Garden City junior Catherine McTiernan is challenged for possession of...

Garden City junior Catherine McTiernan is challenged for possession of the ball by Manhasset senior Nicole Sockett during the Nassau Class B final at Hofstra. (June 1, 2011) Credit: Christopher Pasatieri

You ever look at those LaxPower, MaxPreps and ESPN Rise national rankings and think, "OK, but it's kind of arbitrary"? They are a pretty good gauge - and the best we've got on a national scope - but without those teams playing each other there's always room for debate. We've all heard or made some form of despite-the-rankings argument: "___ has played tougher competition" or " ___ could beat ___ head-to-head." A prime example is the hypothetical Garden City versus McDonogh argument.

Well, after next Saturday there'll be a little less need for such conjecture.
Garden City, St. Anthony's and Hauppauge will square off against Maryland's best teams in the New York-Maryland Challenge at St. Paul's School for Girls in Brooklandville, MD. The Trojans, Friars and Eagles are arguably Long Island's top teams - they are in Newsday's Big 10 rankings, at least - and they're all nationally ranked.

Laxageddon! (I know that one's terrible, but I'm going with it anyway.)

Hauppauge will face St. Paul's at 10 a.m.: Hauppauge is ranked No. 11 in the country and St. Paul's No. 25, according to ESPN Rise.

St. Anthony’s against Bryn Mawr at noon: St. Anthony's is ranked fourth in the country and Bryn Mawr is No. 3.

West Genesee vs. John Carroll at 2 p.m. (It's a "NY-MD" challenge so it couldn't be all Long Island teams. Although an argument could be made...)

Garden City vs. McDonogh at 4 p.m: This, of course, has the "main event" billing as it's been years in the making (waiting). McDonogh finished last season ranked No. 1 in ESPN Rise's and LaxPower's polls, and Garden City was No. 2 in both. They're one-two in ESPN's 2012 ranking.

Get the latest news and more great videos at NewsdayTV Credit: Newsday

LI Catholic group's challenge to diocese ... Out East: Jamesport Country Store ... This week's weather outlook ... Get the latest news and more great videos at NewsdayTV

Get the latest news and more great videos at NewsdayTV Credit: Newsday

LI Catholic group's challenge to diocese ... Out East: Jamesport Country Store ... This week's weather outlook ... Get the latest news and more great videos at NewsdayTV

SUBSCRIBE

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

ACT NOWSALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME