Judge refuses to dismiss the indictment, charges against 3 women from the same family charged in 7-year-old Jor'Dynn Duncan's death

Emily Kelly, left, Barbara Renner, middle, and Elyssa Seymore, right, are charged in connection with 7-year-old Jor'Dynn Duncan's death. Credit: SCDA
A Suffolk judge ruled Thursday that the criminal case will proceed to trial against the three women charged in connection with the alleged child abuse death of 7-year-old Jor’Dynn Duncan.
Supreme Court Justice John B. Collins denied defense motions to dismiss the indictment or reduce the charges against all three defendants — Bayport residents Emily Kelly, her mother Barbara Renner and Kelly’s daughter Elyssa Seymore – in written rulings. The judge also denied Kelly’s request for a separate trial.
“Disappointment but no surprises at all,” Kelly’s attorney John LoTurco told Newsday.
The judge granted the defendants’ requests for a Huntley Hearing to determine whether any statements they made to authorities will be admissible at trial.
The defendants were not present in Suffolk County Criminal Court in Riverhead Thursday for a pretrial conference in their case. The defendants are due back in court in January.
Kelly, who was engaged to Jor’Dynn’s father, Derrick Dixon, who was serving a prison sentence in Sing Sing Correctional Facility at the time of his daughter’s death, was granted custody of Jor’Dynn in April 2025.
Jor’Dynn died on Dec. 29. Prosecutors have said the girl had approximately 90 injuries on her body at the time of her death, including nine sharp-force injuries in and around her anus. She died from a massive infection, prosecutors have said.
Kelly, 50, Renner, 75, and Seymore, 24, were arrested May 20. Kelly has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder and other charges; Renner has pleaded not guilty to second-degree manslaughter and other charges and Seymore has pleaded not guilty to first-degree unlawful imprisonment and other charges.
They have said Jor'Dynn harmed herself in the aftermath of her biological mother ceasing contact.
Prosecutors have said Jor’Dynn reported her abuse to Bayport-Blue Point school officials as early as January 2025 and that Jor’Dynn missed more than 11 full weeks of school in her year living with the women in Bayport.
Jor’Dynn’s mother Portia Duncan has filed a $250 million lawsuit against Suffolk County, the Bayport-Blue Point Union Free School District, as well as individual county Child Protective Services workers and school officials for failing to protect Jor’Dynn.
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game


