Phillip Phillips and Joshua Ledet team up to sing Maroon 5's "This Love" next on "American Idol."

Their duet last week was a failure, with no chemistry. This one's a little better; their voices worked pretty well together.

And there's some actual choreography, I guess. Instead of sitting the entire time, they take turns standing up.

They sing passionately, and then at each other separated by twin grand pianos -- but it just doesn't click for me.

Steven Tyler says, "Everything about that was perfect." Jennifer Lopez also thought their voices melded surprisingly well, calls it "an unexpected treat."

Randy Jackson calls it "amazing."

I don't know, the judges this season just say whatever they want on this show; there's no connection to what we just saw.

Agree? Disagree? Tell us in the comments below, or on Twitter using #ndidol.

Top Stories