As LIPA eyes more battery storage, LI developer envisions alternative method

A lithium-ion battery storage facility substation at 18 Cove Hollow Road in East Hampton is seen in 2023. Credit: James Carbone
As New York State doubles down on large energy-storage plants which could lead to a second wave of lithium-ion based projects and alternative battery technologies before the end of the decade, a Long Island entrepreneur is proposing one of the first plants using an alternative called flow-batteries.
Last week, the state announced a second bulk-energy storage solicitation, seeking projects that could add 1,000 megawatts of battery storage plants across the state by 2030. It expands on awards from the first round announced this summer that saw two of eight new projects awarded for Long Island -- in Holtsville and Manorville.
All are part of Gov. Kathy Hochul’s plan for 6,000 megawatts of battery storage by 2030, and come as Long Island continues to collectively resist the strategy with moratoriums in nearly all towns. Concerns here are based largely on reports of thermal runaway events at four New York plants in 2023, including one in East Hampton, where high levels of forever chemicals were reported earlier this month at a site dealing with a spreading toxic plume following fire suppression efforts.
The New York State Energy Research and Development Authority’s competitive solicitation announced on Nov. 12 is “open to a range of eligible storage technologies,” the agency said. Non-lithium batteries are eligible for 25-year contracts in the new solicitation, versus 15-year contracts for lithium-ion battery proposals, NYSERDA said in responses to Newsday.
- As New York State doubles down on soliciting for large energy-storage plants proposals, a Long Island entrepreneur is proposing one of the first plants using an alternative called flow-batteries.
- Last week, the state announced seeking projects that could add 1,000 megawatts of battery storage plants across the state by 2030.
- Meanwhile, Larry Siegel, a businessman from Wantagh with a background in energy finance, said he is in the early stages of developing a non-lithium ion battery storage project for eastern Long Island which would use flow-battery technology to provide 5 megawatts of storage for the grid.
NYSERDA’s NY Green Bank will help fund the new battery projects with a “range of financing options” to advance energy storage, the agency said, and its siting team will work “closely with local governments to provide tailored education, technical assistance and model local laws.”
LIPA expressed support for the state’s latest battery solicitation, saying in a statement that it “welcomes NYSERDA’s efforts to advance innovation in energy storage and help promising technologies become commercially viable options for meeting New York’s energy needs.”
Meanwhile, Larry Siegel, a businessman from Wantagh with a background in energy finance, said he is in the early stages of developing a non-lithium ion battery storage project for eastern Long Island which would use flow-battery technology to provide 5 megawatts of storage for the grid.
Siegel, in an interview, said his newly formed Tobay Energy has identified a location for the plant on a site less than an acre. He said he recently met with PSEG Long Island, which runs the grid under contract to LIPA, about connecting his project to the electric grid. It could be ready by 2028, he said.
Flow batteries use liquid electrolytes rather than solid lithium-ion cells to store energy, using zinc bromine or vanadium to the store power for up to four hours of discharge onto the grid. Batteries can help stabilize the grid in the face of intermittent energy from solar and wind arrays, one of the reasons they are crucial as LIPA prepares to make way for up to 924-megawatts of wind energy early next year.
Siegel said he’s still finalizing a design and specific manufacturer for the project, and that much will depend on the cost of connecting to local power lines.
“All over Long Island, there’s a demand for a large number of these batteries, but it’s just very hard to build them because of the moratoriums,” Siegel said, noting that Islip Town recently approved a ban on batteries over a certain size that could nix a LIPA contract for a 79-megawatt battery. “Even Brookhaven is not in a rush to approve them,” Siegel said of the town where multiple projects have been proposed because it has a special zone for batteries and no moratorium. More recently, town supervisor Dan Panico has assured concerned residents nothing will be approved until the town is sure they are safe.
Siegel said flow batteries are not subject to thermal runaway fires that lithium batteries are, and said they are already in use in the state and across the country. He pointed to a July contract awarded to manufacturer Eos Energy to build zinc-based battery storage systems for a “Golden Dome for America” defense system for the U.S. Department of War.
“It’s going to cost me more” to work with flow-energy batteries, Siegel said. “There’s less profit in it because the costs are higher, but I think it’s the way to go.” The Wantagh resident, who said he previously worked for the U.S. Department of Energy, grew up in Patchogue.
“I know the market, I see other site locations that will never get built,” said Siegel, who has attended community meetings where residents have objected to lithium-ion batteries. “I know what’s going on out here. There are a lot of projects that have been abandoned on Long Island.”
His proposed flow battery of 5 megawatts has challenges, he acknowledged. “I do have a hurdle to convince investors about these flow batteries,” he said. “They have questions. That’s because they know lithium. I did the analysis. I think [flow-battery technology] works.
Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends
Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends
