Riverhead IDA threatens to recapture tax break from Scott's Pointe operator

Owner Eric Scott opened the indoor-outdoor recreation facility in 2023. Credit: Elizabeth Sagarin
The Riverhead Industrial Development Agency could move to recapture tax benefits granted to a Calverton adventure park following delayed payments and other compliance issues, officials said.
IDA board members agreed at the agency's Nov. 2 meeting to warn Island Water Park, the operator of Scott’s Pointe, that future overdue payments in lieu of taxes, or PILOTs, would lead to enforcement without a grace period. The park has a 10-year PILOT agreement with the IDA.
The stern warning comes after the company submitted an overdue PILOT on Oct. 5, according to board chairman James Farley. The annual deadline under the company’s agreement with the IDA is Jan. 31. Late payments are subject to a 5% penalty, plus additional interest of 1% per month overdue, according to the agreement. At the Nov. 2 meeting, officials said they have an outstanding balance of approximately $1,800.
“What it boils down to is noncompliance,” Farley said in an interview, noting that the board has been lenient with the company. “The agency’s goal is to support businesses trying to locate and grow in Riverhead, and so you try to be tolerant of them as they go through their trials … I think it’s fair to say that [Island Water Park] did have some difficulties … but compliance is just a requirement of the agency.”
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- The Riverhead IDA is warning Scott's Pointe that continued delayed payments in lieu of taxes and noncompliance could trigger the agency to recapture tax benefits.
- The warning comes after the company submitted an overdue PILOT on Oct. 5, according to the IDA board chairman.
- The Calverton adventure park, which opened in 2023, has received nearly $1.4 million in net tax exemptions from 2022 to 2025, according to reports filed with the state.
Earlier issues settled
Owner Eric Scott opened the indoor-outdoor recreation facility, which features a surf pool, rock climbing and aqua park on a manmade lake, in 2023. The following year, he encountered legal issues with Riverhead over what the town claimed was an illegally built go-kart track and pickleball courts.
He has since settled with the town and received approvals for those features, along with a new zip line and to allow battery-powered watercraft on the lake.
The Aqua park at Scott's Pointe in August 2025. Credit: Morgan Campbell
Scott, in an interview, acknowledged the payments were late but said delays and town bureaucracy have been challenging to navigate. He said he had not received a warning letter from the IDA yet as of Thursday.
“I still made all my payments,” Scott said. “We were struggling and we were trying to figure out what our next move was because the town was torturing us. That’s why they were late,” he said.
Scott said the tax incentives help offset substantial operating costs at the park. The adventure park is open year-round but he plans to open the newly permitted amenities, including the zip line, in 2027. “This will be our first spring fully operational,” he said.
The IDA did not specify how many previous PILOT payments have been late, but the agency warned the company in 2024 about losing its benefits due to the permitting issues, a late PILOT payment and falling short of employment projections.
Board frustrations
At recent IDA meetings, board members expressed frustration with what they described as a pattern.
“I think the board is generally frustrated with their repeated noncompliance,” Lee Mendelson, a board member, said at the IDA's Nov. 2 meeting. “I don’t think we should go through this every year.”
Board member Lori Pipczynski urged the board to consider recapturing benefits. “I’d like to have canceled the project already,” she said Nov. 2.
Pipczynski has opposed the benefits since they were first granted in 2021. Last year, she voted against an amended application for benefits based on changes to the scope of the project and reduced employment numbers.
At the time, Pipczynski said her concerns included “unrealistic” job creation numbers and failure to submit compliance reports and payments on time. “Given this track record, I have little confidence that the commitments outlined in an amended application would be honored,” she said at the time.
Scott’s Pointe received nearly $1.4 million in net tax exemptions from 2022 to 2025, according to reports filed with the state Authorities Budget Office. The company paid $221,753 in PILOTs through that year, according to the reports.
Under state law, IDA agencies have the authority to recover previously granted tax benefits if companies fail to meet agreed-upon terms and conditions, including creating the number of jobs promised or failing to submit required reports or payments.
'At any moment something could happen' In such a car-dependent place, agents' road tactics have brought new risk to the daily routines of many Latino drivers. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa and Newsday investigative reporter Josefa Velásquez have more on this story.
'At any moment something could happen' In such a car-dependent place, agents' road tactics have brought new risk to the daily routines of many Latino drivers. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa and Newsday investigative reporter Josefa Velásquez have more on this story.