Islanders can still get contributions from Scott Mayfield

Scott Mayfield #24 of the New York Islanders skates during the first period against the Chicago Blackhawks at UBS Arena on Tuesday, Mar. 24, 2026 in Elmont, New York. Credit: Jim McIsaac
This is not to suggest re-inserting Scott Mayfield into the lineup would instantly vault the Islanders toward a Stanley Cup run. This is only to question why the veteran defenseman has seemingly fallen so far off the roster radar.
Because as patient as Mayfield continues to be, it’s become clear management is willing to move on.
But the view here is that Mayfield could still help the Islanders.
“I think they understand that I’ve been around and know the position,” Mayfield told Newsday after Monday’s practice at Northwell Health Ice Center in East Meadow, which indicated he was headed toward being a healthy scratch for the 14th time in 20 games when the Islanders face the Eastern Conference-worst Blue Jackets on Tuesday night at UBS Arena.
“I think I’ll just leave it at that. It’s a business and you can only dress 20 guys each game.”
Mayfield, 34, is in the fourth season of a seven-year, $24.5 million deal that has a full, no-trade clause this season and a modified no-trade clause over the final three seasons. He told Newsday earlier this season he wanted to finish out the contract with the Islanders.
“It doesn’t change much from the last time I spoke,” Mayfield said. “You just stay ready.”
Will Mayfield eventually change his mind and signal he’d be willing to waive his no-trade clause, perhaps before the March 1 trade deadline? Players always want to play. More than money, that is their motivation.
There might not be a path back to playing with the Islanders.
Newsday asked Pete DeBoer following Monday’s practice to cite the main reason Mayfield has not cracked the lineup since Nov. 5.
“All I can tell you is there’s no agenda here other than winning games and we’re going to put the best lineup on the ice that night in order to try and win a game,” DeBoer said. “Those are the decisions we’ve made so far, both on forwards and on defense and in net.”
Granted, Mayfield is limited in his skating speed and DeBoer knows the Islanders must play a fast game to stay competitive in the ultra-quick NHL. But Mayfield, drafted in the second round in 2011, has always brought a defensive presence – albeit sometimes marked by turnovers – and has been a solid penalty killer across his 13 NHL seasons.
Yet Mayfield was eighth on the depth chart when the team had eight healthy defensemen. Now, with Logan Stanley out day-to-day with a lower-body injury, Mayfield is seventh out of seven.
Ben Hutton, signed on Nov. 5 after joining the Islanders on a professional tryout agreement three days earlier, will skate on a third pair with offseason free-agent signee Matt Kessel. Stanley was signed as a free agent on Sept. 27 – three days before the season opener – rather than trust Mayfield with a spot in the opening-night lineup.
“You’ve got to be realistic and know the business,” said Mayfield, who, the last time he played, logged a team-low 8:56 in a 5-3 loss to the Stanley Cup champion Hurricanes at UBS Arena in the second of defenseman Ryan Pulock’s four-game absence with a shoulder injury. “I’ve seen it with different guys. I’ve seen it with young guys. I’ve seen it with old guys. Every situation is different.
“It can be frustrating at times. You want to play. That’s really all it is. The frustration isn’t anything other than you’re not in the lineup. And that’s OK to be frustrated about.”
The 6-5, 215-pound Mayfield has gone without a point but with 12 penalty minutes in his six games while averaging 12:20 of ice time.
“I feel good on the ice,” Mayfield said. “I know the game I need to play. I like my penalty kill and I like what I’ve done defensively on the ice. That’s my main focus. Some games are better than others. The Carolina game was my last one. They’re a hard team and smothering and that was a more difficult game for me.”
Mayfield also logged 15:51 in one of the Islanders’ better efforts, a 4-3 overtime win in Minnesota on Oct. 29 that saw Pulock get injured on his first shift.
Pulock has been Mayfield’s teammate both in the AHL and NHL since being drafted 15th overall in 2013.
“It’s hard but, for him, he keeps his head up and he comes to the rink every day,” Pulock told Newsday. “He puts in the work and he prepares himself to play and be ready every night. Obviously, it’s something new in your career when it happens and it’s not easy to handle. But he’s such a professional that, every day, he shows up and works.”
Mayfield is who he is, and that’s a third-pair defenseman. But he could still help the Islanders in that role.
