Nicolas Cage's cartoonish portrayal of John Madden misses on the real-life "Boom!" he brought to the game

Ask any football coach what they despise the most and the answer is going to be losing. Ask what’s in second-place on that list and it’s probably distractions.
Anything that gets in the way of the pursuit of victory is the enemy. Business, in-fighting, media, ego, all of it. Football wouldn’t be the same without those elements, but they are the very ones those inside the gates try with all their might to keep on the other side of the moat.
So it’s more than a little ironic that the new Amazon Prime movie “Madden” about America’s favorite coach-turned-broadcaster-turned-video game pioneer that begins streaming on Wednesday is derailed mostly by a distraction.
In this case it is the cartoonish portrayal of the protagonist by Nicolas Cage. Donning a padded suit that makes him look at times more like Jiminy Glick than John Madden, and trying to mimic the manic gestures that made Madden so endearing- yet somehow coming up short of the real energy with every sweaty take - Cage’s performance tilts more toward buffoonery than homage.
In one scene in which Madden is meeting with the nerdy computer programmers who are designing his soon-to-be released video game, there are complaints about the stiffness and inaccuracies of the two-dimensional pixels on the screen. They don’t look or move like real people.
Hmm. Imagine that.
Cage gets too caught up in Madden schtick and misses the joke, which is that there is no joke. At least there wasn’t to Madden. It was honesty and passion that he delivered. He had fun with it at times, but unlike many of today’s cable sports network stars who drop in and out of character as it suits them, Madden was never acting like Madden. He was Madden.
Cage is more maddening than Madden.
When the teasers for the movie first came out a few weeks ago, the initial reaction to Cage in this role was predictably negative. Many suggested that a more seasoned impersonator like Frank Caliendo should have gotten the part.
But after watching the whole film at a Manhattan advanced screening, what John Madden really needed was less of a caricaturization, not more of one.
It would have been a better movie had it been played straight. No prosthetics, no overly-graveled voice.
There are times when Cage actually does a decent job of capturing the heart of Madden, such as when he spars with Raiders coach Al Davis and regrets it or meets up with a mud-splattered local youth team at a barbecue joint and preaches the importance of having fun. Why they are still in their filthy uniforms at the restaurant is unclear; maybe they just dropped in for the wet naps.

Nicolas Cage, left, as John Madden, and Christian Bale as Al Davis in "Madden." Credit: Prime © Amazon Content Services LLC/Chuck Zlotnick
There is also a touching scene when he goes to see an injured Darryl Stingley who has been left behind at a hospital by his own team. At one point Madden saves Stingley’s life by alerting nurses that the respirator to which he is hooked up has stopped working, likely one of those “not all of this actually happened but it could have” moments the movie warns us about at its opening.
Too bad no one was around to save this movie in the same manner.
The rest of the cast is done up in the same 1970s and 1980s hair and clothing styles that Cage is. That provides some cringy fun, never more than when Christian Bale is playing the rebel owner of the Raiders. He is so deep into that character that there were times I wished I was watching a parallel movie starring him about Al Davis’s life rather than having him as a secondary character in this one. Perhaps in that flick we learn where Davis got his start in football coaching: Adelphi on Long Island. True story!
As far as the football goes, don’t expect a tutorial here. Madden may have been a savant, but most of the Xs and Os that show up here are 101 basics. Pains are given to explaining terms such as “play-action” or “draw” while the rest of it is mostly smart-sounding mumbo jumbo terms that are never dissected and thrown around just to make things seem football-y.
There are nods to the current sport too, some of them inadvertent. A Raiders player waves a pistol around the locker room to illustrate the chaos of the outlaw team, but that hits a little close to home after the incident with Jordan Elliott in Tennessee earlier this season. And the bickering in the press between Madden and his broadcasting partner Pat Summerall early in their partnership has echos that can be heard today while following the likely end of another all-time great booth pairing, Joe Buck and Troy Aikman.

Nicolas Cage and Joel Murray as John Madden and Pat Summerall in "Madden." Credit: Prime © Amazon Content Services LLC/Chuck Zlotnick
Fun cameos by some more up-to-date players -- Marshawn Lynch, Julian Edelman and Chris Long -- give more purposeful nods to the present day state of the game. And quick glimpses of very minor but recognizable characters such as the Moe Howard-coifed current Raiders owner Mark Davis (played by Shane Donovan Lewis) and the exceptionally short and precocious Bob Costas (played by Connor Price) are chuckle-worthy winks.
Ultimately the movie doesn’t know what it wants to be. Is it an SNL skit expanded to feature length or a serious biopic at a Halloween party?
It would have been nice to spend more time in some of the eras and really explore them — Madden’s retirement from coaching and his family dynamics; his relationship with Summerall and the evolution of his on-air style; how he became the king of video games — rather than sprint through them like training camp drills. Instead we’re just given a greatest hits version of his famous commercials, fear of flying, and telestrator sketches. In other words, just like the football acumen, all the things we already know and none of the deeper things we want to know. It’s always going from one "Boom!" to the next "Wham!" while missing the substance that Madden always sprinkled in between his catch-phrases.
By the end of the movie, set in the early 2000s, as Madden is older and grayer and happier, Cage actually starts to look and act more like the Madden we remember. The character and the actor have somehow met in the middle. But at that point the damage has been done and the film is over. Too bad.
It’s hard to come up with someone who has had more influence on today’s game of pro football than John Madden. Players and coaches in the league right now grew up learning the sport not on the field of play but by spending hours dissecting his video game and watching his insightful broadcasts. It’s significant too that this movie comes out now, so close to Thanksgiving, a holiday that football has commandeered. There are five stand-alone NFL games between Wednesday and Friday next week and a big part of that is because of the way Madden served the sport up to us like his beloved turduckens.
As a fan of football’s history and its personalities, though, I would love to be able to sit down and watch a real deep cinematic dive into Madden’s life and what the NFL has become because of him. Maybe somebody can make that movie one day.
Instead for now we are given this sketch-pad scribbled version of an American sports icon who deserves much better from the project — and much less from the actor who portrays him.
