Experience an 1863 Thanksgiving at Old Bethpage Village

Celebrate the holidays at an 1863 Thanksgiving celebration at Old Bethpage Village Restoration on Nov. 21-22. Credit: Nassau County Department of Parks
Mary Donohue, of Massapequa Park, will play a pivotal role at the 1863 Thanksgiving at Old Bethpage Village Restoration on Nov. 21-22.
Donohue, a second-grade parochial schoolteacher wearing a 19th-century apron and work dress, will be rotating a 12-pound turkey on a spit over a crackling fire in a reflecting oven — an 18th-century, hand-operated rotisserie — inside one of the farmhouse kitchens. In other houses, 19th-century side dishes, soups and desserts will be prepared by costumed interpreters also using authentic 19th-century implements and methods.
"I think that the turkey cooked on the open hearth tastes better than a turkey cooked in an oven," says Donohue. "There’s a smoky flavor and it’s very juicy."
In addition to her cooking duties, Donohue will be taking questions from those who visit the house.
"We interpret the house and the people that lived here, and we talk about what the family who lived here did for a living," she says.
This is not a sit-down dinner or even a buffet, however. It’s for demonstration only, says Michael Butkewicz, supervisor of Old Bethpage Village Restoration. Although hearth-cooked vittles are lip-smacking delicious, according to those who’ve tried previous year’s efforts, guests can’t partake in the feast due to health regulations, Butkewicz says.

Mary Donohue demonstrates 19th-century cooking at Old Bethpage Village's Thanksgiving celebration. Credit: Old Bethpage Village Restoration
Butkewicz says the event is meant to give "a sense of how cooking was done in the 19th century when you didn’t have ovens and stoves, you had hearths, wood-fired stoves and beehive ovens. These were all cooking implements that were used during the 19th century," Butkewicz explains.
You can savor the sights, smells, sounds and ambiance of a Thanksgiving dinner. The meal honors the tradition that began in 1621, which eventually became a national holiday after President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed the last Thursday of November a national day of thanksgiving.
Here are four Restoration kitchens to see how the meals are made:
Williams Farm
Original location: New Hyde Park
What’s cookin’?: turkey
The 19th century farmhouse was owned by Henry Williams, a third-generation carpenter and housebuilder, Donohue says. "It has one of the nicest kitchens on the restoration," Butkewicz says.
Powell House and Farm
Original location: Old Bethpage
What’s cookin’? Two soups and applesauce cooked over an open fire.
The Powell Farmhouse "has a very large kitchen where people can walk in and see the demonstrations and move on and see the rest of house," including the dining room, parlor and a bedroom," Butkewicz says.

See how apple pie was made at The Conklin House. Credit: Nassau County Department of Parks
The Conklin House
Original location: Setauket
What’s cookin’? Different types of hearth cooking, including baking bread and apple pie in a beehive oven and an array of other traditional food.
The Conklin House "is my smallest house," Butkewicz notes of the onetime abode of a Long Island fisherman who worked as a wood carver in winter.

Visitors can explore historic structures, enjoy live music and purchase handmade goods. Credit: Nassau County Department of Parks
The Ritch Hat Shop and House
Original location: Middle Island
What’s cookin’? Mincemeat tarts
Ritch was a hat-maker and his hat shop is open next to his house.
"A docent talks about how the hats are made," Butkewicz says, "and you can order your own custom-made hat from on-site hatter Ken Quinn, choosing your style from the headgear on display." The hats are made in the village.
Fun around the village
Between kitchens, visit 12 of the 30 historic structures open for the day, including Layton General Store for $2 candy sticks; Noon Inn, a one-time East Meadow establishment, for a $1 birch beer or root beer; and the gift shop for handmade wicker baskets, crocheted animals and other Restoration and Long Island handmade goods. Live music will be performed on fiddles, banjos, concertina and an array of other 19th-century instruments in the farmhouses and throughout the grounds.
1863 Thanksgiving
Old Bethpage Village Restoration, 1303 Round Swamp Rd., Old Bethpage
WHEN 10 a.m.-4 p.m. Nov. 21-22
COST $15, $12 ages 5-12
MORE INFO 516-572-8409, oldbethpagevillagerestoration.org