DEAR AMY: I am an only child and recently married. My husband has a sister who has two children. One is a toddler and the other is in elementary school. My husband and I agree that the Christmas spending tradition has been overblown and that even though we are financially stable we do not want to participate in gift exchanges with family and friends. We've also agreed that when we have children gift-giving will not be a part of our holiday celebrations. Recently, we communicated our decision to family and friends. We explained that while we want to celebrate the holiday with everyone, in lieu of gifts we will be making additional donations to charity. My sister-in-law vehemently disagrees with our stand. She complains that we are "ruining Christmas" for everyone, in particular her children (to whom my husband previously gave gifts each year). My husband says we should make an exception for children (even though he agrees that if we had our own children it would be OK not to give them gifts). Do you have any advice on how to respond to my sister-in-law or how to persuade my husband to hold firm to our otherwise agreed-upon beliefs? 
 --Not A Scrooge! 
 DEAR NOT: You and your husband are from small families, so even if you chose to give gifts, the burden would not be too great. But I get it -- it's the principle of the thing. 
 I like your idea of taking the materialism out of the holiday, though you do sound like a humorless Scrooge. Your sister-in-law is wrong to accuse you of "ruining" anything. And what if your husband decides to continue to give gifts to these children? Will you permit him? One way to celebrate without giving material gifts would be to start a tradition involving the extended family. You could treat the kids to a holiday concert or a production of "A Christmas Carol." You cannot control other people.

DEAR AMY: I am an only child and recently married. My husband has a sister who has two children. One is a toddler and the other is in elementary school. My husband and I agree that the Christmas spending tradition has been overblown and that even though we are financially stable we do not want to participate in gift exchanges with family and friends. We've also agreed that when we have children gift-giving will not be a part of our holiday celebrations. Recently, we communicated our decision to family and friends. We explained that while we want to celebrate the holiday with everyone, in lieu of gifts we will be making additional donations to charity. My sister-in-law vehemently disagrees with our stand. She complains that we are "ruining Christmas" for everyone, in particular her children (to whom my husband previously gave gifts each year). My husband says we should make an exception for children (even though he agrees that if we had our own children it would be OK not to give them gifts). Do you have any advice on how to respond to my sister-in-law or how to persuade my husband to hold firm to our otherwise agreed-upon beliefs? --Not A Scrooge! DEAR NOT: You and your husband are from small families, so even if you chose to give gifts, the burden would not be too great. But I get it -- it's the principle of the thing. I like your idea of taking the materialism out of the holiday, though you do sound like a humorless Scrooge. Your sister-in-law is wrong to accuse you of "ruining" anything. And what if your husband decides to continue to give gifts to these children? Will you permit him? One way to celebrate without giving material gifts would be to start a tradition involving the extended family. You could treat the kids to a holiday concert or a production of "A Christmas Carol." You cannot control other people.

News

LSAMY08

Let the Christmas gift debate begin!

Newsday

Homepage Trending

Halloween events on LI

Deported: Immigration on LI

Wallet Watch

Working moms

NEWSDAY TV SHORTS

Vertical videos

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano has your look at what to know ahead of the 2026 Oyster Festival.

What to expect at this year's Oyster Fest

Billy Joel will be auctioning off more than 70 motorcycles at Gooding Christie's in Manhattan next month. NewsdayTV's Andrew Ehinger got a sneak peek at three.

A sneak peek of Billy Joel's motorcycles going to auction next month

Marine life experts said two juvenile humpback whales became stuck due to sandbars created in last month's nor'easter. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa has more.

2 whales stranded on LI

The firefighter says her free speech rights were violated. The case demonstrates the depths of the divisiveness of politics in America today. NewsdayTV's Andrew Ehinger reports.

LI fire department removes volunteer after Facebook comment about ICE

The Mineola High School marching band and wind ensemble have been invited to perform at London's New Year's Parade in 2028. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie has more.

LI High School marching band to perform in London New Year’s Parade

NewsdayTV's Doug Geed heads to Seven Ponds Orchard in Water Mill where you can pick crisp apples, gather garden-fresh veggies, and let the kids burn off some energy at one of the island's largest playgrounds.

Out East: Seven Ponds Orchard

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano visits Das Biergarten in Long Beach.

It's Oktoberfest every day at this Long Beach restaurant

Stuart Cameron, now the chief of the Old Westbury Police Department, said "The Long Watch" began as an attempt to share his experiences during 40-plus years in law enforcement with his children and grandchildren.

Chief Stuart Cameron talks new book 'The Long Watch' and Gilgo investigation

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa visits Bisqo in Hicksville to try the Miso Overload, a Dubai-inspired creation which combines a frappe with a slice of tiramisu.

 Trendy Bites: Have your frappe with a slice of tiramisu on top

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano tries a crafty coffee at The Caffeinated Bunny in Melville.

Coffee cart opens at Melville flower shop

<a href="https://www.newsday.com/video/newsdaytv-top-stories">Get more on these and other NewsdayTV stories</a>

Newsday TV

NewsdayTV Top Item

NewsdayTV's Doug Geed is heading 'Out East' to showcase the ultimate local spots you need to explore.

Out East Show: Visit The Shamrock evergreen maze, Sannino Vineyard, Seven Ponds Orchard and the Warrior Ranch Foundation

News - megaslot

Newsday has the most up-to-date stories on Long Island & NTC. Join us & stay current with news articles on sports, business, health, technology & more.

Stay logged in.