Neighbors Fred Lloyd, James Robinson and Nathan Bright stand in...

Neighbors Fred Lloyd, James Robinson and Nathan Bright stand in front of an abandoned property in New Cassel, which is hidden from street view by overgrown bushes that are full of poison ivy. (July 28, 2012) Credit: Judy Cartwright

So, just what are the chances of converting a neighborhood eyesore into a good neighbor?

Watchdog tried to find the answer after the Town of Oyster Bay demolished an abandoned house in Farmingdale in June. Such a teardown is not typical, and that one was years in the making, coming after a town engineer deemed the house a hazard. The town got the go-ahead when it notified the bank that it intended to raze the site -- the house was in foreclosure -- and the bank did not object.

Properties wind up abandoned for a variety of reasons -- foreclosure, death of the owner, divorce are among them. And sometimes owners who have moved away just want to hold on to a property here.

The presence of such unmaintained houses is growing as the foreclosure crisis continues, said Christopher Niedt, academic director of the National Center for Suburban Studies at Hofstra University.

And that translates into more and more neighborhoods left with an eyesore in their midst -- and residents wondering why more of them can't be restored or razed or even condemned by the municipality.

Most towns and villages we've spoken with say their goal is straightforward: to get code violations corrected. That means getting the grass cut, litter and junk vehicles removed, holes that let in rain and vermin covered. But even when violations are corrected, they often don't stay corrected, as evidenced by the properties we've seen.

In an effort to resolve problem properties more quickly, some towns and villages have adopted stricter blight ordinances that carry more severe penalties.

Still, the process can last for years, sometimes decades. To understand why, we turned to Niedt:

"There are legal requirements that provide safeguards to homeowners but that also delay local action against vacant homes," Niedt said. "And it's a difficult balance to strike."

So there is no easy answer. For now, here's a look at four properties in various states of distress and the prospects for their return to good neighbor status. They're just a few of the dozens that readers have flagged. Watch for more in coming weeks.

 

Until the blight law was enacted, the property's condition allowed the town only to prohibit occupancy, Carter said. "We couldn't allow somebody to live in the house, but as something of an eyesore in the neighborhood there was nothing more we could have done," he said.

 

Village Manager Shawn Cullinane said the village would arrange for another cleanup and a replacement tarp; such work requires authorization of the village board.

 

"It is one of the worst eyesores I have ever seen," village resident James Giordano wrote Watchdog. The mayor concurs: "It has become an eyesore and a blight."

 

The town's procedure calls for issuing three such notices before the highway department cleans up the property. The cost of the work is charged to the owner.

The latest notices of violation follow one in April that cited the presence of litter, which Nash said had been addressed.

Nassau County is also involved with the property; it took over a strip along one side for nonpayment of taxes, county spokesman Brian Nevin said, and has been trying to sell it to get the property back onto tax rolls.

Loading video…

PLUS: Working Moms: Making friends and Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

Updated now 2026 Holiday gift guide, Working Moms: Making friends and Out East: Bedell Cellars. Here's a look at some of the exclusive stories you may have missed this week on NewsdayTV.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME