Average homebuyers are 40, NAR says. Here's advice from Long Island pros, no matter your age.

Long Island real estate pros Juan Guillermo Roa, left, Lynda Olita, top, and Rylan Jacka gave their advice for buyers in any phase of their journey. Credit: TILRE Media; Douglas Elliman Real Estate; Kelli Hull Photography
Homeowners are staying put longer, and the age of first-time homebuyers is older than ever before, according to findings from the National Association of Realtors.
While this plays out nationwide, local real estate agents have seen similarities here in Long Island's housing market, due to factors including high interest rates and generational competition.
The National Association of Realtors (NAR) released their 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, which surveyed thousands of buyers across the country in the 12-month period ending in June.
It found that the median age of first-time buyers is 40, the highest ever recorded by the NAR, and that more retirees have entered the market as buyers this year.
Lynda Olita, an agent with Douglas Elliman Real Estate in Huntington, has seen retirees and millennials competing against each other as buyers. She knows several seniors that moved from Long Island to another state, and are now coming back to the Island — most often to be closer to their children and grandchildren — and others that have remained in the region to downsize.
"Retirees are not flying off to other states like everybody thought," Olita said. "Instead, they may go out east and buy a smaller place."
This year, U.S. homebuyers also said they expect to live in their homes for a median of 20 years, and 26% of purchasers said they will never move, based on the NAR's findings.
Olita said this has created a "vicious cycle" on Long Island.
"Retirees are not moving, so first-time buyers don't have the amount of inventory that they would normally have," she said. "So the moving-up market has shifted quite a bit."
Olita has seen retirees and first-time buyers alike going head-to-head over ranch-style homes, a highly desired architectural style on Long Island due to its maintainable layout.
Juan Guillermo Roa, a real estate agent with The Agency in Huntington, has noticed another competitive niche in the past year: Long Islanders are prioritizing homes close to bustling downtown areas, such as the main drags in Oyster Bay, Huntington and Bay Shore.
"People that were able to have homes closer to villages who are older, they're holding onto those houses more often," Roa said. "That's why there's competition: When one comes out, it's so crazy because they don't come that often."
High interest rates and the cost of construction have limited current homeowners from seeking out new properties on the East End, said Rylan Jacka, managing director of The Agency in East Hampton.
"When the interest rates were really low, people had no fear of moving around and selling, buying something," he said. "And now you have to think long and hard about that."
Roa doesn't foresee these conditions changing too soon: "In 2027, I do see it still being a seller's market for a little while," he said. "If a house is ready to move in, there's a big market for that, no matter where it is."
If you're a first-timer

Credit: TILRE Media
Name
Juan Guillermo Roa
Job
Real estate agent with The Agency in Huntington
Advice
Look early, up to a year in advance
First-time buyers should "start looking early" for their home, Roa said, even up to a year in advance.
"If you love a home now, let's see when it goes on the market, when it goes under contract and what the price difference is between now and then, so you have a better understanding of what you would offer for that home based on comps. That way, they're a little more prepared," Roa said.
If you're a senior...

Credit: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Name
Lynda Olita
Job
Agent with Douglas Elliman Real Estate in Huntington
Advice
Keep an open mind, consider looking further east
Seniors in these situations should keep an open mind during their home search: "We may not be able to get them right back into a location that they left," said Olita. "They may have to look at various areas further out east, as opposed to closer to city lines, or condos and two-bedroom homes."
Anyone who wants to buy...

Credit: Kelli Hull Photography
Name
Rylan Jacka
Job
Managing director of The Agency in East Hampton
Advice
'Be careful and do all your homework.'
Researching neighborhoods and how they may evolve is important for all buyers, Jacka said, particularly on the East End.
"I think when you're in a period of time like now where people tend to hold onto their houses a lot longer because of interest rates or the economy, you want to know that you're in an area where your house is appreciating. So it's really important to know how those different neighborhoods have performed over time, and a good broker can help you with all that data," he said. "My advice would be to be careful and do all your homework."

