The combined compensation for more than 264,000 educators across New York State topped $20 billion in the 2025-26 school year, according to a Newsday analysis of state data. Newsday education reporter Dandan Zou has more. Credit: Newsday Studios

Eight of the 10 highest-paid public school educators in the state worked on Long Island in the 2025-26 school year, with Roslyn’s superintendent topping the list, a Newsday analysis found.

The veteran educator, Allison Brown, received a pay package of $436,975, which included her base salary and unspecified additional pay, according to state data. The second-highest-paid educator was Great Neck schools Superintendent Kenneth Bossert, who earned a total of $420,781.

The 10 highest earners in K-12 schools statewide were all administrators, including nine superintendents and one deputy superintendent. In addition to Bossert, the Great Neck school district had a second administrator in the top 10 — Deputy Superintendent John O'Keefe, with total pay of $375,210.

Financial watchdog groups have questioned whether that money should instead be used elsewhere in the school system, and to achieve better academic outcomes.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • Eight of the 10 highest-paid public school educators in the state worked on Long Island in the 2025-26 school year, according to a Newsday analysis.
  • Roslyn’s superintendent topped the list, with a pay package of $436,975.

  • Supporters argue such compensation packages are necessary to attract and retain talent. Critics argue the money should be used elsewhere in the school system and to achieve better academic outcomes.

“The fact that essentially a bureaucrat and manager is making that type of money is just a negative side effect of bureaucracy,” said Zilvinas Silenas, president of the Empire Center for Public Policy, a conservative-leaning think tank based in Albany.

“Why isn't that money put into achieving better results?” he added. “Why isn't this money put into classrooms?”

But supporters have argued competitive compensation packages attract and retain the talent needed to manage schools that will educate the next generation of doctors, electricians and chief executives. They also pointed to the high cost of living on the Island, where homeowners pay among the highest property taxes in the country.

About two-thirds of a homeowner's property taxes generally go to fund schools, with payroll the single largest expense for districts.

Robert Lowry, senior education finance and policy analyst at the New York State Council of School Superintendents, said superintendents have a wide range of responsibilities, from high-level decision-making over safety and instruction down to whether the cafeteria has enough healthy food options.

Lowry also noted home values are often tied to the quality of the school district.

“The question becomes, ‘How much is all that worth to you?’ ” he said. “Don't you want to make sure that you have a professional leader of your school system who's up to dealing with all those things?”

Total pay on LI nears $6.5 billion

Newsday's analysis was based on figures obtained from the New York State Teachers’ Retirement System through a Freedom of Information Law request. The annual payroll data covers teachers, administrators, guidance counselors and other staffers who worked in the state’s public schools in 2025-26. It also includes some employees of SUNY colleges. New York City schools employees were excluded from the database.

The combined compensation for more than 264,000 educators across New York topped $20 billion last school year, the state data shows. On the Island, total pay for about 68,000 employees neared $6.5 billion.

In the 2025-26 academic year, 79 K-12 and SUNY employees on the Island earned more than $300,000, up from 64 a year prior. Another 1,317 made between $200,000 and $300,000 last school year, up from 1,129 in 2024-25, according to the data.

While SUNY employees were included in the database, Newsday excluded them from the top 10 ranking because salary levels in the statewide university network are not comparable to those set by local school boards.

Island schools chiefs who appeared on the top earners list also include: Francesco Ianni, of Oyster Bay-East Norwich, who received $412,662; Kathleen Bannon in Copiague, with a $389,246 pay package; Kevin Scanlon, of Three Village, with $376,761; Joseph Famularo at Bellmore with $375,771; and Kevin Coster, of William Floyd, with $365,206.

Two additional administrators — interim Webutuck Central schools Superintendent Raymond Castellani in Dutchess County and Amy Creeden, superintendent of Middletown schools — also were on the list. They made $389,356 and $376,701 respectively.

Newsday reached out to all 10 administrators and their respective school board presidents. They either declined to comment or did not respond to requests for comment. Five districts responded with statements and two noted their superintendents' long tenure as reasons contributing to their pay.

In Roslyn, Brown’s base salary for 2025-26 was $363,262. District spokeswoman Cynthia Younker did not say what made up the superintendent’s remaining pay of more than $70,000, but she noted Brown is in her 11th year as superintendent after first joining the district in 2008.

Over nearly two decades in the district, Brown has worked her way up through the ranks, from a principal to an assistant superintendent and later deputy superintendent, according to her biography posted on the district website.

The 3,300-student Nassau district was recently ranked by Niche as the second-best district in the country. Roslyn High School has consistently produced semifinalists in the prestigious Regeneron competition and students in the district have won awards ranging from the region’s math fair to NPR's Podcast Challenge.

Leonardo Nunez Botto, of Flower Hill, believes Brown’s pay was excessive, especially when compared with other districts: “I think it's quite too much money for the superintendent.”

Leonardo Nunez Botto told Newsday he thinks the Roslyn schools...

Leonardo Nunez Botto told Newsday he thinks the Roslyn schools superintendent's salary is excessive. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

Pat Goldstein, of East Hills, however, said she didn’t have an issue with it as long as the district was willing to pay it. Goldstein’s two adult children graduated from Roslyn schools in 2009 and 2013 and she considered the district to have provided a good education to them.

“I was always satisfied with the programs that they had,” she said. “If they can get it, why not? I'm not going to begrudge them.”

Pat Goldstein, meanwhile, was happy with the education her adult...

Pat Goldstein, meanwhile, was happy with the education her adult children received in the Roslyn school district. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

Experience, academic outcomes cited

When asked for comment about the superintendent's pay, William Floyd district spokesman James Montalto cited rising graduation rates under Coster’s tenure and his three decades of experience in education.

Montalto also pointed to the district’s size. William Floyd is one of the Island’s biggest districts with 9,500 students, 1,500 staffers and a budget of $332 million.

“Since assuming the role in 2015, the district’s graduation rate has increased from 79% to 95%, alongside significant improvements in facilities, an upgrade in the district’s bond rating and expanded educational opportunities in Career and Technical Education, science, music, the arts, athletics, and more,” Montalto wrote in an email.

Montalto said Coster’s base salary for 2025-26 was $325,485 and the additional pay of nearly $40,000 came from a payout for unused sick and vacation time at the end of last school year.

Wanda Ortiz-Rivera, superintendent of the Island’s largest school district in Brentwood, which serves 18,000 students, earned $295,155 last school year.

Three Village spokeswoman Denise Nash noted the superintendent's pay figure includes other compensation in addition to Scanlon’s base pay.

Three Village was one of five Island districts that held a revote after residents rejected its initial budget proposal that called for a 4.54% tax levy hike. Voters later approved a lower increase.

Unlike the other superintendents whose gross pay went up, Scanlon was the only one on the top earners list whose compensation stayed the same from 2024-25 to 2025-26.

In Great Neck, a spokeswoman said the pay figures for Bossert and O'Keefe included base pay and contractual benefits. Bossert and O'Keefe could cash in unused vacation days, and O'Keefe was entitled to an annual “longevity” payment of $6,000, according to their contracts. Both had a car allowance: Bossert at $1,000 per month and O'Keefe at $500.

Bossert is also serving as president of the New York State Council of School Superintendents this year. 

Great Neck schools are considered among the best in the state with high graduation rates and proficiency levels.

In Copiague, a statement from the district said the superintendent's compensation “reflects salary, contractual benefits and payouts for earned but unused sick leave and vacation days in accordance with the terms of Dr. Bannon’s employment agreement.”

Bannon has led the district since 2015.

Bettianne Balzano, who has lived in Copiague for 27 years, said she found Bannon’s total pay to be “ludicrous.”

“It's unfortunate because I think that our taxes are so exorbitant,” she said. “And it's a shame. We live in a beautiful place and I love it here. But a lot of people are being taxed out of here.”

Bettianne Balzano took issue with the superintendent's compensation.

Bettianne Balzano took issue with the superintendent's compensation. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

Jessica Dejesus, a mother of two, took a different view.

Dejesus said she had moved from Brooklyn to Long Island for a better life for her children and she has been pleased with the education her two kids, 9 and 16, received from the Copiague district.

“I really do feel like it is a better life out here,” she said. “The taxes for me personally, I can't speak [for] everyone else, is worth it for my kids to have a better life. And as far as their schooling, they are excelling in school.”

Jessica Dejesus said her two children are excelling in the...

Jessica Dejesus said her two children are excelling in the Copiague district. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME