Zoanette Johnson gets standing ovation, Breanna Steer busts windows but Janelle Arthur 'flat' on 'American Idol'

"I dated a girl like that many years ago," cracks Keith Urban, who says he "loved it." Thinks the vibe was exactly right, "and you made me believe you could literally bust the windows out of my car." Nicki Minaj says she could go out and get a record deal right now; says "you were believable, you had your swag on." Randy Jackson calls it a "perfect" song choice, with Mariah Carey was loving how the contestants get to choose their own song in this round.

"I love that you have no clue what you're going to do," says Urban. "Kudos to the queen of the jungle." Minaj says, "you just served it." She says she loves how everyone from Liberia is going to get to watch her on the show, "you're the person we're going to remember after tonight -- you're unforgettable, you're a superstar." Johnson gets emotional, says she loves how the U.S. and this show gives people who come from nothing "a shot."