View of the partially completed anerobic digester facility in Yaphank.

View of the partially completed anerobic digester facility in Yaphank. Credit: Newsday/Mark Harrington

A $120 million-plus project that promises to turn food waste into biofuels and fertilizer remains stalled in Yaphank, tangled in lawsuits and liens over alleged unpaid bills, even as its developer says he's getting close to finding new financial partners. 

American Organic Energy initially proposed the region's first anaerobic digester on the grounds of its parent company, Long Island Compost, more than a decade ago. The project promised to turn tons of food scraps otherwise sent to landfills into biogas, fertilizer and other sustainable products. It received a state loan of $55 million in 2023 from the New York Green Bank, a division of the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority, to build the plant, and potentially would benefit from a state law passed in 2022 that required restaurants and others send food scraps to such facilities.  

But after a high-profile groundbreaking in 2022 that included local lawmakers and environmental leaders, the project hit a roadblock involving ownership of the facility.

Since then, contractors and suppliers, including the fabricator of the main digester components, say American Organic Energy owes them for work and material in amounts ranging from $144,803 to more than $6 million, and several have filed liens on the Yaphank property, according to court records.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • A $120 million-plus project that promises to turn food waste into biofuels and fertilizer remains stalled in Yaphank, mired in lawsuits and liens, even as its developer says he's getting close to finding new financial partners. 
  • American Organic Energy proposed the region's first anaerobic digester on the grounds of its parent company, Long Island Compost, more than a decade ago. The project promised to turn tons of food scraps otherwise sent to landfills into biogas, fertilizer and other sustainable products.
  • But after a high-profile groundbreaking in 2022, the project hit a roadblock after one of the corporate partners in the project, Viridi, reportedly split from the co-owners at the Vigliotti family.

A spokeswoman for NYSERDA said the $55 million  “construction-to-term loan” to AOE “remains in place” and the Green Bank “continues to work with the borrower.”

“AOE remains responsible for its loan commitments,” the state agency said, directing questions about the loan to Charles Vigliotti, the chief executive of Long Island Compost and AOE. 

Vigliotti, in a statement to Newsday, said, “I intend to see this project through. It is too important for the State and too important for me personally to leave half-finished, and I am committed to ensuring its completion.”

He added he has “recently been in conversations with new investors, and I am optimistic that the capital will be available to move things forward.” The statement didn’t address the Green Bank loan.

In March, Vigliotti, in a Newsday interview, said all creditors would be paid and that he was working with new funding partners to advance the project. NYSERDA suggested Newsday also contact “Viridi Energy Operating LLC/Warburg Pincus,” an early partner in the project, regarding AOE payment and schedule-related questions. It's unclear what Viridi's current status is and a representative for Viridi didn't respond to calls seeking comment.

In March, Vigliotti said American Organic Energy "had to go back to our lenders and are in the process of working out the details of extending the whole credit package," adding at the time, "We are very close to getting that done." He expected the 2015-conceived project to restart construction work in the spring for an opening in 2027. "Everyone will be paid in full," he said in March, "contractors, subcontractors, everybody." He said the company had been "making certain progress payments as we’ve gone along."

More than $120 million has already been spent on the project, Vigliotti said. "We just need an increase in our funding, and our lenders have assured us [that] will be coming."

The digester project, which the state said would reduce CO2 emissions by 944,391 metric tons over its lifetime, garnered awards from environmental groups and considerable legislative support. LIPA at one point even approved an agreement to purchase electricity from the plant, but that plan was later scrapped. 

Among those filing suit against American Organic Energy and its Long Island Compost subsidiaries is Cleaver-Brooks, a Thomasville, Georgia-based fabricator of the main boiler for the project. According to its suit, filed in State Supreme Court in April, it submitted a bill for the boiler and related work of $574,255, but a balance of $344,553 remains. The company has filed liens to recoup the unpaid balance, plus interest, but AOE has “failed and refused to pay the balance due for the project,” Cleaver-Brooks’ lawyers wrote in the suit. 

Venture Engineering & Construction of Warrendale, Pennsylvania, another contractor for the project that was also sued by Cleaver-Brooks, filed an answer with the court denying the charges of unpaid bills and alleging the claims were barred by multiple laws. In addition, Venture filed a cross-claim against “all defendants” in the case, saying that if Cleaver-Brooks did suffer damages, those losses were “caused by the acts and/or omissions of the other defendants.” 

Earlier this year,  Newsday reported that Veolia WTS Systems USA of Trevose, Pennsylvania, filed suit against Venture, Long Island Compost, American Organic Energy and the Brookhaven Industrial Development Agency, saying it supplied more than $8.4 million in equipment for the anaerobic digester and performed additional labor at the site valued at $1.6 million for a total of $10 million, but was paid only $3.7 million. It’s seeking that sum plus interest and has filed a lien against the companies to recoup it.

Long Island Compost, in denying those claims, said in the event there is liability against it or its Great Gardens retail brand subsidiary, that liability “would be due to the misconduct of Venture, over which” Long Island Compost “had no influence, permission or control.”

Venture, in its answer to the suit, denied “each and every allegation.”

Another suit filed last year by a company known as West Rac, based in Hauppauge, said it’s owed $144,803.25 plus interest for material and labor to construct a visitor’s center at the digester site, but to date hasn’t been paid. A second Hauppauge company, Core Concepts Contracting, alleged in the suit it is owed $247,539.67 for concrete and masonry work at the site.

Calls to lawyers for each of the companies were not returned.

In another suit filed last year, Irving, Texas-based Consolidated Electrical Distributors, which does business as Mosebach Electrical Supply, filed suit against Venture, Long Island Compost, American Organic Energy and West Rac, among others, in claiming it is owed $372,020.83 plus interest for work and materials it performed at the site.

The accused companies denied those claims, and some filed counter claims.

MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Highest paid educators on LI ... Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'

MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Highest paid educators on LI ... Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME