Judge upholds ruling in Ground Zero fire case

Three construction company figures have lost their bid to get a judge to dismiss a manslaughter case in a blaze that killed two firefighters at a contaminated Ground Zero tower.  

Friday’s ruling means Mitchel Alvo, Salvatore DePaola and Jeffrey Melofchik are headed toward a trial in the August 2007 fire at the former Deutsche Bank building. They have pleaded not guilty.

The men say they were unfairly blamed for a fire fueled by others’ failures. But prosecutors say the men knew about and covered up a break in a crucial firefighting water pipe, and that was a critical factor in the firefighters’ deaths.   

The building — just across the street from the World Trade Center’s south tower — was heavily damaged and filled with toxic debris when the tower collapsed into it on Sept. 11, 2001. A laborious process of dismantling the now government-owned building has taken years.

On Aug. 18, 2007, a construction worker’s careless smoking
sparked a fire that tore through several stories of the building.   

Firefighters contended with a roster of hazards, including
deactivated sprinklers, blocked stairwells, an air system that was
supposed to control toxins but ended up concentrating smoke, and a
break in a crucial firefighting water pipe called a standpipe.

With the standpipe severed, it took 67 minutes for the firefighters to get water by other means to fight the blaze.   

Firefighters Robert Beddia and Joseph Graffagnino became trapped
on the burning 14th floor. They died of smoke inhalation after
their oxygen tanks ran out.

The standpipe had broken during asbestos removal work in the building’s basement in November 2006, Manhattan prosecutors say.   

Alvo, Galt’s director of abatement, and DePaola, a Galt foreman, ultimately had a 42-foot-long section of the standpipe cut up and removed from the building, according to prosecutors. Melofchik, site safety manager for general contractor Bovis Lend Lease, filled out checklists saying the building’s fire suppression equipment was working despite the broken standpipe, prosecutors say.

“While [the three men] choose to point their fingers at other entities who they claim bear responsibility for the deaths of the two firefighters, this case is about these defendants and their actions that caused two deaths and nearly caused numerous others,” Assistant District Attorney Noah D. Genel wrote in court papers in May.

Defense lawyers say the men didn’t realize the pipe was a standpipe — and they note that a raft of inspectors never flagged it. Regardless, the attorneys argue, the broken standpipe wasn’t the key cause of the firefighters’ deaths. They point to the many other hazards and failures that prosecutors and city officials have acknowledged.

 “Why are they scapegoating a few defenseless people at the bottom of the line?” Melofchik’s lawyer, Edward J.M. Little, asked a judge at a hearing in July.

When the case was unveiled in December 2008, then-District
Attorney Robert Morgenthau pointedly said there was blame to go
around among the maze of government agencies and companies that had worked at the building during its dismantling.

The fire department hadn’t inspected the building in more than a year, although it was supposed to do so every 15 days. Other city and state regulators also had been in the tower on a near-daily basis but didn’t report the hazards.

But Morgenthau said prosecuting officials would be fruitless because governments are generally immune from criminal prosecutions.   

The city agreed to fire safety reforms, and Bovis agreed to pay the firefighters’ families $10 million in a memorial fund.