Simpson nets OT goal as Sirens spoil Sceptres' chance to move into playoff spot

Toronto Sceptres goaltender Raygan Kirk (1) makes a save as... — Toronto Sceptres goaltender Raygan Kirk (1) makes a save as New York Sirens' Sarah Fillier (10) tries to get her stick on the puck during first period PWHL hockey game in Toronto on Tuesday, April 21, 2026. Credit: AP/Frank Gunn

By The Associated PressUpdated April 22, 2026 10:02 am

TORONTO — Allyson Simpson scored at 2:42 in overtime as the New York Sirens played spoiler in defeating the Toronto Sceptres 1-0 on Tuesday night.

Kayle Osborne stopped 21 shots for New York, which came in three points back of the Sceptres and needed a regulation win to avoid being eliminated from playoff contention.

The overtime result ended the Sirens’ postseason hopes.

Raygan Kirk made 32 saves for Toronto, which remained one point behind the Ottawa Charge for the fourth and final playoff spot.

The Sceptres would have moved past the Charge for that spot with a regulation win, but will instead wait to see Ottawa’s result against Boston on Wednesday. If the Charge win in regulation, the Sceptres will be eliminated.

Toronto did not play with the urgency of a team with a playoff berth on the line. The Sceptres had four shots through 20 minutes and just 10 through 40 minutes. The Sceptres came in with the worst offense in the league, seven goals behind last-place Seattle (58) and the second-worst power play. But coming off a 2-0 win over Minnesota on Sunday on the strength of two power-play goals — a first for the season — Toronto failed to carry the momentum over.

Entering Tuesday, Kirk had three shutouts in her last six starts since March 15 with a .968 save percentage during that stretch. Three of the five goals she allowed in her last six games came against New York in her only start against the Sirens this season.