Knicks vs. Heat: What to watch for in Eastern Conference semifinal series

Knicks coach Tom Thibodeau argues a call during the second half of Game 2 of the team's NBA basketball first-round playoff series against the Cleveland Cavaliers, Tuesday, April 18, 2023, in Cleveland. Credit: AP/Ron Schwane
When the Knicks and Heat met three times in a span of less than a month late in the season, the hard-fought games seemed almost like a playoff series. But nothing in the regular season really feels like playoff intensity — and no playoff series comes with the intensity that the Knicks and Heat once brought, even if it happened before some of the current players were born. The two teams once had four straight seasons of series that went the limit.
“When we played them here, it was all tough, physical games,” Josh Hart said of the three meetings after he came over in a trade-deadline deal. “Definitely had a little bit of that vibe. I think if you asked me then, I would have said yes [it had playoff intensity]. If you ask me that now after actually finally experiencing the playoffs, I would say not as much. These two styles, they’re very similar and they’re very tough, very gritty. It’s going to be a good series.”
So even if this doesn’t feel like a continuation of the regular-season battles or a throwback to the late 1990s, it figures to be a battle in a way that none of these players have experienced. Here’s what to watch for as the series begins:
DON’T LET THE
BUTLER DO IT
The Knicks spent the opening round determined not to let Donovan Mitchell beat them, throwing defenders at him from all angles, determined to get the ball out of his hands. Now they figure to take the same approach against Butler. Quentin Grimes and Hart took nearly an equal amount of time as the primary defender, with Hart slightly more effective, but the Knicks will use the whole team to get the ball out of his hands.
RANDLE STATUS
Make no mistake about it — the Knicks need a healthy Julius Randle no matter the round. He is one of only two players who regularly can force defenses to double-team, which creates open shots. But if there is a team in the postseason against which Obi Toppin can flourish with open three-pointers and runouts, it could be the Heat. Kevin Love will not blow by Toppin, who is quick enough to handle him on the perimeter and, the Knicks hope, ready for the screens and switches. If Grimes is healthy and can handle Butler, that frees up Hart for some time at power forward.
IN THE SPOTLIGHT
Jalen Brunson and Butler are made for these moments. But the others? When the Knicks opted to limit Mitchell and allow the Cavs’ complementary players to try to beat them in the opening round, those players wilted, particularly in the games at Madison Square Garden. The Heat, with Tyler Herro and Victor Oladipo out of action, are filled with undrafted players who have made their way into the rotation, but none seem to be the type to be rattled by a challenge. Still, the Knicks have tried to run them off the three-point line, and Duncan Robinson, Max Strus, Gabe Vincent and Caleb Martin will be under pressure from the crowd and the defense.
THE MITCHELL ROBINSON
EXPERIENCE
Robinson took a star turn in the opening round, outplaying Cleveland’s Jarrett Allen and controlling the paint, including an 18-rebound (11 offensive) performance in Game 5. But that was a perfect matchup for him — a player with a similar style, but not as strong and hard-working. Bam Adebayo, a 6-9 center with ballhandling skills, presents an entirely different challenge, and he took nearly as many shots in the 10-to-16-foot range this season as he did at the rim. So Robinson will not only be challenged to chase him but also will have to work in all sorts of screens.
THE CHESS MATCH
Erik Spoelstra and Tom Thibodeau are experienced coaches who will have every bit of the game plan plotted out, their teams drilled for every possibility. And for the Knicks, it not only will be taking advantages of matchups when they are on offense but recognizing the shifting defensive strategies that Spoelstra lays out — particularly the use of a zone, which the Heat did often against the Knicks in the regular season. That will require Grimes to hit the open shots he gets and the Knicks to recognize and pass quickly through the zone. Speaking of quickly . . . Immanuel Quickley often was a one-man zone-breaker this season with his ability to get to the open creases and to shoot from long range. After a quiet offensive series for the first four games, he broke out in Game 5 against Cleveland.
THE PREDICTION
We haven’t had much time to think about this, given that no one could have predicted that these two teams would be meeting in the Eastern Conference semifinals, but here they are, renewing rivalries that are mostly recalled fondly by coaches and executives. Still, it figures to have a little bit of that fire because of the personalities and style of play of both teams — relying on overachievers rather than lottery picks. As great as Butler has been and as well as the Heat played in upsetting the top-seeded Milwaukee Bucks, the Knicks are prepared and familiar with a Heat team missing Herro. Brunson keeps them calm and the Knicks just have too many weapons offensively and enough bodies defensively. KNICKS IN 6.




