Jeremy Rosado's sweet voice makes him a dark-horse favorite on 'American Idol'

Jeremy Rosado singing Sara Bareilles' "Gravity" next on "American Idol." Such a sweet voice for a big guy, with passion; has the girls screaming.

Hmm, I'm telling you, we have a dark horse right here, audience is transfixed, judges have their eyes closed listening -- a really strong performance, makes you smile listening. And such timing -- he's totally in control up there.

Again, overpraise for early mediocrity makes it harder for the judges to give this performance its due.

"That was beautiful, you couldn't have picked a better song," says Stephen Tyler.

Some people are just blessed, from God ... you open your mouth and immediately, I'm drawn in," says Jennifer Lopez. 

"I was so impressed with the tender moments, and the big booming vocals," says Randy Jackson. 

Agree? Disagree? Tell us in the comments below, or on Twitter using #ndidol.