Dave Lennon: MLB appears to be on the brink off a shutdown
Baseball’s nuclear winter isn’t officially upon us just yet. We still have two weeks to go before the current CBA expires on Dec. 1 at 11:59 p.m.
But commissioner Rob Manfred put his finger on the button Wednesday at the conclusion of the MLB owners meetings in Midtown Manhattan, and made it clear that he’s not bluffing about his side’s unblinking resolve to dramatically alter the sport’s economic landscape.
“I can’t imagine the owners ratifying a deal that does not include a cap and floor,” Manfred said.
So before we get to the financials — MLB detailed their latest proposal Wednesday with military precision during a power-point presentation that stretched for 40 minutes — let’s sum up how things stand from a negotiating perspective.
MLB is not doing a new CBA without a salary cap. The union won’t even entertain the concept in discussions.
Buckle up. It’s going to be a while before baseball happens again. And by the sound of things, both sides seem comfortable fighting a long war of attrition that’s going to bleed them of revenue, salary and regular-season games.
I’ve covered five of these labor battles over the course of nearly three decades. Some went more smoothly than others. No games were missed, but the 2021 season was delayed due to a 99-day lockout that wasn’t resolved until March 10, precariously close to wiping out part of the schedule.
All of those negotiations involved tough talk, relentless PR campaigns and questioning the opponent’s motives. Last time, the whole ordeal came down to a high-profile game of chicken.
But now? This feels very different. MLB believes the sport has reached a tipping point, with its entire economic system requiring an overhaul to adapt to a rapidly changing marketplace. During Wednesday’s presentation, which preceded Manfred’s media session, MLB’s executive vice president of baseball operations Morgan Sword — who you may know from the recent social-media missives — outlined how the cap and floor are central to not only usher in a new era of competitive balance, but also creating a new TV model that would increase revenues and make the games more accessible to fans.
Sword explained how the sport’s total revenue would be split 50-50 with the players, and that would tie into a $258.2 million cap and a $180.2 million floor, allowing salaries to be distributed more evenly among the 30 teams. The briefing also contained two slides that surely were radioactive to the union: the first involved limiting free-agent contracts to five years (six to re-sign with current clubs) and a maximum annual salary of $38.7 million ($41.4 million to stay with the same team). Presently, only seven players have ever surpassed that latter AAV, with Tarik Skubal expected to be the eighth this winter.
MLB’s max salaries would increase proportionately with yearly revenues, but you can understand how the union might react violently to those leashes. And that’s exactly what the MLBPA’s interim executive director Bruce Meyer did within an hour of Manfred wrapping up.
“There can be no clearer example of the league’s lack of seriousness than their insistence that they will not negotiate over the economics outside of a radical change to the system that would dramatically reduce overall player compensation for all categories of players and strip fundamental rights from players like the ability to have truly guaranteed contracts,” Meyer said Wednesday in a statement. “There should be no illusions about the owners’ true motivation in pushing for this system. They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries.”
Well, sure. No one would suggest that owners aren’t interested in boosting profit and franchise values. But MLB did bring other measures to the table, like shrinking free-agent eligibility from six to five years of service time — something unthinkable in past negotiations — and boosting the minimum salary to $1 million. MLB also wants to shorten the regular season to 154 games, for the same pay, and extend the playoffs to pump up revenue.
As Meyer mentioned, some are “radical” changes, but there are parts of this proposal that should appeal to the union’s more middle-of-the-pack players, who can see a quicker path to more money. Both Sword and Manfred also insisted they’re acting on a mandate from the sport’s fan base, according to their own surveys.
“There’s plenty of room for compromise,” Manfred said. “But there’s one thing that I will not compromise and that’s the issue that we’re hearing from the vast majority of our fans. They want a salary cap and floor — and on that we will not compromise. We are not prepared to tell 70% of our fans that they’re wrong on this issue. Competitive balance is a serious problem and it needs to be addressed. And it’s one that we can’t avoid just because the negotiation may be difficult.”
Now we’ll see who blinks first. And that won’t be anytime soon. The lockout was inevitable. We’ve known for years that Armageddon was on baseball’s doorstep due to a looming salary cap that MLB now feels equipped to pursue, at any cost, for really the first time in 32 years. Back in 1994, the owners’ attempt to force a salary cap on the players resulted in a strike that killed six weeks of that season, wiped out the World Series, enlisted replacement players the following spring and stretched for 232 days.
No one thought that either side would be willing to risk pushing that doomsday button again. But here we are, back on the brink.
“The 30 clubs are 100% unanimous in support of the proposals that have been made,” Manfred said. “I’m not in a position to speculate about what happens in the event that we don’t achieve our overriding objective, which is to get a cap and floor system that addresses the competitive problem that our fans perceive.”
It’s looking like we’re going to find out.
