Google says schools must use AI or lose search: How Long Island parents, schools are reacting

The Google building in New York City. Credit: AP/Seth Wenig
Frustrated Long Island parents advocating for stricter technology limits in schools are pushing back against Google's move to drop its search engine from districts that opt out of its artificial intelligence features.
Starting next year, K-12 schools will be able to individually turn on or off certain Google products — including Gemini, Gemini Notebook and search, with each being off by default unless turned on by school administrators.
But schools that shun AI would automatically lose access to Google’s search engine, which, according to the company, comes with built-in AI features.
The issue has sparked concern about the tech giant’s influence over education and is causing some districts to press for more control over students’ access to AI.
“We feel the dangers of AI being integrated in the schools outweighs the benefits of having Google as the search engine for the kids and our gut instinct is let them use a different search engine,” said Lindsay Berger, founder of the North Shore school district's chapter of Schools Beyond Screens, a national advocacy group.
“I wouldn't cave to Google's demands,” Berger added.
Google said it is giving schools more options while rolling out a new “Guided Learning” experience designed to help students work through academic problems.
“Our goal is simple: provide school leaders the control and confidence to use AI products in classrooms as they see fit,” Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president and general manager of education, said in an online post earlier this month. He said more details would be announced in the coming months as Google continues to tweak its approach with feedback from educators, experts and parents.
Search alternatives
Following Google's announcement, DuckDuckGo, which offers its own search product, said it has received “an influx of administrators reaching out to learn more about switching,” spokesperson Kamyl Bazbaz said in an email.
Bazbaz said the company’s doesn’t track how many users have installed their product, which offers searches without AI.
The Google announcement has prompted the Three Village school district to review its partnership with the company. Deidre Rubenstrunk, the district’s executive director of technology, said its technology committee will be meeting and reviewing Google’s new terms later this month.
Rubenstruck said the district currently uses a separate tool to disable AI features in Google search, but the district is concerned they will lose that ability moving forward and younger children will be exposed to AI before being formally taught by the district.
“Google has a vested business interest in folks using their AI tool, but where that belongs with students is, it still should be in the hands entirely of the district and education professionals and not up to Google,” Rubenstrunk said. She added that she is concerned the AI mode will be turned on for their youngest students, who have not been introduced to the tool.
Marlee Rice, director of technology in the South Huntington district, said they would like Google to give teachers greater control over AI access for students. Currently, Rice said the district is using a product that allows educators more discretion over AI use in specific lessons.
“I think we need more clarity from Google right now, but we would really like to see teacher choice for using AI, specifically for Gemini and Gemini Notebook with students. Not just that once it's enabled, students have access to those tools whenever, wherever,” Rice said.
A Google spokesperson indicated that school administrators will continue to be able to disable or enable AI features for different grades or groups of students.
Cautious but prudent
Kenneth Bossert, president of the New York State Council of School Superintendents and the Great Neck schools superintendent, said most districts on Long island are being cautious but prudent.
“Students will have access to AI within their daily lives so it has to be part of our curriculum to teach responsible use of AI and AI literacy,” Bossert said.
Francesco Ianni, superintendent of the Oyster Bay-East Norwich district, said in a statement that district officials have not received a “tangible update” from the company and are keeping tabs on the situation.
“Until we have clear information from Google and direction from the state, it would be premature to speculate about how this may affect our students or our instructional programs,” Ianni said.
But some parents and experts are worried AI can be misused by students and disrupt learning.
Berger, whose two children, ages 13 and 7, attend schools in Sea Cliff, called it a “very large problem in schools.”
“In addition to issues with cheating and plagiarism and kids using AI to simply write all of their assignments, it's actually having a more pervasive effect in that students are not learning the research, analysis and writing skills that they need for higher education and professional endeavors,” Berger said.
In New York City, where there is a one-year moratorium on student-facing AI in elementary and middle schools, Mayor Zohran Mamdani called out the tech company on X.
“Google is trying to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools. No corporation should have the power to dictate how we teach our children,” he posted.
Alina Vegliante, a member of the Oyster Bay-East Norwich chapter of Schools Beyond Screens, echoed those sentiments, adding, “It’s very telling of our day and age that a corporation can feel so emboldened as to make claims on government-run institutions.”



