Nassau jurors hear closing arguments in murder trial of Oumar Barry and Joel Badger

Oumar Barry listens to testimony in Nassau County Court in Mineola in October. Credit: Rick Kopstein
A cooperating witness who agreed to testify against fellow members of a violent Nassau County street gang could be the weak link in the trial of two men for the accidental fatal shooting of a Bronx schoolteacher, defense lawyers said Monday during closing arguments.
The getaway driver, who Newsday is not naming at the request of prosecutors because he is a witness in future gang cases, testified in the monthlong murder trial against reputed Afghan Blood Hound Brims street gang leader Oumar Barry and the alleged triggerman, Joel Badger, who was 17 at the time of the shooting.

Joel Badger is charged with murder in the fatal shooting of Bronx teacher Kimberly Midgette. Credit: Neil Miller
Nassau County prosecutors charged both men with second-degree murder, attempted murder, assault and several counts of weapons possession for the April 1, 2023 shooting death of elementary school teacher, Kimberly Midgette, 44, in Hempstead in front of her 10-year-old daughter.
On Monday, prosecutor Brian Rodriguez summed up his case against the two men, showing surveillance video, Flock camera license plate photos, text messages, ballistics analysis, cell tower data, DNA testing, police interrogation video and the testimony of the cooperating witness, who was 16 at the time of the shooting.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- Defense attorneys and a Nassau County prosecutor gave closing arguments in the murder case against Joel Badger and Oumar Barry, reputed members of the Afghan Blood Hound Brim street gang, for the shooting death of Bronx schoolteacher Kimberly Midgette
- Midgette was shot in the head in a case of mistaken identity as she dropped her 10-year-old daughter off on Polk Avenue in Hempstead on April 1, 2023
- Defense attorneys told the jury not to trust the testimony of a 16-year-old getaway driver, who took a plea deal in exchange for a lighter sentence for his role in the shooting
The teen took the stand to talk about the shooting and his life in the gang, telling the jury, “We do crime, all the time. We do nothing good.”
Prosecutors also charged him in the shooting, but he agreed to plead guilty in exchange for a promised 8-year prison sentence, cutting decades from his potential punishment if he went to trial.
According to the witness’s testimony, he drove a stolen black Honda past 29 Polk Ave. in Hempstead around 1:30 a.m. on the morning of the shooting, just as Midgette pulled up to the house of her ex with her friend and her daughter to drop the girl off for her weekend visitation.
He said that Badger, who sat in the passenger seat with a loaded 9 mm handgun, fired four shots into Midgette’s Toyota Corolla before they drove away.
Barry, the top-ranking Bloodhound Brim in Nassau County, had led the crew to the location in a separate car, a red Honda Civic, hoping to exact revenge on someone who had shot at him the night before, according to testimony.
The gang leader’s target had blond dreadlocks or braids, just like Midgette wore, who prosecutors said had no connection with the group.
The bullets hit the Bronx teacher in the jaw and forehead, killing her, prosecutors said. Her friend in the passenger seat was struck in the left arm, they said. The 10-year-old was not hit.

An undated photograph of Bronx schoolteacher Kimberly Midgette. Credit: SCDA
Both defense attorneys admitted that their clients had gang ties.
“I’m not going to get up here and say that Joel was a perfect angel. He was in a gang and took part in criminal activity,” Badger’s defense attorney Gregory Zak said, though he cautioned the jury during his closing statements to be skeptical of the cooperator’s testimony.
“He told the prosecution whatever would get him out of jail the quickest,” the lawyer said, pointing out that the teen had violated the terms of his cooperation agreement by getting arrested again after a fight in the Nassau County jail.
He told the jury that he had not breached the terms of his agreement during his testimony, Zak said, but then admitted under cross-examination he was rearrested.
“We have a witness that has shown a willingness to lie to protect his deal,” he said.
On the night of the shooting, Barry drove around with another man, Milton Allen, 22, who wore an ankle monitor with GPS tracking from a previous arrest.
Barry’s defense attorney, George Michel, questioned why the group would expect to pull off the crime and get away with it when one of their members was being tracked by law enforcement.
“He’s just bad at his job of being a gang leader,” the prosecutor responded in his closing. “He can’t do the shooting himself, so he got 16- and 17-year-old kids to do it for him.”
The jury is expected to beging deliberations on Tuesday.
Sag Harbor eyes limiting chain stores ... Biggest health insurance hike in decades ... Drop in holiday travel expected ... Which NY colleges have highest earnings for grads
Sag Harbor eyes limiting chain stores ... Biggest health insurance hike in decades ... Drop in holiday travel expected ... Which NY colleges have highest earnings for grads

