The Long Island Arena in Commack closed its doors 25 years ago. Newsday takes a look back at the historic arena. Marissa Sarbak reports.  Credit: Newsday / Reece T. Williams; Photo Credit: AP Photo; AP Photo/IS; AP Photo/DM; Walter del Toro; Music Credit: Universal Music/Reece T. Williams; Photo Credit: AP Photo; AP Photo/IS; AP Photo/DM; Walter del Toro; Music Credit: Universal Music

Before there was Nassau Coliseum, there was the Long Island Arena. In 1959, Suffolk County birthed its first arena at 88 Veterans Memorial Highway in Commack. The building was a constant source of entertainment hosting sporting events (hockey, basketball), concerts, political rallies, a flea market and even the circus. But more importantly the building had a personal connection to its attendees who felt a kinship to the 4,000-seat venue, which closed permanently 25 years ago on July 31, 1996.

"When you walked in the place, you felt like there was something special going on," says Paul Blake, 67, of East Meadow. "There was a vibe in the building."

Eric Lowenhar, 54, of Greenlawn adds, "For suburbia, it was incredible. It felt intimate like you were connected to the players or performers. Even if you had a bad seat, it was still pretty good."

The signature arched roof gave the building a unique look but the accommodations inside were rudimentary.

"There wasn’t anything luxurious about it. It was a big barn basically," says Paul Charles, 61, who is originally from Commack but currently lives in Long Beach. "The whole place was made out of wood. You could get splinters from the walls and always feel the cold coming up from the ice."


Sen. John F. Kennedy during his speach at Long Island Arena...

Sen. John F. Kennedy during his speach at Long Island Arena in Commack on Nov. 6, 1960. Credit: Newsday File Photo/Marvin Sussman

During the 1960 presidential election, both candidates John F. Kennedy and Richard M. Nixon held rallies at the Long Island Arena along the campaign trail. Nixon appeared on Sept. 28, 1960 while Kennedy came on Nov. 6, 1960 two days before Election Day.

"I remember Kennedy arrived in an open convertible car. The crowd was huge. We had flags that we waved that said ‘JFK/LBJ’ and we were all wearing campaign buttons," says Christina Paino, 68, of Hauppauge, who attended at age 8 with her father Tony Mirro, a committeeman in the Smithtown Democratic Party. "Kennedy spoke from a platform that was built in the stands. We were within two or three rows of it. When he won the presidency it was like, ‘I saw the president of the United States!’ "

Vice President Richard M. Nixon holds his wife Pat with...

Vice President Richard M. Nixon holds his wife Pat with one arm and waves the other  at a Long Island Arena campaign appearance on Sept. 28, 1960. Credit: AP/Henry Griffin


A souvenir LI Ducks puck from the collection of David...

A souvenir LI Ducks puck from the collection of David Tochterman, who grew up in Commack. Credit: David Tochterman

Eastern Hockey League franchise The Long Island Ducks was the anchor tenant for the Long Island Arena after the venue opened in 1959. The team was known for its rough and tumble approach to the sport.

"The hockey fights were notorious," says Michael Davern, 61, of Commack. "You would even see brawls in the hallways of the arena. It was the wild west back then."

Part of the raucous fun came from the fans’ involvement in each game.

"You were really in it because there was no plexiglass around the sides of the rink," says Charles. "The players would get checked against the boards and land in your lap."

Members of the Long Island Ducks hockey team at the...

Members of the Long Island Ducks hockey team at the Commack Arena on October 13, 1971.  Credit: Newsday File Photo/Walter del Toro

Peter DeMarco, 73, of Medford says, "Without anything on the sideboards, you could get hit with a stick or a puck. People in the first row used to wear football helmets. It was nutty."

The Ducks spawned stars like defenseman John Brophy and left winger Buzz Deschamps.

"The league was very intense. If you ever watched the [1977 Paul Newman] movie, ‘Slap Shot’ — that was it," says Deschamps, 81, of Long Beach. "When John Brophy came to the Ducks, he said to me, ‘You put the puck in the net and I’ll take care of the rest.’ Our defensemen were some tough cookies. There weren’t too many teams that messed with us."

John Brophy,  coach of the Long Island Ducks , watches...

John Brophy,  coach of the Long Island Ducks , watches the game action from the sidelines at the Long Island Arena on February 23, 1968. Credit: Newsday File Photo/Bob Luckey

The Ducks won the Eastern Hockey League North Division in 1964-65 and 1965-66. On April 7, 1965 the team won the Walker Cup making them the EHL champions.

"The fans were so involved with the team it was crazy," says Blake. "The players on the ice could hear individual fans yelling at them and they would acknowledge the ones that were giving them grief."

After the Ducks came the brief tenure of the Long Island Cougars from 1973-75.

"The Cougars had potential, but the Eastern Hockey League folded because of rapid NHL [National Hockey League] expansion. The minor leagues couldn’t survive," says DeMarco. "The salaries were skyrocketing and they couldn’t keep up."

The Long Island Cougars, LI's last minor-league hockey team on the...

The Long Island Cougars, LI's last minor-league hockey team on the ice during the 1973-74 season at the Long Island Arena. Credit: Paul Blake

All the focus went to the New York Islanders at the newly opened Nassau Coliseum in Uniondale during 1972.

"The Long Island Arena was primitive in comparison to the Coliseum," says Blake. "The Coliseum was a shining jewel. It looked like fantasyland with a beautiful concourse around the outside, good lighting and comfortable seats."


.Peter Frampton performed at the Island Music Center (as the...

.Peter Frampton performed at the Island Music Center (as the Long Island Arena was briefly known) on August 24, 1975 where he recorded part of his multi platinum double live album, "Frampton Comes Alive!."  Credit: Mike Finnegan

In addition to hockey, the Long Island Arena was known for its concerts, which drew big acts such as Frank Zappa, Blue Öyster Cult, Black Sabbath, the Bee Gees, Styx and more.

"You really didn’t have to go to Madison Square Garden. There was so much right there," says Vic Berretta, 60, who grew up in Commack. "Nobody wanted to spend the money to drive into the city. You couldn’t ask for anything better."

The Who played Long Island for the first time when they headlined the arena on Dec. 1, 1967.

"I was so close to the stage I could see the rubber bands in bassist John Entwistle’s mouth for his braces," says Mark Cheron, 68, who grew up in Commack. "The show was really loud. My ears were ringing for two days!"

Back in 1975, Hot Tuna played a record long show at the venue running over six hours ending at 2 a.m.

"People were falling asleep in their seats and waking up screaming, ‘TUNA!’ " says Steven Gianturco, 63, of Holbrook. "I remember guitarist Jorma Kaukonen stopping in the middle of a solo to tie his shoes. My friends and I were hysterical over that for years."

But perhaps the most famous show was when singer/guitarist Peter Frampton opened for Ten Years After on August 24, 1975, which was partially recorded for his multiplatinum double live album, "Frampton Comes Alive!" released in 1976.

"Peter Frampton just blew everybody away and no one expected him to be as good as he was," says Clay Connor, 61, who grew up in Smithtown. "Classic rock radio still plays 2-3 different cuts from that album. Whenever it comes on and I’m with a group of people, I’ll say, ‘I was at that show!’ "


Circus music director Jim Haverstrom, who grew up in Commack,...

Circus music director Jim Haverstrom, who grew up in Commack, took pictures of his wife Lillian and 2 year-old son Kyle riding an elephant by the Big Top of the Clyde Beatty Cole Bros. Circus in the parking lot of the Long Island Arena in 1989. Credit: Jim Haverstrom

One attraction that came to the Long Island Arena annually was the Clyde Beatty Cole Bros. Circus. This three-ring attraction would be held in a giant tent six-stories high the length of a football field outside the venue.

"They would let the elephants parade in from a distance. It was really cool to have the animals come to us," says Nancy Roth, 62, who grew up in Commack. "I remember seeing jugglers and the ringleader, who was dressed in a Gene Wilder-like costume."

Commack native Jim Haverstrom served as the circus’ musical director from 1988-1996.

"Playing my hometown was really cool. My parents and high school friends would all come out to support," says Haverstrom, 61. "My job was to sync up the music with what was going on in the show."


Former St. John's star Tony Jackson of the NY Nets...

Former St. John's star Tony Jackson of the NY Nets in 1968 at the Long Island Arena.(A few years later, the same uniform number would be worn and later retired by Julius "Dr. J"  Erving, the greatest Nets player of all time. Credit: Newsday File Photo/Rex Lyons

Before they landed in New Jersey and then Brooklyn, the New York Nets(who actually began as the New Jersey Americans) called the Long Island Arena home for one season, 1968-1969. The American Basketball Association team also played locally at the old Island Garden in West Hempstead and Nassau Coliseum. (The Long Island Arena was also home in 1962 for the New York Tapers of the short-lived American Basketball League, the organization that introduced the three-point shot to pro hoops.)

John Newman, 65, of Commack sold subscriptions for Newsday as a young man. One day along his route, he made a sale to Nets guard Bobby Lloyd, who befriended him.

"Bobby used to give me free tickets to the games and the team’s signature red, white and blue basketballs," says Newman. "Later in the year he took me in the locker room to get all the players’ autographs and shake their hands."


Buzz Deschamps poses for a portrait during a Long Island...

Buzz Deschamps poses for a portrait during a Long Island Ducks reunion of the Eastern Hockey League team at Miller's Ale House in Commack on, August 10, 2019. Credit: James Escher

Toward the end of its run, the Long Island Arena turned into a flea market that featured hundreds of vendors spread across the arena floor and around the outer corridor.

"You could get anything there from socks to electronics to food to jewelry to baseball cards," recalls Lance Koppell, 58, of Huntington Station. "The variety was amazing."

Berretta says, "Even though you could score some real good deals it was kind of a downer because they weren’t doing anything there anymore. The shows were gone and the stands were empty. It was a bit depressing."

On July 31, 1996, the Long Island Arena closed down to make way for a $25 million dollar shopping center, the Veterans Memorial Plaza. Today Miller’s Ale House occupies the actual address of the arena (and was the site of a 2019 reunion of several Ducks players and their fans).

"Growing up in Commack the Long Island Arena was the greatest place to go. When I heard they were knocking it down, I felt kind of sad," says Paino. "It was like the end of an era."


Aside from hockey and basketball, the Long Island Arena hosted a variety of different sporting events from time to time.

Boxing Local club fights and closed-circuit professional bouts were regularly shown.

“They would have matches on a big black & white projected screen,” says Michael Davern, 61, of Commack. “But, it was always a packed house like it was a live fight.”

Wrestling - Although Madison Square Garden had the big matches, the Long Island Arena held the second tier wrestling cards.

“I remember seeing Johnny Valentine as well as world champion Buddy ‘Nature Boy’ Rogers,” says Peter DeMarco, 73, of Medford. “Bruno Sammartino and Bob Backlund were also big draws on Long Island.”

Roller Derby - A regular attraction was the wild game of roller derby, which was played on a ramped wooden track with a wrap around railing.

“The games were scripted. It was like wrestling on wheels,” says Paul Blake, 67, of East Meadow. “It was intense because they would whip around the track and try to knock each other over the railing. It was a very physical game but a lot of it was choreographed.” - DAVID J. CRIBLEZ

Newsday LogoDON'T MISS THIS LIMITED-TIME OFFER1 5 months for only $1Save on Unlimited Digital Access