With the Rangers' Sean Durzi nearing a return, Mike Sullivan faces tough choices on defense

Rangers defender Sean Durzi skates with the puck against the Utah Mammoth in the third period of an NHL game at Madison Square Garden on Oct. 4. Credit: Kathleen Malone-Van Dyke
When the Rangers returned to the ice for practice Thursday after a couple days off, defenseman Sean Durzi, who has missed the past eight games with an undisclosed injury, was out of the non-contact jersey he had been wearing the past couple weeks. That means he’ll be returning to action soon, perhaps as soon as the next game, Sunday, against the Carolina Hurricanes.
But with the Rangers having won six of their last seven games, and with fill-ins Scott Morrow and Matthew Robertson having played well, what is the best way to reconfigure the defense to accommodate Durzi’s return? Do they even need to put him back in right away?
“I don't think there's any question he makes us a better team when he's in our lineup,” coach Mike Sullivan said of Durzi. “He's just a solid two-way defenseman. He's a mobile guy; he helps us get out of our end; he can move the puck; he goes tape-to-tape (with his passes). He's pretty good along the offensive blue line.”
The simplest way to reintegrate Durzi to the lineup would be to take out Morrow, who had been a healthy scratch for the first 14 games of the season, but stepped in when Durzi went out and has played eight straight games. Morrow and Durzi are both righthanded-shooting defensemen with offensive skill sets, so it would be a like-for-like exchange.
But Morrow has played well, and scored a goal in the last game, Monday’s 3-1 win over Montreal. He has a goal and an assist, and is a plus-4 in his eight games, and taking him out now would seem harsh.
Robertson, a lefty shot, stepped in when rookie Alberts Smits (upper-body injury) came out of the lineup on the recent road trip. He has played the last five games – partnering with Morrow – and has no points and is a plus-2.
But would Sullivan take out the lefty Robertson to open room for Durzi? That would give the Rangers four righthanded defensemen (Adam Fox, Braden Schneider, Durzi and Morrow), meaning one of the righties would have to play the left side.
Sullivan has said multiple times that while he is in favor of forwards playing on their off wing, he’s not keen on defensemen doing that. On Thursday, though, he said he’d be OK with a righthanded D man playing the left side in this situation. Schneider played a handful of games on the left last season; Morrow said he played a lot of time on the left in college, at UMass.
“The question I try to ask myself and our coaching staff is how do we put individual players in a position to succeed?” Sullivan said. “The next question is, what group of players gives us the best chance to win? And if it means somebody's got to play their off side, or somebody's got to play their off wing, or we've got to move someone into a position that maybe they're not as familiar with, or as comfortable with, but we think it gives us the best chance to win… then we'll make those decisions.”
And then there’s the question of who should partner with who, once the lineup is decided. The top pair of Vladislav Gavrikov and Fox will stay together, but would Durzi step back into the second pair, with Marcus Pettersson? Or would Schneider, who has partnered with Pettersson since Durzi went out, stay where he is? In Thursday’s practice, the seven defensemen currently on the roster rotated through six spots, with players taking turns with different partners.
Pettersson and Durzi, who both joined the Rangers in offseason trades, were paired together from Day One of training camp and stayed together until Sullivan switched them up in the Oct. 26 game against the Kings. That was the last game Durzi played before coming out of the lineup. The two got off to a strong start, but their effectiveness faded as Durzi became compromised by whatever injury he was dealing with.
According to Natural Stat Trick, the pair of Pettersson and Durzi has played together at five-on-five for 187 minutes, 28 seconds, and in that time the Rangers have been outscored 7-6, outshot 80-52 (a 39.39 shots-for percentage) and shot attempts have been 169-149 in opponents’ favor, a 46.86 attempts-for percentage.
Pettersson-Schneider has been together for 140:28 at 5-on-5, with goals being 6-5 against, shots 63-58 against (a 47.93 shots-for percentage) and shot attempts being 141-112 (a 44.27 attempts-for percentage).
Pettersson said after building great chemistry early on with Durzi, he’s adapted to playing with Schneider the last eight games, and he thinks however the defense pairs shake out, the Rangers' defense will be OK.
“Whatever we go with, I think we all complement each other very well,” he said.
More Rangers




