Deandre Brackensick and Hollie Cavanaugh in 'Idol' bottom three

Hope not. I had them both in the top four from last night.

This makes more sense -- they had Deandre Brackensick and Hollie Cavanagh come up on stage too. I think they're both going to be in the bottom three; they were for me.

Mentor Jimmy Iovine calls out the judges for pretending Brackensick was great last night; awesome, maybe it'll keep them honest.

Still, she helped make the show big; her season -- with winner Taylor Hicks, runner-up Katherine McPhee, should've-been-the-winner Chris Daughtry, Elliott Yamin, my fave Paris Bennett and Long Island's own Kevin Covais was when "Idol" hit its highest ratings, and in my opinion had its best mix of personalities.