Interesting take on the song; building to an emotional climax. It's right on the edge of over-the-top; but works for his personality and fans, I think. Wanted to love it, didn't, but enjoyed it.

OK, kind of an odd round of comments from the judges, like they didn't really know what to say.

Strong start, so easy to listen to. And effortlessly hitting the big notes, she has some serious vocal skills. Not wildly creative or anything but we want big and strong when it comes to Whitney, and she delivers.

"Dude, you nailed it," says Jackson. Lopez exults over her big voice, and Tyler just says, "That was really nice."

SUBSCRIBE

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

ACT NOWSALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME