Steve Popper: Why are Knicks keeping Karl-Anthony Towns in contract limbo?

Knicks' Karl-Anthony Towns reacts to a tribute video prior to the start of the a game against the Minnesota Timberwolves on Dec. 19, 2024 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Credit: Getty Images/David Berding
When Karl-Anthony Towns got the word delivered in person at his home in the suburbs of Minneapolis on the final days before training camp three seasons ago, that the team was trading him, it came as a shock.
He believed that his time with the Timberwolves was forever. Even though he grew up in New York and New Jersey, a place that was still home to his family. But in the end, like it often is, even for a player who had been the No. 1 overall selection in the NBA Draft and spent nine seasons with the franchise, it was all about money.
It’s also a lesson worth remembering for the Knicks right now.
For the Knicks right now, with every one of his NBA-leading rebounds or the record-setting streak of double-doubles to start the season, or the smart and skillful assists he hands out unselfishly, it’s hard to not measure every one of those statistics with a dollar sign.
When the Timberwolves were faced with that dollar sign question, they chose to move, dealing Towns to the Knicks even though they’d already agreed to a contract extension, the four-year, $220 million deal that he is in the third year of now paying him $57 million. The final year, next season, is a player option for $61 million.
The Knicks' decision on a new deal for Towns has been far more public than they’d like. Eligible for an extension, he has openly stated that he would take less than the $276 million deal he is eligible to sign, but on the morning of the Knicks preseason opener he expressed his dissatisfaction with where the talks were and the grim reality that he saw the two sides as not close.
That prompted the Knicks to issue a statement days later that there would be no negotiations until later in the season so the team could focus on preparation for the season. That move may have sounded like it was keeping the peace, but it also took away a chance to get Towns to opt into that final year of the contract and build an extension onto it, which could have made the years behind it more tenable to the efforts to remain below the second apron of the salary cap.
So it’s hard not to look at Towns visiting Minnesota and wonder if he might be forcing the Knicks into a hard decision with his play. He has been playing the most efficient and consistent ball of his career, making up for the loss of Mitchell Robinson with his rebounding, shooting as well as he has in his career and orchestrating the offense much of the time from top of circle.
The Knicks reportedly offered $200 million for four years, no small number, but also not in line with what other players of his stature are being paid and it’s hard to justify a pay cut with the way he’s playing. As the Knicks readied to face the Timberwolves Thursday it’s hard to debate that they didn’t win the trade, sending out Julius Randle, who Minnesota already moved on from, and Donte DiVincenzo, a beloved piece of the Knicks building toward the championship, but a player who has been lost to a torn achilles suffered in April.
And the sight of Towns holding the Larry O’Brien trophy as the parade rolled through New York is the real arbiter of the result of the deal.
The other thing is that he’s as low-risk a player as there is off of the court, spending time as an executive in the players association and devoted to his hobby and now side-business of collecting sports cards. He fit into a team that was already built when he arrived.
New York feels like home to him now, but so did Minnesota before he was moved. When the Knicks arrived, he spent Wednesday night hosting a group from HOPEKids, children facing a life-threatening medical condition, for a movie in St. Louis Park. He spoke with the kids and spent time, one family discussing on social media that Towns had done it last year, too, after a delayed flight got him in late.
“It’s great to be home and be back here,” Towns told reporters Thursday morning. “Nine years of my life, some amazing years, amazing moments, yeah, it’s special to be back. Obviously, I thought the other day it’s bittersweet to come back with a championship. I wanted to win it here so bad for the city. For Minneapolis, for Minnesota, for all the people who haven’t seen a championship here, but it’s great to be able to come back and see friends, people I call family here, to eat at my favorite spots. It’s really cool.”
The thing is, New York is home for Towns now, and he has publicly stated that he wants to finish his career at Madison Square Garden, just as he once thought he’d stay in Minnesota forever. But it goes both ways, and the Knicks have to do their part to ensure that he isn’t visiting New York someday talking about how much he loved it before he had to go.
