The Brookhaven landfill looking south in August 2023.

The Brookhaven landfill looking south in August 2023. Credit: Newsday/Steve Pfost

The Brookhaven landfill’s required monitoring of methane and other environmentally damaging gases relies on incomplete inspections and equipment that has never been tested for efficacy, according to a recent report from an environmental group on New York’s largest landfills. 

Methane is a potent greenhouse gas that traps about 80 times more heat than carbon dioxide in the 20 years after its release. Other gases released from solid waste landfills, including sulfur dioxide, benzene and volatile organic compounds, pose health hazards to nearby communities.

The report, released by the research and advocacy group Full Circle Future, based in Washington, D.C., found methane emissions reported by landfills across the country are underestimates. It also noted several weaknesses in the Brookhaven landfill’s procedures for detecting and reporting these gases, like a number of other landfills. Federal rules require operators to monitor emissions from the entire facility, usually accomplished by a person walking along prescribed pathways, set 10 feet apart, with a handheld monitoring device, to ensure thorough coverage. But the testers are allowed to bypass areas that are on a steep slope or are otherwise possibly "dangerous."

Much of the Brookhaven landfill is steeply sloped, Kim Finlay, director of research and analytics at Full Circle Future and the author the report, pointed out. "That's actually where a lot of leaks are probably going to happen — where the pressure point is on the steep slopes," she said. And yet those are the spots that are "completely excluded from walking or monitoring."

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • A report from a D.C.-based research and advocacy group identified several weaknesses in the Brookhaven landfill’s procedures for detecting and reporting methane and other gases that pose hazards to the environment and human health.
  • Community groups have raised concerns for years about the health effects of air emissions, airborne ash, as well as contamination of groundwater.
  • Federal and state standards for air emissions monitoring and control for landfills should be strengthened and aligned with technological advances, the report suggests.

During a 2024 test, "63 of the 875 points on the landfill’s walking route were skipped," the report notes.

Finlay said there’s a simple fix: emissions can be identified via satellites and drones fitted with detecting equipment that fly over challenging areas to be sure nothing is missed.

Brookhaven Town spokesman Drew Scott told Newsday the Full Circle Future report "relies on outdated information and is riddled with inaccuracies, failing to reflect substantial upgrades, including a modern enclosed flare that destroys the referenced air pollutants with 99.7% efficiency."

"Through EPA-required stack testing, around-the-clock remote monitoring, and continued investment in modern technology, Brookhaven remains committed to protecting our environment and surrounding communities," Scott wrote in an email.

He said the report's figure for the population of Bellport was incorrect but did not respond to Newsday's question asking when the upgrades had been installed, and if and when the existing flare had been tested for efficacy, one of the criticisms in the report. 

Black liner capping material with green turf being installed at...

Black liner capping material with green turf being installed at the Brookhaven landfill on August 19, 2025. Credit: Michael A. Rupolo Sr.

A history of environmental concerns

Environmental hazards at the Brookhaven landfill have been a source of public controversy and federal and state scrutiny for years. The Department of Environmental Conservation imposed fines in 2018 for odor violations and two years later the Environmental Protection Agency sued the town over violations of the Clean Air Act going back 15 years. A 2023 Newsday investigation of a whistleblower complaint found the waste company Covanta ignored concerns about whether the ash it was dumping at the landfill might be hazardous.

Most recently, the town has been battling with the DEC over plans to remediate a hazardous plume spreading underground from the landfill. 

Residents and advocacy groups have likewise raised concerns about the health hazards of toxic emissions and airborne ash for years. The surrounding community of North Bellport is predominantly Black and Latino; emergency room visits for asthma are the second-highest in Suffolk County.

"Other communities are not being inundated with the same type of poor air quality," Monique Fitzgerald, co-founder of Brookhaven Landfill Action and Remediation Group, told Newsday this week.

Landfills use flares to burn off escaping methane, converting it to carbon dioxide and water vapor — a somewhat less potent contributor to global warming.

An enclosed flare, such as the one installed at the Brookhaven facility, is more efficient than the open type, Finlay said. But her report found the flare, in place since January 2021, "has never been tested to measure how much methane and other pollutants it actually destroys."

Finlay says her research suggests the amount of methane emissions that landfills nationwide report is "a huge, huge underestimate."

Her report concludes tighter federal rules on emissions, with more effective gas collection and detection of leaks, could cut methane emissions from landfills over the next 25 years by 46%. The decrease would be "equal to taking more than 80 million cars off the road every year."

"We believe that the regulations aren't strong enough," Fitzgerald said. "The Clean Air Act is a minimum — a bare minimum.

"There has to be a reversal of the impacts that the environment, the air, the animals, the people are experiencing for it to actually be effective."

Landfill operators often cite cost as a barrier to making improvements but Full Circle Future's research suggests the climate and health benefits outweigh the cost. Washington state upgraded its landfill emissions controls in 2024, for example, anticipating health and climate benefits of $595 million over 20 years against about $20 million in costs. 

The DEC is considering new state regulations to reduce emissions from landfills; a virtual public meeting on the subject will be held on  Dec. 17. Some states, such as Colorado and California, have already upgraded their rules, Fitzgerald noted.

The Brookhaven landfill, which generates roughly $30 million a year for the town, is expected to reach capacity in 2028, Town Supervisor Dan Panico has said, and will cease accepting more waste.

But the need for emissions monitoring and fixing leaks will continue for many years after, Finlay said.

MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Highest paid educators on LI ... Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'

MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Highest paid educators on LI ... Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME