Anthony Rieber: Former Yankee Brett Gardner isn't going to make the Hall of Fame, but club could use more players with his intensity
Brett Gardner celebrates a walk-off hit at Yankee Stadium on Aug. 6, 2021. Credit: Jim McIsaac
By all accounts, former Yankees outfielder Brett Gardner was a Hall of Fame teammate and is a Hall of Fame person.
But a Hall of Famer? Probably not.
The question about Gardner’s worthiness for induction among the immortals in Cooperstown was raised this week when he was listed as one of 14 first-timers on the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot.
Gardner spent his entire 14-year career with the Yankees, from 2008 to 2021. He had a batting average of .256 with 139 home runs and 274 stolen bases. He was an All-Star once, in 2015, and won a Gold Glove in leftfield in 2016. Former Yankee Brett Gardner slides into third base during a game against the Rangers on May 20, 2021 in Arlington, TX. Credit: Getty Images/Tom Pennington
In 2017, Gardner won the Major League Baseball Players Alumni Association “Heart & Hustle Award,” the only Yankee to do so since the honor was created in 2005. No one who has worn pinstripes in recent years fits that description more aptly.
He doesn’t have a Hall of Fame resume, not by a long shot. It’s possible Gardner will secure less than the 5% of the vote from eligible members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America, which would knock him off future ballots.
And you know what? It’s OK. Yankees fans still can celebrate the career of an undersized, gritty, gutty player who went from a walk-on at the College of Charleston to a third-round pick by the Yankees in 2005 to a World Series champion in 2009 and a fan favorite whose career spanned the Derek Jeter and Aaron Judge eras.
Jeter was the captain, as Judge is now. As his veteran status grew, Gardner inherited the Jorge Posada role as clubhouse enforcer. Gardner played hard and played the right way and wouldn’t tolerate a teammate who didn’t — something many former Yankees think is missing from the current squad.
CC Sabathia, who was one of the former Yankees who questioned the team’s vibe this offseason, once called Gardner “the heart and soul” of the teams of his era.
Sadly, Gardner has not been seen around these parts since the Yankees chose not to re-sign him for the 2022 season. He has not appeared for an Old-Timers’ Day, even in 2024 when the Yankees honored the 2009 World Series champions, of which Gardner was a bench player.
Even more sadly, Gardner suffered an unimaginable tragedy, the loss of his 14-year-old son Miller on March 21, 2025, after the entire family fell ill at a resort in Costa Rica. Local authorities determined the cause of death was carbon monoxide poisoning. The Yankees hold a moment of silence for Miller Gardner, the son of former Yankee Brett Gardner, on Opening Day at Yankee Stadium on March 27, 2025. Credit: Getty Images/Mike Stobe
The Yankees honored Miller on 2025 Opening Day at Yankee Stadium and some fans wore No. 11 jerseys to show their support for the Gardner family. The Bleacher Creatures ended their first-inning Roll Call by chanting “Miller Gardner!”
The original statement from the Gardners about Miller’s death was issued by the Yankees, indicating the lines of communication between the player and team are not completely closed.
Gardner’s absence from the larger Yankees universe is a shame because he could have been exactly what the team needs if he had gone into coaching after his career ended.
I remember once asking Gardner in the Yankees’ clubhouse if he had ever considered coaching or managing once his playing days were over. He said it wasn’t anything he had thought about yet (he was truly nice about it — didn’t stuff me in a locker or anything).
Gardner was 100% in player mode and wasn’t making any post-career plans. Some athletes go home after they call it a career and immerse themselves in family life. Nothing wrong with that. Former Yankee Brett Gardner yells as he runs the bases after hitting a three-run home in the 9th inning against the Cubs at Wrigley Field on May 5, 2017 in Chicago. Credit: Getty Images/Jonathan Daniel
Still, Gardner’s intensity and drive might have helped him become a great coach or manager. The Yankees happen to have an opening for a bench coach at the moment. See what I did there?
But throwing out names such as Gardner or Posada or Sabathia or Paul O’Neill or David Cone for coaching gigs is a worthwhile effort only if the person is interested, wants to put in the long hours and is willing to buy into (or put up with) the analytics-based atmosphere in today’s game.
The truth is the Yankees probably need someone like Gardner who could get in players’ faces and bring back accountability to the Bronx. But if they wanted that, it already would have happened; the Yankees are more likely to continue with their player-friendly staff under Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone.
Gardner isn’t walking through the clubhouse door to join the coaching staff and isn’t going to get a plaque in Cooperstown. Some fans would like to see him get a plaque in Monument Park or even have his number retired, both of which seem unlikely until Gardner is willing to re-engage with the Yankees.
Even if those honors never happen, here’s hoping Gardner does return someday so fans can have a long-overdue Gardy Party.
