Steve Popper: Knicks' Josh Hart bound to turn struggles around

Knicks' Josh Hart reacts during a game against the Celtics on Oct. 23, 2026, in Boston. Credit: Getty Images/Maddie Meyer
Josh Hart expressed his frustration and confusion last week while describing the trouble with his headspace. It was clear on the court that something wasn’t right.
“Wish I could tell you,” Hart told reporters of his troubles after the Indiana loss Friday night in which he missed all four of his field goal attempts and was put on the bench in the fourth quarter. “Don’t know. Right now I’m not in a good headspace, and I’ve got to figure out how to improve that and improve my play. Just mentally, got to be better mentally. Got to figure stuff out.”
He followed that with an 0-for-5 struggle Sunday as the Knicks pulled out an overtime win over Toronto, Hart again sitting nearly the entire fourth quarter and overtime with the exception of a last-minute defensive set.
This is not to diminish any worries Hart is enduring, but the Knicks didn’t sound worried as the team readied to face Toronto again Tuesday night, and maybe you shouldn’t be either.
Hart is the beating pulse of the Knicks, his energy lifting the team through the dog days of the regular season. A reliable factor in the team’s postseason successes, his do-it-all versatility is as valuable as the more heralded scorers on the team.
But he’s also gone through these bouts of openly questioning himself, his role or his production. And the common denominator has always been that a game or two later, he finds himself and, after some performance that keys a win, Hart comes laughing into the locker room and mocks the media for making a big story of his emotions.
In the preseason before the 2024-25 season, Hart didn’t score until the final exhibition game and on the eve of the regular season he said, “I’m lost. I have no idea. There’s a couple days we have until [the regular- season opener]. So whether that’s trying to get a rhythm with that starting unit, or we give somebody else a look and my role changes and [I] come off the bench and go with that unit, just trying to figure out right now; I pretty much have no idea.”
Then, early last season with Mike Brown taking over as head coach and attempting to bring Hart off the bench, the team struggled and Hart struggled. It came to a head after he sat out the fourth quarter of the fifth game of the season.
“I think throughout the season it’ll be a battle of, you know, kind of fighting the egotistical view of it,” Hart said. “I think I did have a good year last year. And, you know, with a different role, now it’s totally different. I think the biggest thing, I’ve had to sacrifice my whole career . . . You know, that’s something that I try to do every year and try to make sure, whether I’ve got to sacrifice or not, make the team the best that we can be.”
But Brown spoke with him, swapped him back into the starting lineup and the rest is history, as the season ended with a parade through the Canyon of Heroes.
“Josh is a pro,” Brown said Sunday night. “And he’s been in this league long enough to understand what he needs to do to continue to get himself back on track because at the end of the day, we need him.
“And he’s a big part of what we do on both ends of the floor. And everybody knows that. And it’s only a matter of time before he works his way out of it. Same thing for everybody else. Mikal [Bridges] was going through it a little and the last couple of games he strung some good ball games together. And I don’t see it any different for Josh.”
The 0-for-9 shooting over the last two games entering Tuesday dropped his shooting numbers to career lows in every category. While Hart was the lowest scorer of the starters last season, he was an efficient weapon when teams attempted to collapse on Jalen Brunson or Karl-Anthony Towns, converting 41.3% from beyond the arc.
Now, he was shooting just 28.9% from three and an unsightly 33.8% overall. Even at the rim he is just 8-for-16 entering Tuesday, after converting 61.8% at the rim last season.
There are understandable reasons for the slump. After a shortened summer with the long postseason run, Hart suffered a calf injury in training camp that limited his work, and he sat out three of the first 10 games — two with ankle soreness and then one with an illness.
Like the rest of his teammates, Hart is using the early part of the season to get in the sort of conditioning he was in last season throughout the playoffs. It takes time and for Hart and the Knicks, they have it. And they also have — maybe the team more than Hart — the belief that it will turn.
