Colton Dixon told he 'looks pretty' when he sings on 'American Idol'

It's an obscure song, but fits him like a glove; wails out the opening lines, performs it like he wrote it. He's an authentic artist; knows his niche and does it well. Not really melodic and won't get your toe tapping, but a good performance.

"Wrong song for your voice and your passion," says Steven Tyler bluntly, didn't think the song went anywhere.