Phillip Phillips and Joshua Ledet an 'unexpected treat' on 'American Idol'

Their duet last week was a failure, with no chemistry. This one's a little better; their voices worked pretty well together.

And there's some actual choreography, I guess. Instead of sitting the entire time, they take turns standing up.

They sing passionately, and then at each other separated by twin grand pianos -- but it just doesn't click for me.

I don't know, the judges this season just say whatever they want on this show; there's no connection to what we just saw.