth quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Carey at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)

Carey's Matt Robison makes a catch in the third quarter of the Nassau II semifinals against Garden City at Hofstra University. (Nov. 17, 2012)